today I did a knitting experiment. I had a braid pattern I was trying out, but I was having a bit of trouble visualizing it from the written out instructions, so I drew a quick grid and charted it out (doing a second iteration of the repeat so as to see the full pattern more clearly)
I thought it was a little weird how the bits between the braid are a mix of knit and purl stitches (well they're all purl, since half are worked on the back side, but the result is a mix--) and wondered if it would work better if those were all the same. So I modified the pattern with that difference.
Left: Original pattern. Right: My update
And then of course I had to test that theory out in practice. Who knows, maybe there was a good reason for the way it was already! So I knit both versions, two repeats each. First the pattern as it was, and then with my update.
Left: front side. Right: back side
They don't look too different from the front, except that the edges of the braids look sharper on my version. My husband says it looks like I was having difficulty doing the stitch right for the first half and then figured out what I was doing for the second half.
On the back, it's a very clear difference. Less of a diamondy pattern and more of a sort of straight stitch with gaps. (also, looking at the first half, I did get some stitches twisted when switching from knit to purl.) I think both could have their uses, but I'm likely going to use the modified version for projects I want a brain on, especially if the back is not going to be very visible.