I fear we have lost the plot on what counts as a tumblr sexyman. I’ve see Ryland Grace doing well in the most recent Tumblr Sexyman poll, but guys, Grace is not a tumblr sexyman. He is Ryan Gosling, that is a traditionally attractive man.
A tumblr sexyman is not just a man that is popular on tumblr, it is a man/creature who is not traditionally attractive but that finds a cult following and is MADE attractive by tumblr users. Sans is a tumblr sexyman, the purple guy is a tumblr sexyman, the onceler is a tumbler sexyman. I will even accept characters like Stan Pines because he is primarily a weird old man, but he is on the fence.
The tumblr distinction is that they are only sexy on tumblr. If you show a true tumblr sexyman to an average person they should think you are a little crazy. It’s gotta be a hear me out. But Ryan Gosling is not a tumblr sexyman! That is just a sexy man!













