Quarant-ween movie #7: As Above, So Below
This is a movie guaranteed to dig up that claustrophobia you didnât know you had. The Paris catacombs make for a naturally spooky setting, but itâs not the unquiet dead that provide the major scares- itâs those tunnels, their tight fits, the lack of sunlight and fresh air, and the ever present fear of a collapse that will make you hold your breath. Though the visions and ghosts and cultists donât make things any easier.
Scarlett, an Indiana Jones type, is determined to find the philosopherâs stone somewhere below the grave of Nicholas Flamel (the writers presumeably counting on a whole generation of media-consumers knowing who Nicholas Flamel was.) Together with a cameraman, a reluctant friend, and a team of urban explorers, they set out to uncover what has not seen light in hundreds of years. But the path keeps going down long after they should have hit the bottom- and why is an old landline telephone ringing beneath the earth, anyway?
The first half of the movie is extremely Lovecraftian without even a single tentacle in sight, as Scarlett digs into ancient languages and forbidden tombs to uncover clues about the mystery that drove her father to his death. Once we go beneath the catacombs, it feels more like a nightmare session of Dungeons and Dragons (Tomb of Horrors, anyone?), complete with a player complaining that it makes no sense for his character to be going down there.
Iâd like to commend the movieâs atmosphere, scares, and characterization (Scarlett starts off as brash and selfish but displays true heroism by the end), but most of all Iâd like to commend it for playing fair. You know what I mean- horror movies are fond of setting up rules and then demolishing them in the name of a last-frame scare. Not this one. Once the rules are set, theyâre set. That means itâs possible to work with the rules and maybe even escape- but thatâs only if you donât get killed before you work them out. Even playing fair, itâs still a dangerous playing field.
If I have a complaint about this movie, itâs that it didnât really gain anything from the found footage style. Iâm not opposed to found footage horror, but I feel like it should contribute to the movie as more than an aesthetic choice- Paranormal Activity relied on the footage to capture things that happened while the protagonists were asleep, while What We Do in the Shadows drew dark comedy from the fact that a full camera crew waltzed into a vampire masquerade party and expected to go unnoticed. It doesnât detract from As Above, So Below, but it doesnât add anything either.
Overall, though, this is a tightly crafted descent into hell. And once you get out, a gasp of fresh air never felt so good.














