Ok ok so no threesomes no chucking but a secret third option. Exhibitionismmmmm :)
Dex sets everything up to make it look like he’s kidnapped you and he will hurt you. Matt is rubbing around town freaking out desperate to find you. Finally tracks down what sounds like your voice moaning in pain (?) and Oh my! It’s you getting dicked DOWNNN. Being an Active and Enthusiastic Participant. Bouncing on it crrrrazy style. Doing that freaked out daredevil role play moaning shit like “Matt since when are you this big?” and “only Dex gets to come inside”
Dex making direct eye contact with Matt who’s clutching his pearls standing frozen in the doorway while you’re too fucked out to even notice him there.
Poor Matt is being held at gunpoint in an imaginary love triangle Dex is delusional enough to believe and you’re too horny and desperate to correct 😭
why did i not think of this as an option omg. yess
guys we're almost there, i can feeeeel it in my bones. i'm starting out part five as we speak, but i can tell this chapter is going going to take awhile to flesh out.