On revisiting the use of Christo, I agree it gets a pass because they were younger and still learning the business. It’s in later seasons where they seem to have forgotten how to handle a situation similar to one they had before that makes me wonder. Is it the writer’s inconsistency or are the writers showing us deliberate character mistakes? It’s sometimes implied they are getting burned out but their knowledge should always be demonstrated since they are now considered senior hunters.
Hi there! I actually don’t know exactly what situations you’re referring to here. Do you have specifics I can address? Because just speaking in vague terms like this, I’m not sure exactly what you mean. I’m happy to do my best to explain my personal understanding of whatever situations you feel might be them “forgetting” stuff they knew how to handle at some time in the past. :)
In the meantime, please enjoy this response from another anon on the same topic:
[ID: an ask message reading as follows:
Re Christo anon, I loved how they hung a lantern on that with Jack trying to get the lowdown on Harper during his solo hunt with Dean in 14x06 - it's a nifty tool for newbie hunters but you don't need it for all the reasons you laid out. /end ID]
AND OMG YES, how quickly I forgot 14.06, and Jack’s bumbling about learning hunting techniques. If we hadn’t also had 13.04 and 13.06, I would’ve wondered if it wasn’t just Dean (and maybe Sam, and even Cas) overpreparing Jack, telling him he must use all of the tools available to him so as not to leave him unprotected or unprepared. But because of those earlier episodes, we KNOW it was just Jack’s own personal lack of understanding about How To Hunt Properly combined with an excitable eagerness to prove he CAN handle a hunt and knows what he’s doing. Poor bab.
Like with the line of questions he asked of Athena in the funeral home in 13.06, about cold spots and stuff that had nothing to do with anything zombie-adjacent but immediately “outed” Jack as a hunter to the shifter, you know? Rookie mistake, but also one borne of his need to prove to Sam that he was a Good Hunter and Fit In. And even in 13.04, not understanding why they would need to lie about their identities and have a cover story to hide their true motives for being there. Jack is also still kinda shaky on the How To Human basics, along with the How To Hunt basics.
But you’re absolutely right, 14.06 really hits us over the head with it all. This is a fledgling hunter who hasn’t learned to narrow things down through conversation and context, and just throws everything he’s got at a wall to see if anything sticks. And all of this was underscored in fluorescent ink by his absolute social naivete, as well, in dealing with Harper. They were definitely using Christo as one of those “this dude has no idea what he’s doing and he’s gonna get himself killed ffs” warning flags, funny as it was. I mean, I remember posts after the episode first aired laughing at his awkward technique with both small talk with Harper, and bumbling attempts to slip in all the hunter tests to see if she was some sort of monster.
I mean, to make it any more awkward than it already was, he would’ve had to pour the holy water on her directly, you know? And the Christo felt like it was tacked on just in case anyone hadn’t yet figured that out. To US who have been watching for all these years, hearing that for the first time since 1.04 should’ve been a massive flashing warning sign in both directions-- both to the people like me who thought it was a hilarious example of Jack’s complete inexperience, and to the folks who have whined for years that it was some sort of magical demon tool that they stupidly never used again it served as a neon sign as to exactly WHY they never used it again... because it was stupid... :’D
That said, back to my original anon... if you do have a specific example, I’m happy to clarify my understanding of the thing, but without a bit more guidance I’m afraid I don’t know exactly what you mean. Feel free to reply to this (which I may or may not see, since I’m rarely on tumblr these days), or send another anon (which I will see eventually! I’m checking my inbox at least once a day) :)















