With its long and intriguing past, it's not surprising the this old Lighthouse in St. Augustine has a strong and validated haunted reputation. Many who have dared to explore it, worked in it, and even those that live close by, have reported experiencing something that is extraordinarily mysterious. Often times it cannot be explained. Many call it one of the most haunted lighthouses in the world!
Most popular tales of its phantoms are actually sourced to its former keepers. One story is that the smell of cigar smoke is the first lighthouse keeper. The second lighthouse keeper fell to his death while painting the outside of the lighthouse and you can see him looking out from the top of the lighthouse.
Another story is that of the two young sisters who died on the property. Hezekiah Pity was hired to renovate the tower in the late 1800s. His daughters, Eliza and Mary, were playing inside a cart that was being used to carry materials back and forth to the lighthouse. When the cart broke loose, they weren't able to jump out in time and the cart slid rapidly into the bay, plummeting both girls to a watery death. Today and most days since then, the girls can be heard laughing at the top of the tower late at night. Others have spotted Eliza floating about the grounds wearing the same blue dress she died in.
