PSA: don’t eat your Halloween pumpkins!
I’ve seen multiple posts encouraging this, and while your standard big orange jack-o-lantern pumpkin is edible in the technical sense and certainly won’t make you sick, they are Not Tasty. If you roast one you’ll get stringy, watery, insipid glop. Don’t do this to yourself.
If you’re worried about pumpkin waste, you can:
Compost your pumpkins (bear in mind that unless you take very exacting care of your compost pile and monitor its temperature, seeds can survive and sprout the next year! I have experienced so many Mystery Squash from insufficiently heated compost)
Roast the seeds for a tasty snack and compost the shell (especially if you’re carving the pumpkin, but consider this even if you aren’t!)
If you or a friend has chickens, give them the pumpkin as a treat
If you DO want something that does double duty as decoration and delicious food, there are a lot of squash that fit the bill!! You just need to look beyond the standard big orange pumpkin. There are too many wonderful squash varieties to list here, but a lot of cucurbita maxima and cucurbita moschata varieties are both beautiful and have excellent table quality. Try “cheese pumpkins,” Cinderella pumpkins, various Hubbards, Buttercups, Kabocha, and more! They come in a dazzling array of shapes and colors.
If you want to eat your decorative squash, don’t leave it outside if there’s any danger of frost. However, they will keep at room temperature for months and the flavor will only improve after a month or two of storage.
Alternatively, consider heirloom gourds! These aren’t edible, but if you’re careful (maintaining consistent cool temperatures and either hanging them or rotating them every couple of weeks) you can dry gourds until they are stiff and hollow and then use them for long-term decoration or a basis for craft projects!











