[op note: dont rb this with a discourse content warning or im going to block you] ik i rbed a lot and basically hid my tags but i do completely stand by them. we all have biases it came with existing and theres just. i dunno like okay lemme put this in perspective
ignoring (and its hard to ignore) the biases that guided the bloodymary ship, i am someone who struggled to watch iron lung. i am extremely bad with horror, and only got through it because my friend told me everything, including when to look away. i dont actively seek out iron lung content- hell, not even following the tag- because it is a horror media and i dont want horror content on my dash.
i follow project hail mary because i liked it a lot. psychologically did something to me, was very well done, and gave me much joy! its an incredible film, and the things ive heard about the book make me like that too, although i havent gotten access to reading it yet.
the most content ive seen of grace not involving simon comes from a mutual who im 99% sure blocked the tag. stratt is rare to appear on my dash, let alone carl. every crossover is tagged with both fandoms, which does make sense, but becomes an issue because most works i see with a media i enjoy has to be put side by side with a horror media i can really only appreciate. if i block the bloodymary tag (which i dont mind the ship, my reason is coming up for my issue), i lose most the grace content on my dash. i also dont mind seeing simon, and i found iron lung very interesting! what i stomached was a good fucking movie! and yet im not seeking to look at simon much because im here for grace. and yet, people will tag both characters by name, because surely everyone going into grace and/or simons tag are a fan of the ship! and i literally am! but im tired! im really tired! im here for grace! add in the fact that this is a character who is, quite frankly, almost explicitly aro-ace, being put together with a guy from a media that happened to release semi close?
if the reason they were together was solely because of their close release date, why not barbenhiemer? or other films released in close proximity?
and of course, the post is supposed to be focused on the biases around ignoring carl and stratt, and i admit, the side tracking to ace erasure is in a way a form of bias (im queer, i focus on queer-based issues, which means that can get in the way of looking at and focusing on other big issues- not an excuse, but a bias!). but it does drive you a little insane at some point. honestly, the big thing i disagreed with op on doing was tagging "cw racism", mainly because its wild how often people equate any amount of criticisms to "fandom issues". calling out things like racism arent just "discourse". asking someone to tag a post with fandom racism for "those who are just here for the joy and find discourse stressful" is a weird statement and gross for a bunch of reasons. if you cant handle the discomfort of being racist subconsciously and equate addressing it to some fandom-based issue and not something bigger, youre being gross.
the most stratt content ive seen is from mutuals who focus on her, and they rarely come in. i see next to nothing on carl. i could follow those tags, and i do want to! its just... maybe i shouldnt have to force my experience to focus on the characters in the media? a ship doesnt make you racist or anti-racist, sure, but lets do a thought experiment: how much do you remember of graces interactions with carl? or stratt? how much of either of their characters can you think of? are they more than tropes and baseline ideas? compare that to how you think of grace and simons relationship. do you think their relationship is deeper than with stratt and/or carl? if you answered yes to the last question, ill hold your hand to remind you: there is nothing in text that can prove their relationship to be deeper, because it does not exist. it doesnt have to, but canon made the characters and influences the way they act, you have to consider canon a little bit, otherwise you just want ocs.
theres a level of insanity here like. for the minimal amount of time we see anybody in project hail mary, its obvious how much story was thought for them, from the bigger parts of the project like stratt and carl, to even those who were before on the hail mary pre-wakeup. its a detail in the movie i really admired, everyone isnt just a named body to be sad over, but real people with families and beliefs. stratt, while needing to be stoic for the mission, has a comedic air to her at times (the two coffees) and is far from a heartless or cold person (if the karaoke scene didnt establish enough). she needs to be that kind of person, the serious and in-charge leader, because in a poetic sense she has to act inhumane to save humanity, lose her own to give humanity more of theirs. she doesnt act with any pure malice, just as someone who is rightfully taking the steps needed, ethics be damned, to save earth from dying. carl is in a similar position, but we see it differently. carl is mostly in charge of (correct me if im wrong, i only have been able to see this movie once) making sure grace has what he needs as the scientist behind this situation. that doesnt mean he doesnt know a joke, and has a lot of care for grace. they spend a lot of time together and connections are made between them! both are characters who spent a lot of time with grace, are complex regardless of their connection to him, and are so interesting to look at with him! so why is it that i see nothing! why is it mostly the guy from another universe! not even platonic, although at some point you accept that people just dont want to think of a dynamic not kissing unless theyre family (parental or sibling, "coded" or not). i feel like i know why people dont want to focus on grace with stratt or him with carl, and when theres such a strong idea of the closeness that the power of friendship provides? im unsure how to feel anymore. i dont know how people stand it.
above all else, just think: isnt it a little weird how when you saw a character content and happy when being single, you crossed universes to fix that? why does it have to be "let people have fun" if your escapism has to include ignoring rep?













