Portus Fragrans
Dear Caroline:
You'll no doubt be acquainted that such is the (latin) translation of the city you loved and lived in for a couple of years. I don't know if today's Hong Kong is, indeed, a fragrant harbor, but you do seem to be sprinkling it with incense in this blog post of yours.
I would not like to belittle your adopted town's merits, and can believe that they adopted earlier and better measures when dealing with COVIT-19 than anybody else. One of the difficulties of learning from other cultures is that we cannot avoid cherrypicking, and this is an issue because in our real, dirty and grimy world, it is very seldom that you can transplant purely good stuff from a different culture into your own. Everything in culture is deeply entangled, and makes sense within the structure (I feel Henrich would be pretty supportive with me in this), and it comes with its own unavoidable negativities. Traditionally, Confucian cultures are very hierarchical, disciplined, meritocratic, appreciators of learning. While these traits can be seen as 'positive', they are incompatible with a very American (and partially also Western) deep individualism, disrespect of traditions, norms and rigid social orders and relations. This means we suck when it comes to taking quick and effective, top-down measures, but in the long run is more conducive to growth, prosperity, freedom and individual well-being.
You know which other Rationalists fell in love with the East? Well, many Enlightenment thinkers, actually, including Voltaire. For them, the Qing Dynasty was an example of the sort of secular, meritocratic, enlightened Despotism they were wishing at home, with themselves, of course, occupying the comfy places of mandarins instead of all those church bishops, archbishops and cardinals. It is not a theme that has completely melted away - one can still find books that extoll the rise of the Asian Tiger economies as based on Confucian values, and who look with longing eyes to the red sun raising over China. Later entries from your blog seem to show that you awoke not many months after this blog post from your Oriental dream, though.
Quote:
China is the wisest and best governed country in the world
Voltaire














