soloontherocks ha risposto al tuo post
“actually, i was talking about the man in the high castle adaptation...”
dont fuCKING SYMPATHIZE WITH NAZIS, JANE
I thought this was sarcasm. I checked your blog. it was obviously not sarcasm. okay then.
if you go on the official philip k. dick site there’s an entire article from the JERUSALEM REPORT MAGAZINE (http://www.philipkdickfans.com/mirror/articles/Jerusalem_Report_Magazine_pkd.htm HERE YOU GO) which talks.... in.... good.... terms about...... the man in the high castle..... and as far as I know it’s based in jerusalem and the author of that article is israeli so like, I dunno, consider that the man in the high castle is not pro-nazi and it’s fucking obvious since the protagonist is jewish but okay then
a) I haven’t even seen that show yet but I read the book ages ago and I don’t remember particularly sympathizing with any nazis but I remember it being a v. good book and I only heard good things about the show, also I was like twelve when I read it so when I re-read it before watching the show, which I definitely will, I’ll see who I sympathize with now
b) if the fictional nazi is criticizing the system he belongs to making you see his pov is also the point of that kinda book and if you can’t put yourself in discussion enough to actually see what’s the fucking point of a dystopian novel it’s not my problem
c) once I read an alternate dystopian WWII trilogy where I plenty sympathized with a Romani guy who spent book one working for the reich and doing things he hated for them after they experimented on him and turned him into some kind on x-man and he spent book two trying to make amends and regretting all the indoctrination he was going through, it’s the point of dystopias and the entire point was that nazis were the worst and this guy wouldn’t even have been one if he hadn’t been basically taken by force. but whatever, k, this thing shouldn’t have happened anyway because according to you alternate WWII history cannot exist;
d) have fun deleting AN ENTIRE BRANCH OF ALTERNATE HISTORY DYSTOPIAN LITERATURE THEN.
d1) among which there’s philp roth’s the plot against america, and roth is like... JEWISH.... but I guess he has some internalized antisemitism according to you?
e) given that I know my own politics, I know I’m nowhere near pro nazi so I’ll choose to enjoy whichever damned media I please. which by the way I haven’t even watched.
f) also oh, wait, I might have sympathized with edward norton’s character when I watched american history x aka one of the most anti-nazi movies in existence which accomplished the point using a former neonazi and his wannabe neonazi brother as povs and did it brilliantly, ops, sorry, my bad, I shouldn’t have? well, I still vote left and I still loathe nazism. hmmm?
tldr: I haven’t even seen this show but I will, we’ll see with whom I sympathize, the original source is completely anti-nazi and I’ve never seen anyone even think to imply that it was pro-nazi until y’all on tumblr started thinking that dystopias aren’t made to CRITICIZE THE SOCIETIES THEY DEPICT and I’m too old and too tired to hear this bullshit. learn to consume a piece of media, learn that if media wants you to challenge yourself and feel uncomfortable it doesn’t mean it’s BAD MEDIA and there’s a reason why disney movies are for children and not for adults, and if I may quote oscar wilde
there is no such thing as a moral or an immoral book. Books are well written, or badly written. That is all.
Paraphrasing: THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS A MORAL OR IMMORAL TV SHOW, TV SHOWS ARE WELL WRITTEN OR BADLY WRITTEN. and if they’re well-written they will not be pro-nazis but they’ll make people think.
also, if you look at it, most dystopias show up in periods of fucked up politics. I’m nowhere near surprised that the US under trump are producing dystopian stuff en masse. because usually people who see where it’s going WOULD LIKE TO WARN OTHERS OF HOW MUCH WORSE IT COULD BE.
please learn what a fucking dystopia is
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dystopia
aka a genre that the man in the high castle sure af hasn’t come up with or invented since it’s been here for centuries, learn that it never is from the side of the in-verse winning party at the beginning and for the love of whatever deity you believe in stop telling strangers online how they should consume their media or which FICTIONAL (IE NON EXISTING) CHARACTER they should feel sympathetic for because it’s their fucking business. bye.
also, if your reaction to this is reblogging with ‘omg you’re being pro-nazi’ I’d like to inform you that once I actually came this close to punching one irl, but I imagine you don’t care.