I AM BACK ONCE MORE BRAINROT ANON HERE okay so, I saw the post of what the other anon said abt how dsmp members would react to K! Quackity and how Karmaland members would react to Dsmp! Quackity and I wanna give my two cents.
Now, because karmaland quackity is pretty much the embodiment of chaos they'd probably react the same as they did when quackity first joined the dream smp server. Tommy would most likely be happy to see the old Big Q but weary and on guard (given what he's been through and how C! quackity is now) and everyone else would be confused or concerned in a sense. C!Wilbur would most likely be amused and chill about the whole thing.
Now Karmaland reacting to dsmp quackity. Luzu would probably be heartbroken or disappointed in a sense to see what quackity is like in this other timeline(also saddened because he cares a lot about K! Quackity like a little brother and it hurts him to see him like this or that he could potentially become like this). Rubius and the others would probably be surprised and question him as to what happened to him. Anyone can add on to this! (Mainly the karmaland part as I can't speak Spanish for the life of me and only know a bit).
Hello my lovely brainrot anon!
I think indeed if they switched places right now, the members of the dsmp would remember the old dsmp!Quackity more, but I think k!Quackity is a little bit more of a survivor than dsmp!Quackity in the Earlier streams (clarifying) cause in the first three he was on little armour in dsmp (he got like netherite the second stream but that was a gift ) and even if he started dying a lot in Karmaland now k!Q is better so going from moded with a bunch of dangerous mobs to a Vanilla server I see it like more easy in a way. And in the few Karmaland streams he seems almost always with someone and even if they get in a fight is quickly resolved cause they have to trust eachother to a certain degree cause they are a team in the end, and they have to save Karmaland. So I think k!Q will show signs to be a team player and that will confuse even wilbur.
With dsmp!Quackity coming to Karmaland I think he would be quite baffled like first you have all this dangerous things and just trust people to NOT use them? People having pets, and house's close to each other like there is no threat. And them the people, you can be revived if you are down, the first time he dies cause he didn't expect a mob to be that strong he is silently furious that he is dying because of that, but k!Luzu saves him, and he is like Great now I am in debt, but no, k!Luzu keeps taking care of him like he did with k!Q and he doesn't understand k!Luzu is just sad that something so simple like trust and friendship is not something dsmp!Quackity has right now. K!Rubius will be sad but will try to joke and end in an argument with dsmp!Q cause he is so different from the other and just...And an interaction that I think would be gold is dsmp!Quackity meeting Vegetta the most close thing to an admin, and somehow feeling like he has to take a stance but Vegetta is just talking about his house and things and joking around with rubius who exploded his house and he just remebers dsmp!Q that can just use his ilegal chainsaw with wood instead of just getting rid of the item like, this men who is fussing about the simmetry of his home is the most close thing to an admin.
I HAVE to say the true, I am not so deep in the lore of dsmp anymore (in general long english streams are a bit difficult for me) so if I got the characters wrong I am sorry, I am going with my gut.
AND IF YOU HAVE ANOTHER OPINION, SHARE! All with respect <3