Spots to kiss + 11 between Agatha and Nellie. Author's choice if overtly romantic or not.
This was really cute and fun to write, and I hope you enjoy some oblivious wlw mutual pining. I don't know if this is entirely in character for Nellie yet because the story hasn't focused super hard on her relationship with Seer thus far, but I hope it's at least enjoyable even if it ends up being wrong.
11. a kiss on the corner of the mouth + Agatha/Nellie
In Agatha’s defense, she meant to kiss Nellie on the cheek. It was not intentional to accidentally bump into her crush’s nose and forehead so hard that Nellie almost fell into Anya on the couch. Anya, being seven and tack-sharp, moved out of the way like air, so when Nellie threw a hand down to catch herself, the youngest Cowles was safely out of the way.
“Shit—” Agatha started to say, cheeks burning furiously, as intense as if she’d just bitten the seed of a hot pepper.
Nellie just stared up, still half-reclined on the couch, and looking as if she couldn’t decide whether to be scandalized (a joke; Agatha was sure something like this wouldn’t actually ruffle Nellie’s feathers whatsoever) or just to outright laugh. “And here,” she said, laughter winning out, “I thought you’d be happy to see me.”
“I’m sosorry,” Agatha said, reaching towards Nellie to offer her a hand and verypointedly ignoring the whispering she could hear from elsewhere in the room. She could make out her sibling and at least two more people, but the embarrassed thrumming of her blood in her ears made it hard to tell anything more than that.
Normally, it would be easy to tell when Nellie was joking—it was one of the things Agatha liked most about her, after all—but the unfortunate truth about crushes is that the influx of oh fuck oh shit pretty person aaaaaa had a well-documented history of cutting off logic. So, Agatha continued as she grabbed Nellie’s hand halfway to pull her up, “I mean, um, I amhappy to see you—all of you! Agnes said you’d be here but, I mean, it’s still good. And I’m really sorry."
This time, Nellie did laugh, just a single chuckle, dark eyes crinkling warmly. “No harm done,” she said. As she spoke, she brought a finger up to swipe from Agatha’s nose out across her cheek. Checking to make sure she was okay, Agatha realized, and also making Nellie acutely aware of how hot her face was, never mind how it looked. Her breath caught in her chest as Nellie gave a satisfied smile. “Looks like the only thing that got broken was a little concentration, and we were due for a break anyway.”
Nellie glanced away, which was good for Agatha’s heart rate. What was not, however, was the fact that as they both realized that they had been left completely alone, Nellie also flushed. Agatha could count on one hand the number of times she’d seen that happen. And it was nothing dramatic, of course, since Nellie Cowles was not a woman easily flustered.
And yet.
“…We should go find them,” Agatha said, feeling like she should step back and yet not doing it.
“Probably,” Nellie agreed, but she didn’t step back, either.
For the briefest second, she glanced fully away, and then Agatha was too caught up in the weight of Nellie’s hand on her shoulder and the fact that Nellie was shifting up on her toes to notice anything else. Nellie kissed her on the cheek, a straightforward, firm-but-not-forceful sort of kiss, and it would have been so easy to brush it off as platonic if not for the fact that Nellie’s lips were only a hair’s breadth from Agatha’s. If Agatha shifted even a little—
But she didn’t. Even as Nellie smirked at her, eyes twinkling, and then stepped around her and out of the room to chase down their siblings, Agatha stayed put.
It…didn’t have to mean anything, she told herself. After all, she had missed when she went to kiss Nellie, so Nellie could have, too.
Could have.












