on a scale of 1-10 how much better/worse would you say the patrons are compared to the og dancestors? Like, would you say sov!cronus is a better or worse person than hs cronus? Etc. 10 being better 1 being worse and 5 being exactly the same
Ehh... That's hard to quantify on a numerical scale. I'd generally argue that they're substantially better/more tolerable, due to the fact that they don't have a billion years worth of postmortem brain rot, and aren't written by Hussie at a mental nadir. Some of their actions are worse, though, comparatively speaking, though they may be easier to stomach considering it won't be an incessant bullet hell-esque barrage as it is in canon. I say this with (somewhat unrecommended) love- we see the Alpha Trolls in such extremes because they had little to no screentime, and Hussie tends to introduce characters in exaggerated forms.
I can work with the Cronus example here. One could argue that Cronus is easier to stomach in Sovereignstuck than he is in canon, due to the facts that:
He's given significantly more screentime, which means more buffers between distasteful actions and more characterization, and...
He's smarter about how he goes about being, as Hussie puts it, The Worst, and is a lot more underhanded about it because he knows he won't get away with doing things full force and in public. His behavior in canon is brazen, unapologetic, and unhinged, and while he still has sprinklings of that in his character, it's nowhere near to the same extent- there's no reason why he would be as immediately severe as he is in canon.
We go all in on the mythological parallels. I find that oftentimes, when people have symbolism or parallels to chew on, things get a little easier to stomach. The ability to analyze why and how a character is the way they are, and why they're written the way they are really works wonders for the ability to withstand the things on screen. It stops being abuse porn, and starts being genuine story with some real drive behind it. Needless suffering is always hard to digest... But suffering with intention? That becomes intrigue. That is called conflict.
You could also argue that he's harder to stomach, because...
He's given significantly more screentime, which means more time to let the genuine gravity of his presence and actions sink in, and...
He's smarter about how he goes about being The Worst. For a lot of people, the ability to be conniving- or even just plain old stealthy- makes things scarier and more indefensible. It speaks to intention, and to knowing that the actions committed are wrong- or at least worthy of hiding. This is notably a canon feature- Cronus of Homestuck proper knows what he is doing, he knows it is wrong, and he does it anyways. We decided to keep this trait, because it is a remarkably unusual one for a person to have. And...
We go all in on the mythological parallels. If you're aware of the concept of Mituna's Myth of Cassandra and the role Cronus plays in it, you know what that means. We happen to handle it significantly more directly and with significantly more tact. Handling that kind of topic with care means stripping it of any levity. We also delve into how he ties into his namesake, because absolutely nobody else is doing that, and it makes me so angry. The missed potential... That's a rant for another day, though.
Yes, these are copy pasted on purpose. It really depends on your own personal perspective. It's a double edged sword in that way.
We try not to make him totally miserable to read, and especially not miserable to write- that would be self defeating. He serves more as a case study in the effects of extreme entitlement and toxic masculinity commingling, than Hussie's approach of... Creating a psyop, essentially. He's still going to provide ample discomfort no matter what. That's just the kind of conflict he brings to the story, mechanically speaking- there's no way to avoid that. Avoiding it would be cowardice.
If you're particularly interested in how we handle certain Patrons in comparison to their Beforan counterparts, I'm more than willing to throw some words your direction regarding that. The Alpha Trolls are fascinating in their level of mishandling, and most seem to fumble when reinterpreting them... More often than not, a lot of their edge is removed, and they become unrecognizable. Their roles and personalities are often made nebulous- more aesthetic archetypes than they are characters. Skins to place new personalities into, rather than their own defined person.
At the very least, we get the mercy of the Reincarnation mechanic. Fundamentally different people, fundamentally different setting, backstory, et cetera... But we're unconditionally opposed to the idea of stripping their most intriguing traits from them for the sake of digestibility, so... Be prepared for that at least, lol.