Test of Timeline
It was an entirely ordinary day, and perhaps that was what gave Marinette the most reason to be on edge. She was in her room, deep into one of her next projects while she waited for a call from Adrien concerning their next date. Tikki was sitting nearby, munching on a cookie and watching idly.
Life was... complicated, and nothing Marinette did ever seemed to change it. Being Ladybug was as exhausting as ever regardless of having other heroes to help, juggling her hobbies to a point she was comfortable with continued to be difficult, and the secrets she felt she had to keep weighed heavily on her mind. That was simply how things were and she'd tried to accept that it wasn't going to change.
As she was working at her desk, she caught sight of a light reflecting off her computer's black screen. Alert, she stood up and turned around to face it, shouting before anything came into her room, “Tikki, transform me!”
She wasn't even half-transformed when she realized what it was - Bunnyx's portal - and memories she always tried to bury came rushing back to her. Visions of Paris underwater, of the very timeline itself in danger, and her needing to fix everything or else hit all at once.
However, the one who came through the portal was not Bunnyx, much to her shock, but herself using the rabbit and ladybug together. She was taller, older, and had longer hair, sure, yet the way she came out with such speed and panic could only have been her.
The older Marinette swiped her arm up behind her to close the portal, her other hand in a fist against her chest, then stumbled across the room towards her younger self. She was panting, exhaustion vivid in her wide eyes as her hand came down on the younger's shoulder, squeezing it so desperately that it hurt.
It was as if all the pain in her future self's expression was being transferred directly to her. The other Marinette couldn't even speak when she tried, her eyes shutting tight and she struggled to get back enough air to say something to her.
The mask across her face appeared to be having its limits tested as her brows soared high, and her mouth could only force out two words: “Save us.”
Ladybug stared in horror, waiting for an elaboration, but it didn't come. Instead, she saw the consciousness start to leave her other self's gaze, eyes rolling up and legs giving out below her.
With the extra strength given by the ladybug miraculous, Ladybug could easily support the weight falling against her, though the horror kept her unnerved enough that her own unsteady legs stumbled back. Her body hit the desk behind her and she heard a distinct tink sound, indicative of something having fallen to the floor, but she ignored it to focus on her future self.
She was given almost no information, yet her brain felt overloaded. Where was Bunnyx? Why would her future self come all by herself? Was the timeline in danger?
No answer could come without waiting for the unconscious Marinette to wake up, however. Needing someone else to talk to in that moment, she cried out, “T-Tikki! Detransform me!”
The light washed over her, and the strength went with it. She didn't fall over, but had to slowly maneuver herself down to the floor. Tikki, though wide-eyed at the two Marinette, awkwardly tried to assist by grabbing at any loose fabric the future Marinette had and flying upwards.
Sitting on the floor with her future self against her, heart pounding anxiously at everything she didn't know, Marinette asked no one in particular, “What happened...?”
Tikki didn't have an answer, but looked over at something Marinette couldn't see. She blinked, staring like she wasn't quite sure what she was looking at, then gasped, “M-Marinette! Look—!”
She directed a paw in the direction that Marinette had heard the sound before. As Marinette turned to look at it, she noticed that the hand her future self had kept against her chest had fallen open on the floor.
It was clear what had tumbled out when she saw that the black cat miraculous was lying not even a meter away from them.
——-
Marinette didn't move for a long time. If she retransformed or put in the extra bit of effort, she probably could've moved her future self somewhere more comfortable, but the mental weight kept her down more than the physical.
Tikki, meanwhile, silently hovered around the two in worry.
Marinette touched her future self's cheek, noting that she still looked troubled while unconscious. She tried to imagine how long whatever led to this had gone on for; if there would've been dark circles under those closed eyes without the mask.
“...Mnnn,” the future Marinette whined, her breath visibly picking up again as she stirred. She swallowed, her eyelids opening slowly at first and taking in her present self. There was a pause, then her eyes widened as she pulled herself back. “Sorry!”
If Marinette wasn't already sure that this was her from the future, she was now.
"You're... me, right?" she asked anyway, pointing at the both of them. "From the future?"
Her future self nodded, though was in the middle of massaging her temple, probably from getting up so fast. "Yeah." She smiled weakly, eyes surveying the room semi-warily. "You can call me Nette if that's easier. Thankfully, it looks like nothing's going to happen for now."
“...R-right.” Marinette tensed, not feeling reassured in the slightest. Raising a hand towards where the portal had been, she questioned, “And, uh... what would've happened if nothing wasn't what happened just now? You came here in such a rush.”
'Nette' looked exhausted all over again, her hand hovering over the pocket where Marinette assumed the rabbit watch was. Gaze wandering to the black cat ring on the floor as well, she admitted, “I had to. I had to get away with them before anyone could stop me.”
Shocked, Marinette leaned forward, her hands on the floor in front of her for support. “Bunnyx and Chat were compromised?!”
“Ha,” Nette let out, but there wasn't any joy nor concern in it. Rather, she looked resigned. “No, unless it counts if they were compromised to me. You already know who Bunnyx is anyway.”
There weren't any words that could come to Marinette's mouth right then. She had to cycle through what she'd just heard several times to confirm what'd been said, at which point she pushed herself up off the floor to stand up. She didn't have the room to back away due to the desk, but she wanted to.
Tikki had the questions Marinette couldn't bring herself to put forward, flying at Nette with a raised voice to ask, “You took their miraculouses?! Why?! How could you—”
“Marinette.”
Ignoring Tikki entirely, Nette slid herself towards Marinette to keep herself lower than her. Reaching out, she took Marinette's stiff hands in her own and squeezed, her sad eyes and furrowed brows conveying regret and conflict all at once.
Staring up at her, she pleaded, “Hear me out, please. I'm not going to pretend like this'll be easy to process - none of it will be - but everything will make sense if you just listen."
Her grip was strong. At the same time, Marinette felt she could've pulled away if she wanted to, yet she couldn't bring herself to do so. It wasn't so much about curiosity, but that Nette's expression seemed as if the world might end if she didn't.
She recognized that face - the feeling of being alone, yearning so dearly for someone to rely on - and she hated that she did. She'd finally stood up to her bully of many years due to having to take charge as Ladybug, and had kept telling herself all this time that she would keep moving forward in that direction if she was willing to deal with the struggle. What doesn't kill you and all that.
Yet, the woman in front of her didn't appear like someone who'd come out of a fire with skin made of stone; it was someone who'd emerged with visible burns and was still dealing with the pain.
“...Okay,” she uttered, scared yet feeling like it was the right decision to go along with it.
Nette smiled gratefully. “Thank you. Really.”
Marinette freed a hand so she could wave her off - it felt weird being thanked by herself - then helped Nette up so they could go across the room together. They sat in the seating area in front of the window, and Marinette could tell that her future self hadn't been there in a while from how awkward she seemed and the way she looked around. The idea that Nette might feel nostalgic like she thought so fondly of not-so-simple “simpler times” was unnerving.
“Marinette,” Tikki called out, flying towards the two warily. “I don't like this. What if this is a trap?”
Not looking at her, Nette pointed out, “You sense yourself, don't you? So you know I have the real ladybug miraculous. If I wanted to make a wish, I wouldn't have bothered coming here, would I?” Then, without waiting for an answer, she turned to Marinette and said, “Tikki should leave.”
“Why?” Marinette wondered, conflicted as she looked back and forth at the two.
“Yeah, why?” Tikki echoed. “If this is so dangerous...”
Nette finally made eye contact with Tikki, but it wasn't friendly. “This is a guardian-to-guardian discussion. It's not for kwami to hear.”
That was when Marinette realized: Nette hadn't detransformed since she'd arrived. She bit her lower lip, able to tell that there'd be no backing down from this either. Addressing Tikki, she said, “There's cake in the fridge downstairs.”
Crossing her arms, Tikki pouted, but both Marinette remained firm. Relenting to the suggestion, she turned around and headed off by phasing through the floor.
Nette sighed, a noticeable amount of tenseness leaving her shoulders. “It wasn't a complete lie. We're guardians and this is a Marinette-to-Marinette talk.” She grinned self-deprecatingly. “Isn't that terrible? We hate lies, but we've just gotten used to telling them when it's convenient.”
Marinette shifted uncomfortably, unable to say anything to that. She'd hoped at some point in her life that she either wouldn't have to lie anymore or it wouldn't hurt so much if they were “necessary lies.”
That hope shattered once she realized who Monarch was, and who she would have to keep it from.
“You asked what might've happened if nothing happened before,” Nette began. She sat back against the wall, staring up at the ceiling with a frown. “Marinette, the universe is falling apart.”
“What...?” She put a hand to her chest, struggling to imagine that concept. “H-how? How does the universe just—fall apart? When did it happen?”
Clasping her hands together on her lap, Nette continued, “I don't know exactly when, but definitely before we were born. It's been going on forever, and we never realized it.”
“Forever?” Marinette recoiled, having expected it to be something that took place in the future. “Then—what did it? What do we need to do to stop it?”
“That's just it,” Nette replied with a shrug. “I don't know how to stop it, and what caused it just comes from everything I've considered so far. It's the only explanation that makes sense, but it'll be hard to prove to anyone but you.”
