Christianity and Homosexuality
So I got my car serviced today and they ended up needing to go get an air filter for me cause they didn’t have one in stock. While I was waiting, I ended up chatting with one of the service techs. I don’t remember how we got there, but at some point she mentioned her girlfriend and then said something to the extent of “I know it’s a sin, but I don’t see why it’s so much more wrong than my mom cheating on my dad...”
To which I said, “You see, I disagree...” Her face kind of went slack, so I continued with, “I don’t think that homosexuality is a sin.”
She seemed so surprised and kinda stumbled a bit before continuing the conversation. You see (and I don’t know whether or not this will surprise most of you), I had already told her that my degree was in Religion/biblical studies and that most of my work since graduating has been with religious groups...and, especially in our area, a pro-lgbt stance is sadly not what’s expected from religious people.
From there we ended up in a discussion on biblical doctrine in general but much also about how it pertains to homosexuality. From her reaction...I think I’d like to share 2 of the points we talked about on here as well.
(Let me take a moment here to say that I firmly believe that if your religion encourages you to be cruel or hate people, you need a new religion. Even back when I was firmly in the camp of “homosexuality is wrong,” I never agreed with any kind of discrimination. I was in favor of marriage equality because, in the same way that I think religions should be left to practice as they believe, I also think that no religion, including Christianity, should be allowed to use the government to enforce their beliefs. Also, I should point out that this is going to be a discussion on this from a Christian pov. If that’s not your thing, no big deal at all.)
1. Sodom and Gomorrah - This. Genesis 18-19. This is the story that get’s thrown in our faces ALL THE TIME. This is, as they say, the story of when God burned two cities to the ground because he could no longer tolerate their homosexual behavior. Right? Right??
Not exactly. Please consider this passage from Ezekiel 16: - (49)Now this was the sin of your sister Sodom: She and her daughters were arrogant, overfed and unconcerned; they did not help the poor and needy. (50)They were haughty and did detestable things before me. Therefore I did away with them as you have seen.
Did you catch that? The people of Sodom were horrible. They were themselves wealthy and arrogant and did not use that power and privilege to help those who needed it. And in Genesis we find out that when God sends 2 angels to go check it out and see if it’s as bad as people’s prayers say it is...They try to rape the angels and Lot ends up trying to protect/shelter them. But did you notice what didn’t get said?? “God destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah because of same sex couples who loved each other and just wanted to be together.” Nope. That’s not said at all. There are places, such as Jude 7, that do mention the sexual depravity of Sodom...but even those don’t cite the problem specifically as homosexuality so much as promiscuity/depravity in general. Which brings me to my next point...
2. Context: Gosh...how on earth do I condense years and years of study in biblical interpretation into something understandable and short enough for a blog post? *sigh* Look, let me just say that when studying scripture, context is key. The Bible is a product of the time in which it was written, meant to be understood by people who lived thousands of years before us. Not considering context would be like me leaving a note to my husband while I’m out of town to “remember to take the trash out on Wednesday...” and then people find that note 2000 years later and go, “Oh shit! We’ve been taking the trash out of Tuesday! We’re all going to hell!!”
Maybe that example is a bit extreme, but my point is that while the Bible is excellent and there is so much we can learn from it...we need to be VERY careful not to take everything in there literally as a rigid rule meant to be followed exactly for all time. There are many many things in there written as advice for specific situations. We can learn from those, but we need to be careful in how we choose to understand them.
So what does context have to do with sexuality? This. Back in biblical times, the family unit was everything. It’s how you survived. Women needed a husband because they didn’t have their own rights in most cultures. People who had kids and lots of them were the ones who prospered because they had people to tend the land/flocks and carry on their name/legacy.
So with this society being what it was, men and women were GOING to get married and make as many kids as they could. Any homosexual relationship that existed was either going to be adultery/promiscuity or oftentimes as a part of pagan rituals. Of COURSE in that setting it went against Judeo/Christian teachings.
But things aren’t like that anymore. Our society isn’t built the same way. It’s possible for two same sex people who love each other to live together happily, have kids, and do well for themselves.
I know this is a long post, but I know that a lot of my mutuals also come from religious backgrounds and thought this may be a discussion y’all would be interested in. Feel free to add your thoughts. No hate/homophobia/anti-lgbt though. Trust me, anyone in the lgbt community has already been listening to those arguments our whole lives. You’re not going to tell us anything new.