Okay so regarding the “prima nocte” thing Tony cracks in AoU… I have to admit it was a huge WTF? moment for me the first time I heard it, and my gut reaction was just Tony, no, that’s horrible! And I think I’m not at all alone thinking he would never do anything like that. It’s a (kind of nasty) joke and that’s it.
But then I started thinking that every joke is based in some kind of truth…
(And the rest of my thoughts on this will be pretty spoilery so keep away from the cut if you don’t want any of that.)
I think this joke was too. Not because I think that Tony actually would do that, though. Of course he wouldn’t! I mean it would be basically institiuting a law that gives him personal freedom to rape people. We can all agree he wouldn’t, right?
But what if he doesn’t agree? What if he thinks, somewhere deep inside, that he could be capable of doing something that? What if he thinks that he is that kind of person?
Scarlet Witch tells Steve that Tony would do anything to set things right, and that he doesn’t know the difference between saving the world and destroying it. I think she is at least partially right. As Tony himself tells Banner, he sees himself as a monster. He desperately wants to save the world and he feels like it’s still all falling through his fingers, no matter how good his intentions. (”The end of the path I started us on.”)
So yes, I still think prima nocte is a joke - but I also think it says something about Tony’s view of himself in this story.
Or I’m just reading too much into it…
(Gonna tag arvensis5 just because we talked about it earlier.)