Review: The Broken Earth Trilogy
Opening Line: ‘Let’s start with the end of the world, why don’t we?’
So previously I reviewed the first book in this trilogy, The Fifth Season. I recently got to reread book one and then read straight through books two and three, so it seemed to make more sense to review the whole thing as a trilogy.
The problem is, every time I sit down and try and string together some sentences, I just end up making vague gestures at my computer screen.
Friends, this trilogy is overwhelmingly, jaw-droppingly good.
It’s actually really hard to be articulate, because I just kind want to run around yelling? Or fill this whole review with keysmash. But I’ll try. I’m trying. I promise.
The story is set on a continent (country? Landmass of some kind?) called the Stillness. This is an extremely sarcastic name, because Stillness has a vast amount of tectonic trouble. Low-level quakes are pretty common. And every so often, their world enters what they refer to as a Fifth Season: basically a near-apocalyptic event. Sometimes volcanic, sometimes an earthquake or a tidal wave, sometimes a combination, sometimes all of the above. Humans retreat during these times and survive as best they can until the fifth season ends, then (mostly) rebuild civilisation from scratch.
One thing seems to survive down the ages, and that’s a deep hatred of Orogenes. These people have the ability to detect and control tectonic activity (a simplified explanation, but it’ll do). So they’re deeply necessary but also treated with very little trust.
In the middle of all of this we have Essun, and Damaya, and Syenite. Damaya is a young girl discovered to be an Orogene, on her way to the Fulcrum where Orogenes are trained to both use their ability and obey without question. Syenite is an adult working for the Fulcrum, finding out that the world is not quite what she thought it was. And Essun… Essun is living out her own private apocalypse in the middle of a very real one.
That’s about as much as I can explain without getting too detailed or two spoilery. But a list of other things found in this trilogy: stunningly good writing; complex but well-revealed world-building; a trans secondary character; multiple non-straight relationships; a polyamorous three; people made of stone; a surprising but brilliant use of perspective; a wealth of well-written female characters. Jemisin keeps a precise balance between an intensely personal story and one at a scale almost beyond description. Not to mention that she manages to write about a brutal world where characters go through some awful things without ever making her reader miserable – I never felt worn-down by the story, just absolutely enraptured.
Please read this trilogy, folks. I need more people to talk to about it!
One of the best fantasy series of all time. 5/5.
You might enjoy this book if you enjoyed: The Realm of the Elderlings (Robin Hobb), Strange the Dreamer (Laini Taylor), The Black Prism (Brent Weeks).
Check out the rest of my reviews here!