In other words, she'd gone to the past to talk it out with another Marinette, because two heads were better than one even if that head was your own from the past. Perspectives and thought processes changed with time, Marinette supposed.
“A-alright, wow," she muttered, rubbing her cheek anxiously. She took a breath, trying to mentally prepare herself for whatever her future self was about to drop. “I...I'm ready, I think. What's your theory?”
“Before I answer, I want to ask you a question,” Nette told her. She paused, gaze dropping to her pocket. “Didn't you ever find Bunnyx's existence weird?”
“Bunnyx?” Marinette tilted her head. “No? What about her?”
“Time only exists all at once in the rabbit's portal, but the past has to exist first for the future to happen. That's obvious, right?” A small nod came as the reply. “Then what about Chat Blanc?”
The mere mention of Chat Noir's akumatized form made Marinette's throat tighten up. She massaged her neck, eyes wavering at the memory.
Only able to offer her a sympathetic look and a pat on the shoulder for comfort, Nette continued, “That couldn't have happened in this timeline without a Bunnyx to stop it, or neither of us would be here right now. So the question becomes—” She gestured towards the rabbit ears atop her head. “—when did Bunnyx happen?”
Marinette started to answer, as the present Alix was Bunnyx even now, but then the paradox hit: not only was there no Bunnyx by the time Chat Blanc happened, but the Alix of that time would've been dead along with everyone else. By that logic, that nightmare of a timeline should've been the end of her life, unless someone from the past had somehow sensed something amiss and approached her instead. The fact that it was a Bunnyx from the future...
Nette nodded at her, seeing the thought play out without it needing to be voiced. Raising her index finger, she stated, “There had to be a timeline where it never happened for you to meet her.” Then, she raised the index finger of her opposite hand as well. “Now we're here, in a timeline that's not supposed to exist.”
“That doesn't make sense!” Marinette shouted, unwilling to believe it. “Like you said, we're here, aren't we?”
“Gabriel Agreste made a wish,” Nette reminded her, crossing her legs, “and you know what happens when people make a wish. If it was as simple as trading the last few - what, hours? - of his life and whatever Emilie had to bring Nathalie back to full health, then you wouldn't have seen that light. Reality itself has to be rewritten whenever a wish is made: the universe is destroyed and created all over again to fit that wish, supposedly.”
Remembering Chat Blanc and when it took place, Marinette argued, “Adrien's dad made the wish after... what happened.”
“I didn't say it was his wish,” Nette pointed out. She pushed herself up, walking over to the black cat ring that was still on the floor. Picking it up, she turned to Marinette and showed it to her. “People have been making wishes since these have been created, and I think Master Fu was wrong. When he explained it to us, he said that someone would've lost their humanity to give Markov humanity, but there's no such thing as an equal trade when it comes to wishes. If it was the other way around and it was someone willing to lose their humanity to give it to someone else, is that fair? They're both getting what they want, so there wouldn't be any downside then, would there?”
Doing her best to follow along, Marinette admitted, “I...I don't know?”
“And if someone a wisher doesn't know dies so someone they care about is brought back, then that's not equal either.” Nette held up the ring, turning it around to examine it. “The game has always been rigged, against us and the kwami. The butterfly miraculous ended up in someone else's hands, and I bet that's not because of the wish.”
“What—” Marinette had to stop to inhale, realizing that she hadn't been breathing. “What do you mean...?”
“These...these things,” Nette scoffed, holding the ring at arm's length like it disgusted her, “are a prison. Kwami have to obey their masters and we treat it like it's normal. They need us to be able to use their powers without causing a disaster, and they don't have a choice if someone wants to make a wish. If you're the villain, isn't that system practically made for you?”
Marinette said nothing, but the horror was slowly settling onto her face. She covered her mouth with a hand.
“And it can't be that easy to rewrite our universe either; not without leaving things behind.” Outstretching her arm towards some paper and writing utensils resting on the nearby desk, Nette stated, “When we erase our sketches, there's always something left. Maybe it's the effort we had to put into getting rid of it, or our memory of what was there before, or the eraser getting worn down.”
Marinette began to understand the concept from there. The logic behind time travel, when it came to the rabbit, often eluded her to the point where it seemed better not to think about it at all, but the metaphor of an artist's sketch was easy enough to grasp. Perhaps even more apt, the more she considered it, would've been an author writing a story.
The words on the page were time itself, the last word on the page was the present, and everything before was the past. As for the future, considering the phrase about it not being "set in stone," it was the fluid nature of a writer's thoughts of what they wanted to write, but hadn't written yet. Time travelers could access that future, but it was more pliable and likely to change than the past or present.
Whenever a wish was made or a time traveler affected the timeline, it was equivalent to the writer going back and erasing some of the words they wrote, then rewriting something in its place. One could see the faint outline that something was there before, barring cases like Chat Blanc where they weren't just "changed" but erased in full.
So deep in thought that she was unable to look at her future self, Marinette said behind her hand, “You're saying that no rewrite is perfect. You can't destroy everything without anything left over.”
“Exactly.”
“...Someone made a wish,” she concluded, starting to piece everything together herself. “I mean, there were a lot of wishes, and our universe got worse with every one of them, but Chat never got akumatized in the timeline before this new mystery wish. In the, uh—first timeline we don't remember, we gave Alix the rabbit miraculous at some time, somewhere, then that wish happened, and it changed everything enough for Chat Blanc to happen in this new timeline.”
Then came the obvious question: who? Who would make a wish, what had crumbled in the process, and what would've been left behind to prove it?
Just as she went to voice any of those, Marinette heard a shuffling noise that made her look up. Nette had retrieved her diary and phone, balancing the latter on the former so she could still hold onto the ring. She returned to Marinette's side to sit down next to her again, a solemn look on her face.
Marinette had a terrible feeling, even worse than everything that'd come before.
“I know you remember, because I can't forget either,” Nette said. ”What did Chat Blanc say was the cause of all that destruction?”
It came back to her so easily, because of course she couldn't forget. He'd said it was their love that...
“...No.” Marinette shook her head aggressively. “I-I wasn't—not back then! Now I'm even dating—“
Raising the hand with the cat miraculous, Nette curled her fingers around it to keep it in her fist. “I'm sorry. It all adds up when you put together what I know... and who he is.” Her face was apologetic, pitying even. “Like father, like s—”
“No!”
Marinette stood up, physically putting distance between the two of them. She shut her eyes and clamped her hands over her ears, pacing around the room that suddenly seemed too small.
“I can't hear you!” she yelled. “Adrien isn't Chat Noir, and he wouldn't do that! It's something else, it has to be!”
The only thing she could hear then was the panicked pounding of her heart and her own rapid breathing. A hand grabbed hold of her arm, but she struggled against it, crying out when she tried to pull away and her side hit the table.
“Marinette!” Nette called out desperately, managing to pull Marinette's arms apart so she could hear her again. “I know, I know you don't want to believe it! I'm you, don't you think I did everything I could to come up with any other explanation?!”
All that escaped Marinette at first was a pathetic squeak. Her future self seemed to loom over her like the reality being offered to her, and she couldn't get away from it. She could only do her best to fight back, fists tight as she wrenched her arms away. “So—so what then? What would he even wish for?!”
Nette, seeing how on edge she was, stepped back. “...I can't say for sure.”
“See?! So how can you—”
“Because no one can know, not even him,” she cut in. “He had to have reset time, and that affected the future that you—that we had.”
This was all going somewhere, and it wasn't anywhere good. Marinette could practically sense it, which left her completely on edge.
"You think we weren't in love," she ground out, still shaking. "That's why what happened with Chat only happened here."
Nette stared at her tenderly, then made her way back to the window seat. Gesturing to it, she told her, "Come on, sit back down."
Marinette didn't respond, standing stubbornly in place as a refusal.
Nette sighed, but didn't force her. "I don't think we were in love before, no." She hesitated, eyes taking in Marinette's already-rigid stance on this before adding, "I don't think we're in love now either."
Marinette's head tipped up, gaze narrowed. "Stop it."
It was hard to say whether it was a threat or a plea, but Nette continued on regardless.
"Adrien is a sentimonster. He was created using the peacock miraculous. There's a reason he's as pretty as he is, and I'd bet it's the same reason he aces just about whatever Gabriel puts him up to." She walked up to Marinette with purpose. "He was designed that way."
"Stop it!" Huffing, Marinette countered, "Even if you were right, that doesn't change that everyone adores Adrien. You think they'd do that if he was so 'fake'?"
She couldn't believe this was happening right now. The fact that the woman arguing with her was her future self meant that they both understood what it was like to be around and with Adrien, so how could she stand there and say such things?
Yet, Nette forged on, "I wonder about it. Is it really just a coincidence how everyone likes him so much and he can make friends so easily? Is it really just a coincidence how the guys were willing to lie and abandon their own girlfriends to throw him a party, when some of them barely talked to him? Is it really just a coincidence that he fell in love with Kagami when Gabriel planned on getting them together anyway?"
"But he's not anymore!" Marinette burst out. "He's in love with us, like we're in love with him!"
