Pairing: Yandere!Preacher x Reader
Description: You’ve been paraded before the world as a miracle—reborn, beloved, and serene—while inside, you ache with the silent horror of knowing he’s not done with you yet. Beneath white silk and hollow smiles, you brace for the future he’s already decided: one where even your womb belongs to him.
Warning/s: Yandere | Implied Noncon | Implied Breeding | Captivity | Psychological Manipulation | Emotional Trauma | Forced Worship | Identity Erasure | Dissociation | Religious Delusions
Note/s: Yaay! We're finally about to return to regular programming. Jk. I'll be very busy in the next couple of days to work on Sovereign's Reign's ebook as well as Runes of Escape. Still commissions are open (I'm broke af at this point T^T)!
Prequel: The Procession
Masterlist | Series Masterlist | Commission | Tip Jar | Dark Roast 50% Off
The sunlight doesn’t warm you—it presses. Heavy, white-hot, blinding. You feel it baking into your scalp through the veil they pinned too tightly this morning. A cluster of pins digs into your temple, and for a moment, all you can focus on is the slow bloom of pain behind your left eye. But you don’t flinch. You’ve learned stillness. You’ve been taught the performance.
They call it rebirth.
They call it a miracle.
But all you feel is a kind of quiet horror, rising beneath your ribs like cold water.
The air is thick with rose petals and incense. Both cling to your skin, powdery and sweet, making your lungs ache. Your dress—white, of course—is long and flowing, the silk too heavy for the spring heat. Sweat beads at your lower back, slipping slowly beneath layers of fabric. You breathe evenly. You smile faintly. You do not fidget. Not when cameras flash like strobe lights. Not when people cry at the sight of you.
Victor’s hand is wrapped around yours. Gentle. Possessive. His thumb strokes slow, adoring circles over your knuckles. To the crowd, it’s tenderness. To you, it’s the leash.
“My children,” he says, voice rising like a hymn. “We have waited. We have wept. We have wondered if light could ever return to us…”
His voice is music. You’ve heard it in your sleep, through speakers in the walls. You’ve heard it through doors and drugs and dreamless nights. It no longer shocks you how easily he can weep for others. How his eyes glitter with conviction.
“But love,” Victor continues, lifting your joined hands toward the sky, “is stronger than despair. Love cannot die. And today—before you all—this love is returned to us in the flesh.”
The crowd erupts. Cheers. Cries. Chants. Some collapse to their knees, hands outstretched, desperate to touch your hem like you’re a saint. A few are pressed so close to the gate that you wonder if they’re breathing. The gates stay shut. Security lined along the perimeter, robbed in white and gold like angels armed with silent weapons.
You smile on cue.
“My beloved,” Victor says, turning to you, voice soft now, almost reverent. “Tell him what love has given you.”
Your mouth opens, and the words come, slow and deliberate. The same lines you’ve whispered into the dark a hundred times. The same lies you’ve polished into prayer.
“I was lost… and he found me.”
“I was broken… and love made me whole.”
“I was nothing. Now I am reborn.”
They weep.
You breathe.
Victor leans in, so close only you can hear. His breath brushes your ear like a benediction. “You sound perfect.”
You feel hollow. You feel like glass. And yet you stand there, radiant beneath the burning sun, while strangers fall to their knees and call it grace.
They don’t know the price.
They don’t know the pit you climbed out of.
They don’t know it was him who buried you in the first place.
And you smile.
Because if you don’t—if you slip—there are things worse than dying again.
• ─────⋅☾ ☽⋅───── •
Later, when the sun has mellowed and your smile is no longer needed, they allow you to walk the garden. The “Sacred Garden,” Victor calls it. A secluded space framed by marble columns and flowering trees, its gravel path winding like a labyrinth. You know the security team lingers somewhere behind the hedges. You’ve seen their shadows, caught the glint of lenses in the leaves. They never stop watching. Even now.
The scent here is real. Less perfumed, more organic. Soil. Leaves. The pale bloom of jasmine climbing the trellis. The wind moves through the trees in a whisper, lifting your skirt and teasing loose strands of hair. You cling to that breeze like it might carry you away. It doesn’t.
Ahead, a young woman kneels by a rosemary bush. She startles when she sees you, then quickly bows her head.
“My lady,” she says, breathless. “You’re walking.”
You nod, hands folded neatly at your front. “Only for a little while.”
“I didn’t think I’d ever see you,” she says, still kneeling, eyes bright with awe. “You’re real.”
You want to say yes. You want to say no. You want to take her by the shoulders and ask her how long she’s been here, how long she’s believed. If she remembers who she was before this place filled her lungs.
Instead, you kneel beside her, carefully, smoothing your dress as you lower yourself. The ground is warm beneath your knees.
“What’s your name?” you ask.
“Evi.”
“Evi.” You let her name roll across your tongue like something fragile. “You have kind eyes.”
She blushes furiously. “I pray for you. Every night. I—I hope that’s not wrong. I just want to be near your light.”
You force yourself to hold her gaze, to let her see kindness in your eyes. “It’s not wrong.”
Evi smiles, and you feel her faith press against you like a vice. Not because she’s naïve—but because she’s certain. She believes in you more than you ever did in yourself.
You reach for the rosemary, pluck a sprig, and press it between your fingers. Its scent is sharp, earthy, real.
“When I was in the dark,” you say quietly, “I dreamed of a garden. I didn’t know it was here. Maybe your prayers led me to it.”
Evi’s eyes shine with tears.
You leave her there, clutching rosemary, bowing her head like she’s touched God.
And all you can think as you walk away is: I have to keep pretending. For her. For everyone. If I stop pretending, I’ll shatter. And if I shatter… he’ll build me again. But worse.
• ─────⋅☾ ☽⋅───── •
The night, the room is cold.
It always is. Victor claims it helps you sleep better. “Still air,” he calls it. “Holy air.” You think it’s just another way to keep you quiet.
He brushes your hair at the vanity. You sit silently, watching him in the mirror. His fingers are careful, almost gentle, like he’s afraid you’ll fade if he’s too rough.
“You were breathtaking,” he says softly. “When you smiled… I felt the whole world pause.”
You don’t respond. You focus on the pressure of the brush against your scalp, the cool metal of the chair under your thighs.
“Do you remember what you said?” he asks. “When you first woke up?”
You don’t.
“You said, ‘Am I new?’” His voice softens even more. “You were.”
He sets the brush down, turns you to face him.
“You are.”
Victor takes your hands and kisses your knuckles, one by one. “Everything before… it was just the womb. Pain. Noise. Emptiness.”
He presses your palm flat against his chest. His heartbeat is steady. Real. Human. Terrifying.
“But now,” he whispers, “we’re going to create something that lives forever.”
Your stomach twists.
He leans in, lips at your temple.
“Next Easter,” he says, his voice soaked in awe, “they won’t just witness resurrection. They’ll witness a birth.”
You go still.
Victor smiles against your skin, reverent.
“It’s time for the world to know what our love can create.”
And just like that, you silence becomes a scream you cannot release.
