Okay, so Railroading in D&D is a specific term that means that the DM is moving the story forward in a way that ignores
the players’ interests and plans
the characters’ goals
verisimilitude
the dice
some combination of the above
Providing clear plothooks is not railroading.
Narrating transitional moments is not railroading.
NPCs sharing information and taking actions that support their interests is not railroading.
Having a general plot outline is not railroading.
Please let words have meanings.