Over the course of their conversation, she'd noted that Nette had made every attempt to sound neutral or impassive when she could (with varying degrees of success), probably with the thought that it would stir up more emotion or make the revelations all the worse. However, her expression darkened at Marinette's words, so much so that Marinette flinched.
"Is that what you think love is?" Nette questioned in a low voice. "Feeling - or knowing - that your boyfriend is so helpless with emotions that he needs to be protected from them? Letting yourself suffer so that he doesn't have to? Deciding that you have to keep those secrets no matter how terrible it feels? Or are you just waiting for your memory to get erased when you make Alya the next guardian so you don't have to think about it anymore? Is that really the happy ending we dreamed about?"
For every argument, Nette would have a retort; Marinette realized it at that moment. As Nette had implied, she'd thought about all of this longer and harder, because she had to go through all the same mental hurdles when dealing with everything she'd discovered.
"...That's the thing about sentimonsters," Nette said bitterly. "We get to decide how to feel about them. No matter how much I told myself that he's different, because he was made to be a human, we mourned the Ladybug sentimonster that Nathalie made without doing it for the Nino that Gabriel made. They were made with the same thing in mind, so it was only how those situations panned out that mattered in the end. Maybe sentimonsters really have emotions, or maybe they just learn and react depending on what's going on around them. People 'fall in love' with AIs too, like the kind in those Alliance rings, but there's nothing real there; those people just think so."
She glanced outside, the bright sunny skies in sharp contrast with the emotional turmoil Marinette was going through. Nette rubbed at her heart, as if trying to ease the phantom pain of her counterpart's heartache.
"If you ask me, sentimonsters only 'love' within their limits. You should be familiar with it too." Her hand dropped to her yoyo, her thumb running along the edge where the two pieces met. "You could've revealed everything, but you didn't, and by protecting Gabriel, you were protecting Tomoe too."
"I didn't want Kagami to get hurt," Marinette uttered weakly. "Her mom did terrible things, but—but Kagami still cares about her."
"Of course she does. She's a sentimonster that Tomoe made," Nette reminded her. "Is it that Kagami feels like she should care about her, or that she can't help caring about her? Felix's dad didn't care about Felix, so of course Felix wouldn't care about him either."
"So..." Marinette sucked in a breathe. "What they want is based on the person who created them, and what they learn?"
"Or the person holding their object, and the authority in their lives." Reluctantly, Nette told her, "It's pretty obvious when you think about it. Adrien 'fell for' Ladybug, but is that really just a coincidence when Gabriel was so obsessed with getting the ladybug miraculous? When he and Kagami broke up, who did he go for next?"
The person who was secretly Ladybug, Marinette thought, but couldn't bring herself to say.
"And then Kagami ended up with Felix, who looks so much like Adrien that he can disguise himself as him. When a sentimonster can't get what they want - what they need - they'll seek out any replacement they can to fill a hole that can't be filled, like with Emilie." Nette swallowed, a dark look on her face. "Because I don't think Gabriel was the only reason Adrien went after us."
"I-I don't get it," Marinette lied.
The truth was that she didn't want to get it.
"You remember Simon Says, don't you? We went to get Adrien, and saw the picture on his computer of his mom." Not making eye contact, Nette asked, "What did Adrien say about it? About us?"
"That we had her—" Marinette's eyes wavered, her hands covering her mouth in abject disgust. She felt ill, the blissful ignorance she'd had at what she'd seen as a compliment having made her ignore all the red flags that came with it.
He'd compared her to his mother. All those times she took a leadership role over Chat to be "above" him, or viewed Adrien as someone who needed to be babied, she was enabling an association with the woman who created him, the very thing he'd been seeking out but couldn't have.
As if it were fate, Marinette's phone started ringing, the screen turning on to indicate the incoming call. Both of them looked to see Adrien's contact there, his image "pure" and "perfect" while the typical ringtone urged Marinette to answer it.
She didn't. She wasn't even sure that she could move. Her legs were entirely stiff, her hand blindly reaching out for her chair to sit in it.
Nette silently moved forward and grabbed the chair herself, sliding it into just the right spot so Marinette could collapse onto it. The two didn't say anything for a minute, the sound of the phone going off being the only thing to fill the silence.
Marinette waited for it to stop, unable to do so much as think while she could still hear it. Burying her face in her hands, she choked out, "How could you say all that? Why'd you have to tell me? We worked so hard to get here. If it's all a lie, then it was—"
"—for nothing," Nette confirmed. There was no cheer in her voice at having gotten through even a little bit to her present self; the sting of her own words affected her as much as it did when she'd initially thought them herself.
Marinette shook her body from side to side in adamant denial. Her head swam at the memories rushing through her, all of the humiliations she'd faced on her road to confessing to the Adrien Agreste.
Nette's tone shifted back to sympathy. "I know where your head's at right now. He was our everything, and I hate how it had to be that way."
Marinette heard the strange emphasis on the words, as well as the retreating footsteps, and peeked through her fingers to watch as Nette went back to the window seat. She'd almost forgotten about the diary and phone her future self had grabbed, and her diary specifically was brought over to her.
"There was a lucky charm we used to have. Remember?"
Marinette lowered her hands further down her face, eyeing the diary in concern. "Yeah? We gave it to Adrien."
"We loaned it to Adrien," Nette corrected, flipping open the diary. She skimmed its pages, then stopped and pointed at one of them. "It says so in here."
"What?" Marinette straightened as the book was brought down to her level. She couldn't wait and grabbed it herself, setting it on her lap as her hand hit the page. "No, right here, it says—"
Borrow. She'd let him borrow her lucky charm. She tried to remember all the way back to that moment, swearing that it had to be different.
He'd definitely smiled at the gesture... hadn't he? She got a headache whenever she thought about it.
"I told you that I don't know what wish he made," Nette said, "but I can guess what it might've been. I bet he liked the idea of friends giving him gifts just for him, and the wish makes that happen."
Put more simply, they still had some form of free will, but the wish's effect on the universe could shift and change things on a whim. Memories must've been easier to "adjust" than the diary, or maybe it hadn't mattered since she didn't read it until now.
Or, as Nette had suggested, the universe was falling apart the more wishes were made. Keeping the world consistent with itself became more impossible as time went on, so not everything lined up.
Marinette couldn't tear her eyes away from the diary page, in the middle of fighting the cognitive dissonance going on in her mind. "...Why? Why me? Why us?"
Nette departed for the window seat again, but kept talking to her. "I'm still speculating, but I think Adrien did want us in our old timeline. The way Chat felt about Ladybug probably carried over if he was the one who made the wish."
"But we didn't like him back then," Marinette pointed out. "Why didn't the wish affect us?"
"One, because dating us as heroes wasn't what he really wanted. If you think about it, Marinette is everything he could ask for: we have nice parents who could dote on him, we were the ones who helped him stand up to his dad, and we're someone who tries to protect everyone, especially people we care about."
"...And the second thing?" she wondered, not sure if she was ready but jumping in anyway.
Nette gestured at her transformed self. "It's the risk, like what could've happened when Sass used Second Chance that day."
Marinette remembered that. No one knew all the details, but she knew what had been about to happen before: she was going to let Viperion figure out Chat Noir's identity, so they set up a situation that he could Second Chance away.
Except Adrien was Chat Noir, and given how she acted around him... oh no.
Nette nodded. "It's a lot more risky to date as superheroes. We would be out more, we'd be letting our guard down on patrols to focus on each other, and maybe we'd even give in and reveal our identities. It'd be the perfect opportunity for Gabriel to take advantage of."
"Then he figures out Chat's identity," Marinette groans. "And Adrien figures out his."
Looking back at Chat Blanc, she felt like such a fool. She had so many steps to figure out how Chat could've discovered her identity, when actually it was only one step. Likewise with the Second Chance situation, of course she'd eventually reveal herself to Chat after learning he's Adrien.
"You think the wish protects him from learning about his dad?" she asked, though feeling like the answer was obvious at that point.
"Something like that, but..."
Nette let out a heavy exhale, and Marinette heard her retreat to the window seat once more, this time for the phone. She watched her slide her finger across the screen to unlock it, then tap a few times to access whatever she was searching for.
When the phone was turned around to face her, she didn't need to get closer to recognize what was on it: an image of herself grinning with the wall of Adrien pictures in the background.
"I thought this was a coincidence too." Nette pointed at the pictures themselves. "Sometimes we took some off, sometimes we added them, sometimes we didn't remember adding so many at all, but on the day that TV camera showed up..."
Marinette cringed, not needing to be reminded, and hid herself again behind her hands. "There were tons."
"Right, but I don't think that's by chance. It's terrible, but the best way for the wish to keep us close to Adrien when we were too nervous to confess was to make sure we'd never forget about him, at least until he wanted to date 'Marinette' and it was safe."
She had flashbacks from that alone: being unable to sleep from embarrassing herself over Adrien, having nightmares about embarrassing herself over Adrien when she did sleep, and her friends who brought him up even when she wanted to do her own thing. The way her life revolved around him almost perfectly, which seemed innocent and lovely at first, slowly became something she dreaded.
