actually it remains patently insane to me that it's a fact that thingol and melian are just out there in valinor and very much have the capacity if not the desire to create more unprecedented part-elf part-cosmic demiurge babies. and it remains a very amusing headcanon of mine that everyone including the valar are perpetually uneasy whenever they witness or hear about thingol and melian getting canoodly with each other because everybody fears the seismic waves another demigod gremlin will make in the fabric of arda. like luthien already shattered the ceiling with enough force to atomize the pieces left in her wake, please do not subject the world to the chaos and confusion of a little sibling thingol and melian listen to us look here you two PLEASE
more seriously, i think they might joke about or seriously discuss it but at the end of the day they don't want to have any more kids. it's not just that the creation of another such being is too taxing on their spirits, but also that they understand that deep down they would be looking for their daughter and trying to fill the hole she left in their hearts, and that wouldn't be fair to her nor to the hypothetical child












