Random 2am head canon: if you’ve ever had a dream about Caleb being unrealistically mean like cheating on you or calling you names he would refer to dream Caleb as evil Caleb.
You’d walk around him with a small pout not acknowledging him.
“Why’re you avoiding me?” He stepped in front of you.
“I’m not,”
“You are,” His finger reached out tapping your forehead. “You’ve been frowning all day. By this rate you’ll get wrinkles before your 40s,” He chuckled. “Really what’s bothering you pipsqueak,” With a huff, you crossed your arms.
“You called me ugly last night,” you grumbled. Caleb frowned. He didn’t speak his eyes widened slightly. “In my dream,”
“Jeez pipsqueak you scared me,” he sighed. He even bent down placing his hands on his thighs like you had winded him. So dramatic you thought. “I can’t believe he said that to you,” he said, standing up and ruffling your hair. “You’re adorable evil Caleb clearly doesn’t know what he’s talking about,”
“Evil Caleb?”
Caleb nodded. “Evil Caleb attacks you while you sleep,”
His words made you smile. It even made you forget all about evil Caleb's mean words.