It hadn't stopped after they dated either. No matter what she did, things always circled back around to Adrien, and the big secret that was Gabriel's role as Monarch ensured that it would stay that way.
Could it have gone further than that? The supposed “love of her life” had wound up in her class, and him being Chat Noir meant that he would’ve been the only boyfriend she could’ve had that she wouldn’t have to abandon during akuma attacks.
"...Marinette," Nette called, her gentle tone somehow causing more anxiety rather than less. "I need you to look at me for this."
It was getting hard to breathe, but Marinette was determined to see this through. She uncovered her face and saw Nette standing there, one hand notably closed in a fist: the cat miraculous, most likely.
Nette laid the phone down on the diary, which she shut and placed aside on the desk. Her free hand went towards Marinette in an offer to help her up, and Marinette took it despite her confusion. Nette pulled her up into a stand, a look on her face that implied that the worst was yet to come.
Marinette honestly couldn't imagine how it could get worse.
"We've stayed on as Ladybug for a long time," Nette began. "Sometimes it feels like forever. I've had days where I've wondered why I still do it, or if someone else could do it better. Then I remember Master Fu, all the belief everyone has in me, and how hard I've tried to be the best hero I can. I feel guilty, like I have to stay strong for everyone else no matter how miserable it makes me, or it'd be—"
"—for nothing..." Marinette uttered, echoing their conversation about pursuing Adrien.
Nette smiled sadly. "Honestly? It would've been more responsible to give the miraculous to someone else. I thought it was weird whenever Tikki said I was the best, because either she was lying, the other heroes were just that bad, or..."
Or it was another way of keeping her attached to Chat Noir. As long as she felt obligated to be Ladybug, then Chat would have "his lady" around as much as he wanted. Likewise, as the conversation had already uncovered, every time she'd thought about how much she needed him or couldn't be Ladybug without him, that was the wish ensuring that he would remain Chat Noir. Kuro Neko happening right after him giving up his ring hadn't been a coincidence that made her feel like she'd betrayed him, it was a setup. Any act that would've gotten their miraculouses revoked under normal circumstances always ended up just okay enough so they would stay together.
"You have it half-right," Nette told her, having been watching the way Marinette's expression fluctuated. Her free hand went up to grip Marinette's shoulder in reassurance, but wasn't very reassuring.
"What?" Marinette wondered, almost frustrated by this point. Her world had already been thoroughly obliterated by that point, so, "What else is left?"
"Adrien's wish. We can't go back and see it ourselves, but I feel like I know what it is," Nette spoke. "In the first timeline, definitely around when we became adults, he must've found about about Gabriel's identity and it destroyed him. Then, he used the miraculouses to make a wish: he asked to be happy, with us."
"I... oh." Marinette's brows furrowed, unsure how else to take that other than an awkward, "Okay?"
She supposed that she should've felt glad, but she'd been prepared for much worse. The wish made sense and it was impressive that her future self had figured it out, as it explained her obsession with both Adrien and keeping Gabriel's identity a secret from him, but she was rather underwhelmed.
"...W-wait," she then uttered, a chill going up her spine.
Whenever a wish was made, a price had to be paid to balance the universe: a life for a life, or humanity for someone else's humanity.
In this case, it was happiness for someone else's happiness. If Adrien had wished to be happy, then someone...
then she had to be miserable in return.
Marinette had yelled and lost her cool a few times during Nette's explanation, but had managed to not completely break down thus far. She'd dealt with so much over the course of being Ladybug that she'd become numb to things she thought she wouldn't be able to get used to, and cried so hard that she thought she couldn't anymore.
She was wrong.
Nette, seeing her mind rapidly spiraling, pulled her into an embrace. The hug was tight, but safe, keeping Marinette firmly tethered to the moment they were in.
After all, Nette had gone through those emotions before her. She knew exactly what it was like.
"I'm going to tell you what I wish someone could've told me," she whispered. "It's not your fault, Marinette. You didn't deserve all the trauma you went through. You're not a villain and everything that happened to you wasn't some sort of insane cosmic justice. It's a messy universe, and you're just a girl who got caught up in it."
Marinette cried. It started as mere watery eyes, but soon turned into full-on bawling in the arms of her future self. Questions she'd had for so long about herself and the world around her had been answered, but not in any of the ways she'd hoped.
Yet, she would never have wished to go back to blissful ignorance. The knowledge hurt, but she wanted so desperately for that very same knowledge to have power.
——-
Eventually, Marinette could breathe again. The room didn't feel so small anymore, and her tears had dried. She'd started coping at some point too, her anguish twisting into some form of mocking laughter at the hand she'd been dealt, because what else could she do but laugh at the absurdity of the cards stacked against her?
She'd never known that there could be such a thing as an “incredibly depressing relief,” but they'd found it. She wasn't just unlucky, she didn't merely fumble into mistakes by things she never could've seen coming, and she wasn't a catastrophe waiting to happen. She was destined to screw up, whether to guilt her, isolate her, cause her to become dependent on Chat Noir for comfort, or all of the above. Everything going so perfectly for Felix when he took Adrien's place wasn't some clever strategy; things would've inevitably worked out for him from the start.
That, and the realization that Adrien - Chat Noir - was going to leave Paris for months without telling her, when she'd tried so hard to stay or at least have backup plans when the same opportunities were presented to her. What other secrets had he kept from her, after he'd complained about her not telling him everything?
Had the wish protected him there as well?
“...So that's it,” she breathed out with a humorless chuckle, now understanding Nette's reactions over the course of the whole conversation. She stepped away with a shrug, head hung in defeat. “I-it's over then. There's nothing we can do. We'll fail no matter what.”
Nette frowned. Shaking her head, she went forward and knelt down to put herself back in Marinette's view. “I don't think so; not yet, anyway. I want to believe that we still have a chance.”
“How?” she demanded, throwing her arms out in exasperation. “The wish is always going to work against us.”
“But Adrien never got his mother back,” Nette reminded her. When there was no recognition of the relevance in response, she asked, “What made it so Emilie didn't come back in the end?”
Confused, Marinette answered, “His dad. He didn't wish for her to come back.”
Nette pointed at her and nodded. “A wish overwriting a wish. Adrien's wish might've made it so Emilie did come back one day - that was even Gabriel's plan all along - but once the power was actually in his hands, he got to wish for something different.“
“And? What does that mean for...” Marinette trailed off, eyes slowly going wide at the implications and darting down to the closed fist around the cat miraculous. With a quiet gasp, she noted, “You want us to make a wish.”
“I know it sounds insane,” Nette acknowledged, reaching for Marinette's hand and holding it close, “but this whole thing sounds insane, so we'll have to beat it at its own game.”
Recoiling as much as she could given their positions, Marinette stammered, “Y-you're crazy! What if that just makes everything worse?!“
“It won't.” Nette squeezed the hand she held. “This has to work. This is our only way out.”
Marinette then recalled what Nette had told her before passing out: “Save us.” While it definitely was referring to the entire universe too, as she initially thought, it was now clear what Nette meant in the grand scheme of things: saving the both of them from the unshakeable hell they'd ended up in.
“You still have it in you,” Nette continued. She pressed the cat miraculous into Marinette's palm, then curled her fingers over it. “I know you do. There has to be a wish to fix everything.”
“You—” So that was why Nette had come all this way; it hadn't been a lie when she'd told Tikki that she hadn't planned on making a wish, but still, “You want me to make it?! Why not you? Why don't you do it? You're older and wiser and everything!”
Rather than conceding the point, Nette questioned with a forced smile, “Do you want the truth...?”
Marinette faltered, but nodded hesitantly.
Nette covered Marinette's hand in both of hers, then brought it to her forehead. “I've lost all faith in myself. Is that really a surprise, when just about everything we've done turned out so wrong?” She exhaled slowly. “I've deferred so many decisions as Ladybug because of how terrified I am that I'll be wrong. You have no idea how long I've lived with this; what had to have been behind everything. I kept second-guessing myself over and over, or told myself that I was just trying to find an excuse for how incompetent I was, until I couldn't take it anymore.”
She shook and let out a sobbing noise without any tears left to shed, unveiling how truly fragile she was in all of this. The name 'Nette' hadn't just been a casual nickname to make things easier for the two of them, it'd been Nette's way of telling Marinette who she was as an adult: a mere fraction of her former self.
Marinette thought back to when she'd first become Ladybug, standing confidently on the Eiffel Tower with a promise to protect everyone. She'd conquered her fear of Chloe not long after, and life seemed so good.
Yet, it was all downhill from there, and was never going to get better. She felt the black cat ring pressing into her palm, knowing deep down that it was do or die.
“...A...alright,” she said shakily, but she meant it. “I'll do it. I'll try, for us, for the world.”
Nette peeked up at Marinette, hope finally lighting up her eyes, then let go. It really seemed like she believed in—well, herself, but when taking into account the heavy burden being the one to solve all problems had been, being able to entrust the task to someone better qualified must've felt heavenly.
“Thank you,” she whispered. “I know better than anyone else how much pressure this is.”
“N-no, what do you mean? It'll be fine!” Marinette insisted, doing her best to bounce back and hype herself up. Opening her hand to look at half the world's fate in her very palm, she let out a nervous giggle. “T-the worst part'll be having to go back to being single, right?”
