I Wish They Stayed Platonic Tournament - Round 1 - Poll 39
Who would you like to have stayed platonic?
Philip Digby and Zoe Webster (Trouble Series by Stephanie Tromly)
Quentin Coldwater and Alice Quinn (The Magicians)
This tournament is not meant to cause any shipwars or spread hate. Please stay kind when sharing your opinions on the submitted ships.
Vote in the other polls here
Why people wished they stayed platonic:
Philip Digby and Zoe Webster
(Spoilers for the Trouble series) What was once a fantastic friendship with a lot of page time dedicated to it and some real chemistry, immediately went downhill once the two kissed at the end of book one. The chemistry and engaging relationship is lost completely. The characters no longer just spend time together and therefore feel distant. What time they do spend together (that is not spent on plot) is dedicated to love triangles, jealously, and Zoe being upset with Digby because of these things. This leads to an utter loss of what made the relationship engaging in the first place.
Quentin Coldwater and Alice Quinn
I dont want to erase the first time they dated in the show, but I do think they should have stayed platonic after they broke up instead of eventually getting back together. The show showed us time and time again why they were bad for each other, that they were happier as just friends, and them getting back together felt right out of left field.













