Hi! I just was wondering because I can't seem to fond a theory abput this but, has anyone considered that Sebastian could have been Vincents dog? On ch.17 p.4 the dogs not bleeding but has that same black aura, miasma ( not sure exactly what to call it. ) that Sebastian has. Maybe its another demon? What are your thoughts?
Some people actually *have* created theories about it, at least about Sebastian the demon possibly having been Vincent’s dog… but to me it’s just crack theory. If they were the same, Sebastian should know a lot more about the Phantomhive family, and it would help him to use that info to reach his goal faster. There’s nothing to suggest he had any prior knowledge about the family. Besides, according to the lyrics of “Phantom? Knight!” (Performed by the P5) the demon had been deep asleep when woken by the boy in the cage….
Sebastian the dog having been a different demon is only slightly more (not less) plausible. It would have to have faked its death that night until the boys were out of the manor, since the dog was seen looking quite dead next to Vincent and Rachel. (To me, that could just be the way Yana-san depicted the blood. It's hard to draw convincing blood spatter patterns.) It also would have to have not cared whether Vincent and Rachel died. If it had a been a demon with a contract with Vincent (or any of them), it should never have let any of this happen….