“...Hm.” Nette smiled, mirroring the giggle but without the same nerves. “Is that really what you think? You've done so well at putting everything else together.”
Marinette's head shot up. “H-huh?“ She dropped herself down to her future self's level. “Isn't that it?”
“Do you think we would've become an adult without dating anyone?” Nette asked in reply. Looking off to the side as if reminiscing, she reminded her, “That was one of the things that stumped me, because we're romantics at the end of the day. If there wasn't Adrien, there had to be someone else, right?”
“Then who?” Marinette urged, the revelations from before having already left her dizzy. “There's no one else in Paris we like that way.”
“In Paris,” Nette emphasized, drawing an imaginary line under the words she spoke. “I know it's been hard for us to love people because of what happened with Kim; we feel like we have to know everything about someone before we start dating them, so we're scared of it going wrong if we don't.” She brought her legs up near her chest, resting her arms on her knees. “But wasn't there one boy where it was different; where we were drawn to him from the start and were comfortable around him without worrying about knowing every part of his life?”
There wasn't a single other thought that crossed Marinette's mind. Her mouth automatically responded, “Luka.”
Another bomb had dropped, but at the same time, of course it was Luka. She'd nearly thought she didn't like him specifically because she felt at ease around him, which was wild thinking back on the logic in that. Perhaps it'd just been easier not to think of it due to how terrible their break-up had gone.
With the wish, it all checked out to the point that she didn't need it spelled out for her. Luka would've naturally been the second counterbalance to complete Adrien's wish too: for Adrien to be happy, someone had to be miserable, and for Adrien to gain the status of her boyfriend, someone had to lose it.
Nevertheless, some remnant had to have been left in her heart; that was why Luka was the exception to her trauma. After all, one didn't go all the way to nearly kissing someone that they only felt friendly towards, which left the final question of—
“Marinette,” Nette called. then prompted the next thought with, “What happened after we learned that Adrien had a crush on Kagami and we told our friends?”
“...The girls started arguing,” Marinette said slowly, a hand hovering over the lower half of her face. “They didn't want us to give up on him even though he was happy with someone else.”
“And when we were talking to Tikki about if Luka might be more than a friend?”
“Frozer. He interrupted us,” she gasped.
A memory came to mind of her and the others on the Liberty. Jagged Stone had shown up, and she'd thoroughly humiliated herself by giving Adrien all the focus instead of Luka. She recalled specifically asking Tikki, “Why did I do that?” as if she'd sensed something wrong in that moment, as even the biggest Adrien blinders shouldn't have stopped her from seeing the glaringly obvious.
Yet it did, and now she knew why. There was something wrong, which all came back to Adrien. She was literally incapable of not thinking about him due to the wish.
Nette continued, “Someone else interrupted too when we tried to kiss for the first time, and we usually beat him so easily that he was a joke.”
Mr. Pigeon. Marinette's heart started to pound hard in her chest. “I—I thought we did defeat him easily, but when I got back to Luka, the—”
The whole movie was over. All those akuma and sentimonsters that just so happened to come in at the worst times, thus keeping her from enjoying her dates with Luka, were intentional. Luka's issues with secrets had also never come up before and were the exact reason for the tension between them, which was what led her to breaking up with him in the first place.
Marinette's mind raced, eyes darting left and right with no real target. She began to rethink every interaction she'd had with Luka and how it could've been sabotaged. What once seemed like a message from the universe that it wasn't meant to be suddenly became the exact opposite.
She'd be so depressed after the breakup, she could barely get out of bed. She felt hopeless that she couldn't date him due to her Ladybug duties, and Tikki had insisted at the time that she couldn't help...
until it was Adrien rather than Luka. How had it never dawned on her before? Was it only because her future self gave her such knowledge that everything appeared so clear?
“When Monarch found out Luka knew,” she muttered to herself, “it was because of how much he tried not to get akumatized.”
“Isn't that odd?” Nette pretended to wonder, as they both knew the answer. “Luka tried to resist the akuma before he became Truth too, but Gabriel somehow didn't think about it back when Luka didn't know our identity; he even figured out that he knew both ours and Adrien's instead of just one, and then...?”
“Luka had to leave Paris.” Marinette stood so fast that she nearly gave herself vertigo, needing to get off the energy currently brewing inside of her by moving around. She gestured around at nothing while she walked, rambling, “I-I need to go. I have to do something. Before I do anything else, I have to see—”
She spun around to say it directly, since she'd have to put everything on hold to go see Max first to be as discreet as possible, but stopped when Nette had stood up too and was already holding the horse miraculous out to her. She was again reminded, who would know her better than herself?
Her future self, all smiles, asked, “You'll say hello for me, right?”
Marinette rushed forward, quite literally hugging herself. “Thank you. Thank you so much.”
Nette squeezed her tight, nearly lifting her off the floor in the process. ”You don't have to thank me. Remember, this is for the both of us, and it'll be you that saves the world in the end.”
“But...” Pulling back, Marinette gave her a once-over. “What'll happen after I make the wish? Are you going to disappear, or just... change like before?”
“I don't know.” Nette looked wholly unbothered despite the uncertainty, grabbing both of Marinette's shoulders and tilting her head. “But no matter what happens, your life is our life. Live it for both of us without regrets, okay?”
The thought that only one of them might ultimately get to live free pained Marinette, but there wasn't anything either of them could do about it. Taking her future self's hands off her shoulders, Marinette held them one last time with resolve, conveying her acceptance with a sad smile.
Then, she turned, separating for the last time as she shouted, “Tikki! Come on, we have to go!”
“...Marinette,” Nette called out from behind her.
Marinette looked over her shoulder at her, conflicted on whether she should hope for more good news or fear more bad.
Instead, her future self simply said, “Ask him how it happened.”
——-
No one was there when Pegabug teleported herself into Luka's home in Brazil, or at least no one in the room she was in. As she undid the fusion to bring herself back to normal Ladybug, she stowed the horse miraculous away in her yoyo and looked around to check for any sign that someone had been there recently.
Truthfully, she didn't have much of a plan. She just needed to see Luka. Her head was a jumbled mess and she had to talk to the one person who might help her clear her mind.
There were doubts she had about it, though not towards Luka specifically. She'd had a hard time following Nette's rapid explanations, and that was at least with the experiences of being the one all the utter nonsense happened to.
How could she even open that conversation?
”Hey, Luka, so I got a visit from me from the future and apparently the world is falling apart. I wasn't into Adrien before, but I still gave out miraculouses like with Bunnyx, okay? Then at some point, me and you probably started dating in the future until Adrien - by the way, I know he's Chat Noir now, it's fine - made a wish on the miraculouses that changed time so he got to be happy and me and you weren't dating anymore.
”There's also this bad timeline that Bunnyx-from-the-changed-future-that's-technically-the-changed-present-part-of-the-timeline and I got rid of where there was an akumatized Chat Noir, which is how we know that there was a first timeline because otherwise we'd all be dead. I'm obsessed with Adrien now because of his wish and that's also why my life sucks, why everything's more messed up than it already was, and why we couldn't be together like we were before.
”Don't worry though, because even though every wish anyone's ever made before is ruining everything, I'm going to come up with the perfect wish to make everything better.
“Anyway, so how was your day?”
Ladybug sighed into her hands, praying to any god she could think of that this would be the last major hurdle she would have to face. She pictured Nette, worn down but still having the hope to root for her, and tried to find comfort in that.
Her biggest fear the longer she thought about Luka's potential reactions was him being in Brazil. While the timeline hadn't been kind to her, she wasn't sure how it'd treated him outside of their dating. In addition, as she'd only remembered once she'd gotten there, he'd told her that he had a girlfriend.
The thought was crushing, albeit understandable. Who wouldn't love Luka, and what bigger tragedy was there than a boy with so much love in his heart than to have no one to give it to?
What if he was happy exactly where he was and didn't care about what might've been lost? What if she'd have to change the already-impossible-seeming wish to match that, as consideration for all the effort he'd put towards her? What if the wish would mean undoing his relationship with Jagged?
What if, what if, what if. All the thoughts were ultimately pointless and served little other purpose than to give her more anxiety until he actually—
“Marinette?“ The sound of a door shutting followed. “What are you doing here?”
Her head jerked up from her hands to see Luka standing there, his eyes wide and confused but not displeased by her being there. Sass must've been elsewhere, probably having a little snack break in the kitchen.
The fact that she'd been called 'Marinette' rather than 'Ladybug' told her that it was safe to talk comfortably without worrying about anyone else hearing, and that made her smile if nothing else.
“Luka.”
His name escaped her lips without her meaning to. She wasn't sure how she'd said it either but, judging by his expression, it caught him off-guard.
“Is everything okay?” He took a few steps towards her, diligently scanning her face. “Did something happen?”
He was a sight for sore eyes if there ever was one, dressed in the familiar calm blues she adored so much regardless of if the clothes were from Brazil or Paris. She wanted nothing more than to collapse in his arms and vent, like that day Adrien and Kagami had been “coincidentally” placed to throw her off, all so she would nearly lose the Miracle Box to Gabriel and actually lose Master Fu to his memory loss. She took the same number of footsteps as Luka to get closer to him, thoroughly tempted, but stopped before she could reach him.
