tartapplesauce replied to your post “empathy vs action”
This is a good point about empathy versus action, but sometimes there are things you can't do anything about, and some things JGY did not tell them because it was a choice between "do this and get/keep power, or don't do it and lose my status" and he chose status Some things you can’t intervene it. JGY is an adult, how do you tell the wife of the Sect Leader “stop hating the son of your husband’s mistress, stop being physically and verbally violent to him”? LXC and NMJ have no status there to make her stop, or get Jin Guangshan to make her stop, and every other sect will not approve interfering in personal family matters.
Yeah, I agree that they didn’t know EVERYTHING obviously, but like when it comes to Jgy “choosing” status??? The problem was, in his mind, he didn’t have much of a choice! His only options were a) maintain status by doing what his dad told him while getting beat by madam jin OR b) not do those things and...... be homeless??? like, he didn’t really have any wealth of his own, he wasn’t a talented cultivator that could just go rogue or join another sect, he couldn’t just leave and buy a house for himself and have a comfortable life somewhere. it was either do the shitty things his dad made him do, or... live on the street? find someone else to take him in and boss him around????
and for sure, lxc and nmj might not have been able to tell off the Jins (tho nmj doesn’t seem to have a problem telling people off on occasion), but they also could have done SOMETHING even if that something was just reassuring Jgy that he would have some place to go if he wanted to leave the Jins--because as far as we know, they didn’t do that! we know lxc KNOWS that jgy was getting physically abused, but did he do anything other than offer jgy sympathy? and nmj was too pissed off to even know that was happening!
obviously, things happen the way they happen for Plot Reasons, i just think it’s an interesting polarization. if Ixc, who genuinely cared about jgy, had taken steps to ACT on that concern, it would have given jgy a way out, and if nmj had been able to understand where jgy was coming from, i feel like he would have done SOMETHING to help the situation.
this also probably applies more broadly to the world at large when it comes to interpersonal interactions and social justice! in order to help others, we can’t just act OR be empathetic, we have to do both!










