I had a crazy idea!
Jackie choses Alex. Cole is left to deal with feelings and embarks in a journey to heal. But discovers something else about himself along the way!
A story where Cole finds out he’s bisexual could work beautifully in fanfic, because it blends romance, identity discovery, and drama with the Walter Boys family dynamic. Here are some ways you could frame it:
🌱 Coming-of-Age / Self-Discovery
The Crush He Didn’t Expect → Cole realizes he’s checking out a guy (could be Alex’s friend, a new student, or even someone in the Walter household orbit). At first, he brushes it off as admiration… until it isn’t.
Confession by Accident → He blurts something out (maybe to Kiley, Jackie, or Alex) about finding a guy attractive, and suddenly the secret is out before he’s even ready.
Family Reactions → The Walters are loud, protective, and opinionated. Some tease, some rally behind him, some need a minute—but in the end, they close ranks around him.
💔 Angst / Drama
Jackie Triangle → Jackie’s with Alex, but Cole develops feelings for someone else entirely (a guy). It forces him to confront that his love life is more complex than he thought.
First Heartbreak → His first relationship with a guy ends badly, and Cole has to work through the pain while also navigating being openly bi in a family where nothing is ever private.
Fear of Labels → He’s okay with liking both, but he hates the idea of being “pinned down” with a word. Cue lots of emotional late-night conversations with someone he trusts (maybe Kiley or Alex).
💕 Romance Options
Cole x Kiley, But… → He’s falling for Kiley and starting to notice guys—maybe even confiding in her about it. This could deepen their connection if she supports him.
Cole x Alex’s Friend (like Kiley’s male counterpart) → Instant drama. Imagine Cole catching feelings for a guy close to Alex—sparks tension with his brother and Kiley.
Cole x Outsider → A new kid in town who doesn’t know Cole’s whole “Walter Boys reputation” sees him for who he really is, and that unlocks something Cole hadn’t admitted to himself.
🎯 Themes to Explore
Impulsivity vs. Identity → Cole tends to act first, think later—so him realizing he’s bi could be chaotic and messy but heartfelt.
Found Family Support → The Walters are the perfect backdrop for both drama and comfort.
Romantic Chaos → Bisexuality adds layers to his already tangled love life—it could be angsty, comedic, or deeply emotional depending on tone.