“Nothing happened,” she replied, then shrugged meekly and corrected to, “Or, everything happened, a lot of bad stuff actually, but it didn't happen yet? So I think it'll be okay, I think.”
He tilted his head, but accepted the answer. “Alright. Well, I'm here whenever you need me, even if I'm far away.”
“Right.“ She thought fondly of the offer. She knew how it felt to work so hard to try and make the right decisions, to not be a burden on anyone, and to be helpful in any way possible. Luka was that sort of person all the time.
She just needed to make sure of the specifics.
“I...I wanted to ask,” she began, staring at the ground and the distance still between them. “Are you happy?”
“Happy?” he echoed.
“Happy here.” She waved her hands around. “In Brazil, with Penny and Jagged.”
“...Yeah.” He smiled, the faint hint of confusion still on his face. “Why wouldn't I be? You know me, I can find great music anywhere I go.”
He'd hesitated, and part of her hoped she hadn't been imagining it. She dared to take another step, pressing further, “But are you as happy as you've ever been?”
His brows rose, and it was obvious he was starting to sense that something was up. His focus shifted to her waist, where she was fidgeting with her fingers. “Marinette, seriously, is there anything wrong?”
“No—yes... sorry.” She rubbed her forehead, contemplating if she might have to go at this from a different angle. “There are a lot of choices I have to make, and things I have to figure out. I wanted to come see you and thought it might help.”
“Oh.” His smile widened, pleased to be needed. “Sure. Ask me anything.”
(Ask him how it happened,) Nette's voice rang in Ladybug's head. It hadn't been specific, but somehow she knew what it meant.
Certain of little else than that this was the right path to take, she locked eyes with him and questioned, “How did you figure out mine and Chat Noir's identities?”
He didn't answer immediately, which was suspicious all on its own. She remembered Nette's speculations on Adrien's wish and wondered how much it affected Luka too.
“I really need to know,” she stressed. “Life or death kind of know.”
He paused, always having had problems saying “no” to her, then nodded. Raising his arms up to chest level, he rubbed at the disguised snake bangle on his wrist and began explaining, “It was when we were fighting Wishmaker.”
That made sense to her. The most likely scenario for Luka to have seen or figured it out was when he was Viperion, and he hadn't participated in that many battles between their break-up and him admitting that he knew.
She also recalled that he had lied to her then that he'd seen nothing, and she now had an inkling of why he would.
Urging him to continue, she prompted, “Then?”
His gaze lingered on hers, but broke as he continued, “I saw Chat Noir standing there when Wishmaker tried to shoot him. He wasn't moving, so I had to protect him, and the shot I deflected hit you.“ He rotated the bangle in a rare show of nerves. “When I went back to try again, I tried to tell Chat Noir to avoid it so I could go with you, but...”
He let himself get hit, in other words, but Luka was too nice to use that exact accusation. Ladybug's memory of back then wasn't perfect, but she recalled enough of the battle that he hadn't used Second Chance on. When she knew what she knew now, how “funny” was it that a shot like that would happen to hit her? Viperion was always so careful otherwise.
That wish really wanted him gone, even when they weren't dating anymore. She let out a bitter laugh through her nose, then it escaped out of her mouth as well.
“That...” She raised a hand to her face to try and contain herself, shaking her head in what could no longer be called disbelief anymore. “Yeah, that sounds like him. If it'd been me—but because it was him, Adrien just—“
Luka's mouth dropped open, catching more than enough of her scrambled thoughts. “Adrien? You know? Since when?”
The gravity of what might've actually been going on while he was in Brazil seemed to hit him, not that she'd given enough away in the first place for it to register until then. Her casual attitude about it probably hadn't helped.
“I just found out,” she told him. With a dramatic flourish of her hand, she added, “We're over, me and him.”
Luka stared, not having any words. She couldn't blame him, as Adrien had been her whole life for a while, and had remained as such until about half an hour ago.
When Luka could finally get himself to speak again, he lowered his head and admitted, “I-I thought you'd fallen into rhythm with each other; that you'd found harmony.”
(Is that really what you think love is?) Ladybug recalled, and smiled sadly. “No offense, Luka, but I think you need to get your ears checked.”
He let out a small, strained noise from the back of his throat. It was obvious she hadn't been trying to actually insult him, but it must've been jarring for her to talk about Adrien that way compared to the last time they'd seen each other.
“...I can't really blame you though,” she acknowledged, running her hands up her face, through her bangs, then back down again. “It's complicated, and I mean ex-treme-ly complicated.”
She'd put extra emphasis on the syllables and it still didn't feel like enough to fully convey everything. While she wanted to hear his answer to her question about happiness, she supposed it wasn't fair to leave out so much the context that he blatantly needed.
“Here.” She extended her hand to him. “You're gonna want to sit down for this.”
When he reached out and accepted her hold, she maintained the careful distance between them and brought him over to the nearby couch before reluctantly letting go. They then stood there for a solid few seconds before realizing that they were waiting for the other to sit down first. Eventually, they gave up on the stalemate and sat at the same time.
Not knowing where else to begin, Ladybug started off by talking about the time portal that had opened up in her room...
——-
Luka sat patiently throughout her entire story, staying as quiet as possible barring a few questions at the beginning. She tried to start slowly to pace things out, adding her own input or speculation every now and then where she thought it might be useful. Letting Nette's explanations sit in her mind helped her grasp them in a way she hoped she could convey best to him.
Had someone been watching from the outside, it was apparent when things started to get more unbelievable and crazy based on Luka's reactions alone. He stopped asking anything in favor of simply absorbing, his pupils shrank, his hands started fidgeting with his clothes without a guitar to touch, and at one point his mouth was perpetually open like it'd gotten stuck that way. She might've found it funny if the situation had been less serious.
Before everything happened, people on both sides of her identity said that she and Adrien were ”made for each other.” It was a little scary, wondering how much was because of the wish and how much was the people around her being themselves. That was why she had to do whatever she could to fix things, so she wouldn't have to doubt people or question how real their intentions were.
It made her wonder about Luka himself as well. While he'd encouraged her in her relationship with Adrien, there were distinct things that made him stand out from everyone else: the way he supported her, the way he never blamed her, and the way he always tried so hard to see things from her perspective. When she really thought about it, it was the same way a boyfriend would act with a girlfriend he knew and was close to for a long time.
If that was the case, was Nette's theory really true? Had enough of the old timeline lingered? How did their first interaction go if she still had love trauma, and how long must they have been dating for her to move on from it?
She voiced no such questions to him herself, keeping the details of their potential past (or future?) a secret for the time being. It wouldn't do to bring it up when she was so uncertain about what his life in Brazil was like.
When Ladybug had finished explaining the situation to Luka, he didn't say anything right away. She shifted her legs in concern, watching him and trying to gauge what must've been going on in his head, but his expression looked completely blank.
After counting to ten in her head and confirming that he remained speechless, she leaned over to get closer to him. “...Luka.” She pressed a finger to his chin and closed his gaping mouth. “I know it's a lot, but please say something.”
His mouth fell open again, but then he blinked himself back to reality at her voice. Shaking his head, he took a deep, steadying breath and put a hand to his chest, uttering, “I'm sorry.”
“Huh?“ That was not on the list of things she'd thought he might say. “What for?”
“...I don't know. I—you're right, it's a lot, but you were the one it affected the most and I didn't help.”
“That's not true!” she gasped in offense. “You're always helping me!”
“But if I hadn't helped you with Adrien—”
“The whole universe is screwed up, Luka. It's not just me, or you.”
He'd heard her, but his hand gripped the crook of his neck hard, so much so that she could see the way his skin gave. Fearing he might hurt himself, she grabbed his wrist and pulled it away with a scolding look, only returning to her original position when she noticed how close she'd gotten to him.
He let out a heavy exhale. “I keep thinking back on everything that happened. When I try to remember why I did things the way I did, it feels like there are gaps in my memory.”
“Me too.” She brought a fist to her chest, trying not to shake too much. “That's why I have to fix this with the wish.”
“That can't be easy,” he said with a tone that knew very well that he couldn't convince her out of it. He stood up, extending his hand to her as she'd done for him before. “Come on. Have you eaten anything or had something to drink?”
She startled at that, having not given a single thought to eating or drinking, and was reminded again of their potential timeline together. She reached out to drop her hand onto his, hesitated, then sheepishly took just his fingers in her hand instead.
Unable to make eye contact for a moment, she stared at her lap as she asked again, “Are you at your happiest here? Do you like it more in Brazil than Paris?”
“Why are you wondering about that so much?”
“Since we have no idea what the wish'll be yet, we don't know what'll happen when I make it.“ She ran her thumb anxiously across his fingers. “Everything could change, or time could get reset again, and then you'd lose your home here with your dad and Penny.”
He dismissed that immediately. “You shouldn't be thinking about that. Even if time goes back that far, I could still meet my dad again.”
“But...” Her lips pressed together, barely containing the worry she had until she finally looked up at him and burst out, “But your girlfriend! What about her? I don't want either of us to have any regrets when I make the wish, but if I undo what happened, you really might never see her again, ever!”
