Photoshop Phoneys
http://s1011.photobucket.com/user/Bec_Maxted/story/24193
My project explores the power of Photoshop to realistically manipulate images. I have 12 different photos posted on Photo bucket and made into a story, half are originals and half are edited. They all demonstrate different ways photos can be manipulated, from replacing a person to replacing the scene a person is in. Majority of the images are my own with a few exceptions.
Last year for year 12 I did a major in art where a lot of it involved Photoshop. My skills obviously got a lot better during that year as I was using it only a daily basis. However, I did have a PC and the Mac computers software is slightly different so I had to get use to the new setting. By using my Photoshop skills I have manipulated a series of pictures quite realistically, making it hard to decipher which is the original. This demonstrates how easy it is to manipulate a picture and makes viewers question how trustworthy a source can be, also questioning ethics behind Photoshop. For my first edits, I kept them really subtle to make it harder to tell which is which. I cropped my dad into a different background, the real one being unexpected as we were visiting Melbourne when my dad was working and we had a look at the graffiti. The next one was my sister cropped into a picture of mine from year 12. She’s subtly placed in the crowd, and the original, once again, unexpected as she went on a school trip overseas. I then cropped a picture of my friends and I at ‘Flat rock’ in Bathurst into Manly beach in Sydney, this one also being unexpected as we’re all wearing swimmers and so the beach scene seems more fitting. I then decided to do a dramatic change, and made my sister walking home into a sunset skating picture, I changed the colour of her and tried to edit her so she looked like she was naturally in the picture. I did a much more obvious one as I cropped a famous person (James Franco) on top of my friends head, I chose to do this to demonstrate how easy it is to swap people’s faces. For my last one I edited a tattoo onto my friends arm who has no tattoos, this one was the hardest because it was really hard to make the tattoo look realistic on his arm. Next time I do this project I might not do the tattoo one unless I can find a better way to do it because it’s pretty obvious it’s not real. However at first glance you can’t tell. I also might not of done the sunset one because you can kind of tell if you look closely it’s fake. I still believe majority of the edits communicate my point though as they mostly all look realistic.
By attempting this project I learnt just how easy it is to manipulate photos, I have maybe 2 years experience with Photoshop and even some of my edits are scarily realistic image what someone with years and years of experience could do. This made me think about what photos can be reliable and what photos could be fake. I also thought on Photoshop as an art because when it comes down to it, it is a skill and not everyone can use it well so executing a realistic Photoshop is actually quite talented, but where is the line between art and ethics? I believe if a photo has been touched or edited in anyway it should be communicated it doesn’t take much effort to have in small font under a picture ‘edited’. Some contemporary media communication practices don’t realise just how much of an affect they can have on people. Body- image being the main negative affects but obviously there’s others such as pushing us to buy things or influencing on our behavior. Photoshop is a big offender in advertisements, making models unrealistically attractive setting up young women to make unrealistic goals. With my experiences with my own project and how easy it is to edit a photo. I considered maybe it’s just as easy to manipulate film or audio. Editing film could have huge affects on society and if it’s just as easy to learn like Photoshop is, multiple people could be editing and communicating false Audio and Film. By editing audio we could be hearing things that aren’t true, this could mean false evidence is being shown in legal cases. The same with film in that we are seeing false images, examples of these are people who have edited footage to make it look like there’s aliens or ghosts to scare people. Another huge example that we often forget about is movies, 90% of movies have special effects and are showing false images, this however is usually obviously communicated by the unrealistic stories such as Science Fiction films. But maybe documentaries could be editing their footage? All of these different types of contemporary media communications have the ability to communicate false information and just when is it too far and start becoming an ethical issue? By doing my project I have been able to think through all these questions and this has made me be much more careful when it comes to films I view, audio I hear or pictures I see.
sources: http://www.flickr.com/photos/80385419@N00/17910027/in/photolist-2zN2z-4RfhLf-9yAFs8-9yAFrM-9yDGGE-cd3bVm-f9tR8o-4p8kEc-6ybesw-7duQ27-5WJ9t9-6Q66HT-cpqJ1o-8vgCPF-6mvStS-fAhRMg-8BHjnX-6xAVCT-Le1ET-4vYHBR-9d75Bg-C9LUQ-5EPHJH-fbLK8U-f9yF15-815BRh-2rg2X-7ZUPeM-81B88v-8GHG6y-9qpZhz-b2wB68-7G5ce8-4pcqbo-azkvkU-9yDGFo-4pcpQE-yP9zX-ccDi6m-8QZRC7-6mYJDH-6mYDwP-6n3RrE-e6u7Lw-dK5f6w-6pG1rK-fzVnr3-4S3jm2-9uLTs-ei3kEW-8Kqzys
http://www.flickr.com/photos/33139070@N03/5024912083/in/photolist-8E2Zie-9B8y8V-5K1Qqh-a7i545-6LM1Pp-9eTFbA-8Jg8zX-8JjcBJ-9eTFaU-7hTH8f-7zK19v-7zNLjd-9kJbaa-5QRru6-d9JuAz-5QRq5R-f6dZti-5QVGyE-5QRqwX-5QRr1D-5QRqp6-do135V-7hPLD4-7hTHmE-7hTGQE-7hPLMD-7hPL7R-5QRpTX-5QRqBX-5QRpQa-5QRp32-5QVGv7-5QRqVr-5QVJtq-5QRqia-5QVHbC-5QRr7x-5QVHZY-5QRpwH-5QVGKq-5QRpb8-5QVHU3-5QVG33-5QRrpD-dqsrKk-5QRpKc-9fsPyT-4KVQfX-4L15ES-7hNYXX-bjxN5q
http://www.flickr.com/photos/91833118@N05/8344037949/in/photolist-dHknMg-6khSXZ-6id5Mv-efRHgb-6khTxR-7FSaRN-5x2NLG-dHkop2-6ihaVm-gs9MmL-dHkogT-aomu4J-4r6fbU-6igH13-6id3dZ-bDJc9q-bDJcgJ-bDJcju-6EKFvU-6ihbPo-9M11kd-bSCVAp-6icYtt-6id4re-6ihbgJ-6khJMP-6kn4jy-6ihamd-5pkBrQ-8hCE2J-2EGFVp-6khGk2-6oZebn-fC1MWs-4BuCWw-6icZXZ-8SJREZ-2EGGqR-6khGeM-7XFxgP-9foGNJ-bDJchw-6jT8Xe-9rdhqX-6khQ7c-9fjLWB-9fjK1k-9fnQnu-9fnRsj-9fjHfZ-9fjHPp













