Another problem of Toby Pie being a Trollhunter amulet wielder is:
In the beginning Jim and Tobs survived and were not killed by Bular straight away only because there was personally involved Stricklander. He liked Jim, he was his favorite student. So Strickler did his best to prolong Jim’s live and negotiate somehow (until it started affecting his morals). It gave Jim time to do some learning and reveal some mysteries.
And who’s Toby to Strickler? Eh nobody. Lonely orphan with shady semi demented granma. Two people will notice if he disappears. Kill him asap Bilar and bring eternal night to rule humans! What a plot twist right? Even earlier meeting with Barbara won’t fix it.