Luka's brows got lost in his bangs, as if somehow the thought of this girlfriend of his hadn't occurred to him. Ladybug frowned adamantly at him, her grip on his fingers firm in her resolve to not let him drop the subject again.
The atmosphere was strange in a way she couldn't describe, neither of them moving for a long moment. It puzzled her, because he didn't seem worried or sad or fearful about the possibility she'd presented. On the contrary, he almost looked embarrassed.
“...I'm sorry,” he told her, staring at their touching hands. Before she could chide him for apologizing over nothing a second time, he admitted, “I lied to you. I don't have a girlfriend.“
“You—you what? You? Don't have? A girlfriend?” Having learned that her fretting had been over a nonexistent person, she felt as if she'd lost her balance despite being sat down. “But why? I mean, yeah, why would you lie, but why don't you have one at all? It made sense. That's why I was—I was just so sure that someone like you...”
There was a twitch in the hand she held, the uncertainty that was so unlike Luka. Again, he was silent, but he did pull his hand back to take her hand properly in his. She let him, not seeing a reason to be concerned about it anymore, but was entirely struck by how he brought her to her feet and guided her towards the door without a word.
“Luka?” she called. “Luka? Are you okay?
He kept walking. She considered calling out again despite the apparent futility of it, yet his footsteps began to slow the closer they got to the door. She slowed her pace with him, staring intensely at the back of his head as she wondered what could've been going on in his mind. Without seeing his face, all she had to go off of was the way he gripped her hand like he didn't want her to let go.
She didn't.
They were a single step away from leaving the room when he'd come to a total stop. She heard him breathe, as well as a slight jingling sound when his free hand came up to toy with his necklaces. Idly, she thought of the necklace she'd gifted him, and hoped he still had it.
Then, he spoke up.
“...I love you.” Turning to face her, he confessed, “I've never stopped loving you, Marinette.”
Her eyes went wide. Her heart skipped a beat. She swallowed and nearly choked on her own saliva.
He continued, “I lied so you wouldn't worry about me, but you're right. Since we don't know what'll happen, we shouldn't have any regrets, and I'd regret not telling you how much you mean to me.”
She'd remained stuck on the fact that he still loved her more than anything else. He got closer to her, or at least that was what she thought until she realized that her body was pitching forward. She plowed directly into his chest and he caught her easily, keeping her pressed against him.
She sighed contently and wrapped her arms around him, but feigned a pout as she lightly hit his back. “You had me worried anyway, and it was over nothing.”
“I know.” The apologetic smile he had on was evident in his tone. “I shouldn't have kept anything from you after what happened. I don't care if it was me or the wish or what that made me do what I did, but I might've been able to stay in Paris with you if I told you from the start that I knew you were Ladybug.”
“Oh, trust me.” She chuckled nervously. “It was probably for the best. You missed out on all the embarrassments.”
He countered easily, “But I missed you.”
She blushed in return. “...I missed you too.”
That was the kind of openness that only a boyfriend who knew her for a long time could have, she thought. There wasn't any reason to hold back now.
However, as she went to say it, Luka spoke first to tell her, “Honestly, I missed you in Paris whenever I couldn't see you anyway. Maybe it sounds like a cheesy song, but sometimes, I feel like I missed you even before we met.“
She looked up at him in surprise, clutching the fabric of his clothes tightly. “You mean, like we already knew each other?”
He mirrored her expression, his eyes searching her reaction. A moment later, he asked with a gentle awe, “What did Nette tell you?”
Smiling and keeping one arm around him, she reached up and cupped his cheek. “She thinks we were dating before the wish happened. That's why we're so... us. It couldn't have been anyone else but you.”
She felt the breath he let out at the revelation. He almost spoke up, but opted instead to turn his head towards her hand, using his own hand to keep it there as he hid the lower half of his face with it.
His expression was difficult to place, though the blush there told her it wasn't all bad. Was he happy to hear that they could've had a happy life, or upset that it might've been taken away from them? Maybe it was both, but she had the feeling that even he wasn't quite sure himself.
She could relate. She'd gone through the exact same thing. She considered their current embrace and thought about how often they could've done it in what was essentially another life. Every time she kissed his cheek like it was no big deal or touched him without freaking out, how much of it was the them of now and the them of back then?
Could they have it again?
There wasn't a right moment to ask, given the way Luka was reacting and still reacting. Stroking along his skin with her thumb, Ladybug said tenderly, “I think you need that water just as much as me now.”
He nodded against her hand, reluctantly letting her go. They didn't fully separate, his arm around her not unlike that day at the TV studio where they defended their music video, and his free hand opened the door so they could leave.
Sass was indeed in the kitchen once they arrived there, not eating any longer but lounging in a teacup. He raised an arm to greet the two of them, his tail swishing innocently back and forth.
...A little too innocently.
“Were you listening?” Ladybug asked, then jumped when it registered that Luka had asked the same thing. They glanced at each other and exchanged a sheepish yet fond smile.
“I'm not going to do anything,” Sass assured. “You're the guardian, after all.”
She was glad that he wouldn't interfere, but frowned as she insisted, “It shouldn't matter if I'm the guardian or not. You have more experience than anyone else with going back and changing things, so should have a say.”
“Thank you,” he responded with a toothy grin, twisting in the teacup so he could prop his forearms up onto the edge. “Still, we kwami may not have organs like you do, but it would nevertheless be heartless for me to try and stop you.”
Luka turned to Ladybug and translated, “He means that he trusts you to make the right decision; kwami were just trained to give authority to guardians, so it's hard to say. Leaving everything how it is would be disastrous in its own way.”
He left her side to retrieve the two glasses of water, meaning it was just her and Sass staring each other down. She was conflicted, even while knowing he'd heard everything.
“Aren't you worried?” she asked. “Anything could happen. Whatever the wish is going to be, it won't be like any other one.”
“I doubt it would be any more harmful than the ones that have come before,” he argued.
”...What about Luka? If the wish changes enough, he might not become Viperion. You won't get to see each other again.”
He hummed, then acknowledged, “That would be a shame.”
“So—”
“But, you're Ladybug. You've pulled out of horrible situations before, and I believe your best intentions can shine through.”
Luka returned, passing her the glass of water and giving Sass an approving look. “Now you see why Sass gets along so well with me.”
She shook her head at the both of them, focusing on taking a sip of her drink. In her opinion, Luka had far too much trust in her, and that seemed to have rubbed off on Sass. While their lack of worry helped her worry less, it broke her heart to think of holders who might've been separated from their kwami friends.
Then, she thought of Nooroo, who'd been through not one but two villains in her time as Ladybug alone. Certainly, there were more happy kwami she knew than unhappy, but it seemed like some unbreakable endless cycle for the Miracle Box to never come back together again. Why else would the butterfly just so happen to end up in the hands of someone who would use it for evil?
There had to be a way - there had to - to either avoid a downside or at least keep everyone safe, happy, and together.
“Marinette,” Luka called. He waited for her to lift her face from her glass to look at him, then said entirely unprompted, “Do you know why string instruments are my favorite?”
“Uh?” She blinked at him, trusting that this was relevant somehow but not knowing how. “Isn't it because the guitar was your first instrument?”
“That's part of it.” He took a swig of water, then set his glass aside. Departing only briefly, he returned with an acoustic guitar strapped to his torso. Unphased by the puzzled looks he was getting from both Ladybug and Sass, he plucked a single note. “I love the vibration of the string when it's played, like how the Liberty barely moves from one place but still sways from being on the water. It's relaxing.”
She felt his hand touch hers and watched as he guided it to where the strings began on the guitar's body. Putting her fingertips against the strings themselves, his other hand moved higher towards the headstock, where the strings ended.
With his free hand, he pointed from where her hand was to his. “The parts of a string instrument are connected, and that vibration—”
He plucked another note, and this time she felt it.
“—goes all the way from one end to the other. It doesn't matter how long the string looks, the reaction stretches across the entire thing. That's us.” One by one, he started plucking each string and counted off, “My mom, my dad, Jule, Sass, Penny, and you. It doesn't matter what you do or how many wishes you make, because it won't change that we played beautiful music together.”
Her eyes stung, lips wobbling with emotion. Sliding her fingertips from the top string down to the bottom, she uttered, “Luka...”
“So don't worry, Marinette. I don't care whether we go back to how things were before the wish or create something new.” He put his hand upon hers on the guitar, keeping a fingertip on the same string that she was on and moving their hands along the whole length of it. “We're one.”
“We're one,” she echoed in a whisper, and she clung to that notion of his like it was a lifeline. Neither of them could've said what the tether he spoke of truly meant - whether sensorial, emotional, spiritual, or some mix of the three - but it wasn't important.
Even if they didn't remember it, even if what they had was undone, their time together had been precious. In the same way kwami couldn't be sensed while resting inside a dormant miraculous, nor could they be comprehended in the past when the miraculouses had yet to be created, they were there, existing in a profound, metaphysical—
Ladybug froze, an epiphany striking like lightning. Her grasp on the room around them left her for a solitary moment, and with it went the grasp on her water as well.
Not missing a beat, Luka caught the glass mid-air and set it aside. Eyes never leaving her, he removed the guitar from himself and put it down on the floor so he could get closer to her without anything in-between them.
“I know,” she gasped, her body vibrating not unlike the strings he'd plucked. Jumping up, she exclaimed, “I know, I know, I know what I need to wish for!”
Luka held onto her shoulders to keep her stable. Her astonishment was rubbing off on him and he urged, “Where's the other miraculous?”
Her breathing picked up as she frantically reached for the yoyo at her hip. In her haste, she failed attempts at pressing the button once, twice, then a third time until finally getting it open. She nearly thrust her entire arm inside in her efforts to get to the black cat ring, clutching it with her whole hand and bringing it back out into the open.
Was this it? She felt - knew - that she had the right answer, but it was terrifying as well. Even as she tried to slip the cat ring onto her finger, she found that she was shaking too much to manage it.
Luka requested gently, “Give it to me. I'll help you,” then took her right hand in his. She dropped the ring onto his waiting palm, and he kept her hand steady so he could prepare to slide it on.
The edge of the ring had barely touched her fingertip before she pulled back, clasping one hand against the other at her waist.
“Wait, wait! T-there's one more thing. It's important.” She forcefully blew out a breath, making hesitant eye contact. “Luka, about what happened with us...”
He kept the ring carefully in his fingers. “Us from the other timeline? Or this one?"
"...Yes?" She shrugged, not knowing how else to explain it. "Just—listen. We must've worked out back then, and I didn't want to say or do or ask anything if we might forget each other too, but..."
She grabbed the hand not holding the miraculous, her blush returning at what she felt was an embarrassing thing to think about when the world was at stake.
"If everything resets, and we don't remember anything about us, will... will you fall in love with me again? And if we do remember, will you kiss me?"
It was the closest thing to a confession since she'd arrived. While he'd been wholly direct with his own feelings, she'd stalled only because the nature of the crumbling universe was so tentative. Now that there was suddenly an end in sight, she had to act or risk never getting anywhere with him again.
To her surprise, Luka chuckled at the question. He shifted his hand, fingers sliding across her palm until his fingertips touched hers, then he intertwined their fingers entirely. With a loving hold, he brought the back of her hand against his heart and kept it there.
"I'll kiss you," he promised, "because I'm never going to forget the way you make me feel, Marinette. The lyrics to your song are already written on my heart."
Her own heartbeat synced with the rapid beating of his. She would've kissed him herself right there if they both hadn't already been testing the universe as it was.
Her body had relaxed by then, and while she could've put the ring on herself at that point, she let him finish what he'd started. Sass, who had been otherwise uninvolved in their little moment thus far, flew over as Luka held her hand in place.
Ladybug didn't know if it was some sort of kwami custom, or maybe something only Sass did, but he laid his tiny body along the back of Luka's hand while his tail curled around hers. Their eyes met and she felt that he was communicating something, but couldn't quite figure out what.
A blessing? Well wishes? A goodbye? Maybe it was beyond her understanding entirely.
As the cat miraculous was slid onto her finger, she called upon the fusion and transformed. Luka's hand kept holding hers for support and Sass remained wrapped around them both. Channeling her full focus into what she was about to do, she hoped for little else than that she might remember this moment; that there was just enough leftover magic for her to hang onto the good she was given.
All the while, her wish was vivid at the forefront of her mind.
I wish the miraculouses never existed.
——-
Marinette's phone alarm startled her awake, the blanket practically soaring off of her like a bird taking flight as she sat up. She blinked, breathing heavily, then looked down at the phone at her side in confusion.
She could've sworn that she'd changed the alarm sound recently.
Not trusting herself to avoid getting into a snoozing loop, she reluctantly picked up her phone and dismissed the alarm, but something wasn't quite right. She squinted, the mental fog called morning still hanging over her, and that was when she noticed the date.
It was the first day of the school year; that first day of the school year.
She remembered. Granted, the memories were more like a puzzle with missing pieces, but there were enough that it could be formed into a complete (albeit smaller) image.
She recalled Master Fu, becoming Ladybug, and the kwami. She recalled conquering her fear of her bully, mastering her talents, and the struggle to balance her schedule. Finally, she recalled her future self encouraging her to live happily, Luka's hand holding hers as she made her wish, and the broken timeline they'd tried to repair after it'd been tampered with by...
...?
Her mind drew a blank when she tried to come up with a name or face, but she supposed that it could've been someone random that she didn't know the name of. Her head didn't hurt when she thought about it anyway; on the contrary, it'd never felt more clear, akin to a migraine that she didn't know she had finally being cured.
She wondered if it was a sign. Had she actually done it? Did the wish work?
She got up and wandered around her room, noticing that the things she vaguely remembered making in the future weren't there. It should've been unfortunate to have to make them all over again, but she didn't see a reason to complain if she accomplished her goal.
"...Are you free?" she asked the empty room, so used to having a tiny companion by her side that it felt natural to do.
No answer came, or at least not a verbal one. It was difficult to put into words, but the world around her felt fuller, more vivid somehow. As she went about her day, she could've sworn that the presence of the kwami was around her even though she couldn't sense them.
Tikki's luck when her breakfast didn't turn into an utter disaster like the last timeline, Trixx's mischief when she accidentally greeted her father so loud that he dropped dough onto the island and got flour all over himself, and Daizzi's happiness when said flour-coated father gifted her macarons to share with her class...
The bakery's bell rang above her as went outside with the intent to get to school early. When she looked to her left across the street, Master Fu wasn't there, as if the signature moment that snowballed her life into unrest was completely unknown to the world. To her, it might as well have been a long nightmare she'd finally woken up from.
Now, she was just a normal girl with a normal life.
Raising her head skywards in fascination, Marinette remembered Sass wrapped almost protectively around her and Luka's hands. Had she been brought back in time due to her wish, or had Sass's presence somehow changed things? Perhaps he'd only suspected what the results would be and had tried to convey as much to her: enjoy your Second Chance.
She swallowed the mixed emotions that caused her, thankful regardless of the circumstances but regretful that she'd never get to say so face-to-face. Acknowledging that she'd have to accept it as a necessary result of what she did, she turned to start heading down the sidewalk.
She hadn't taken a single step before a familiar sound reached her ears, one that she knew didn't line up with the previous timeline. She spun to face the opposite direction, an open hand up near her ear as she listened.
Plucked strings from a guitar were forming a melody, and it was coming from the park. Someone was playing music, except she knew that there was only one person it could've been.
No one else knew her song.
The light for the crosswalk turned green to indicate that she could walk, but Marinette ran. She went across the sidewalk, over the street, and into the park with a speed worthy of someone who'd been a superhero at one point. The whole time, she kept thinking that there was no way, so scarred from times made nonexistent that she'd been certain she'd have to be the only one living with the memories, if she'd had them at all.
Yet, when she stood there at the entrance to the park, he was there. Luka was sitting on the edge of the water fountain, eyes closed and playing her melody. A butterfly had also descended and perched nearby as if it was a tiny audience member, creating a beautiful scene that made her feel breathless.
For what was probably the tenth time that day, a flood of questions came to her. What was he doing there? Didn't he have to go to school too? Had he come all this way just to see her?
Then, Luka's eyes opened halfway to look at her, taking in her shock with fond amusement. Grinning confidently, he mouthed out to her: I told you.
With that, all of the questions - unanswerable or otherwise - that she'd had over the course of the morning were promptly discarded when she realized one simple fact: she did not care.
She ran to him, her rapid steps giving him just enough time to put his guitar off to the side so she could jump at him. In a way that somehow didn't send both of them directly into the water, her body collided with his and she thoroughly straddled him, enjoying the warmth of their embrace.
She had him. He was familiar, safe, and she didn't have to wait or make plans to see him after all.
Luka laughed melodically, then slowly raised his hands from her back and called out a simple, "Hey."
Though confused why he'd let go so quickly, her head came off his shoulder so she could smile at him. His hands went up to cup her face as she greeted in return, "Hey? What—"
He pulled her in and pressed his lips to hers, never one to have an overdue promise even though the kiss itself was long, long overdue. As for Marinette, she melted into it automatically, her body responding as though she'd done it a million times before.
As her final revelation of this whole experience, she noted that this was why she couldn't have kissed him in the previous timeline. She knew the feeling of his lips, and the recognition came at her in waves from the contact: kisses pressed against her temple on stressful days, clumsy kisses just barely missing her mouth on sleepy nights, sweet kisses that tasted like they'd shared the same drink, and kisses with chapped lips during cold winters that swiftly turned into kisses smelling of lip balm.
Luka had insisted that he didn't care what form they took in their new lives and that they didn't have to go back to whatever they had. While Marinette agreed in principle, she silently made her own promise to the both of them: she wanted all that and more, so much more that they would struggle to fit all that joy into one timeline.
There weren't any more magical accessories for her to use, nor could she do any more wishes to make it happen, but she was happy with that. They would get by on their own, and that was better to her than any magic.
For the time being though, it was enough just to celebrate by getting lost in each other, and the butterfly at their side departed freely into the open sky.










