Fanfiction/ Mini-Fic Idea
So, I was rewatching the first season of Big Little Lies and was particularly interested in the scenes between Celeste (Nicole Kidman) and her wry, plain-speaking therapist, Dr. Amanda Reisman (Robin Weigert).
****Spoiler alerts ahead for Big Little Lies***
Dr. Reisman first meets Celeste and her abusive husband, Perry, for couples counseling, then just meets with Celeste since Perry is too "busy with work". Dr. Reisman is firm that for Celeste's safety and that of her two young children, she needs to leave Perry.
The thought occured to me, what if Hannibal Lecter was Celeste's therapist? I could imagine Hannibal being immediately suspicious of Perry upon meeting him in the one time that Celeste and Perry go his office for couples' counseling. When Celeste returns to continue therapy alone with Hannibal, I could imagine him genuinely wanting to help Celeste and being concerned for her safety. He thinks that men who abuse women and children are the lowest kinds of pigs. I can see him asking Celeste some the exact same questions that Dr. Reisman asked her, firmly but with compassion:
"Are you physically afraid of him?"
"Do you think violence is normal in relationships? When this violence occurs, have you ever been afraid you might die?"
"When are you going to leave him, Celeste? When he hurts you badly enough? When he hurts the children?"
Hannibal maintains a calm demeanor, but is inwardly seething with rage at Perry's physical, emotional and sexual abuse of Celeste and even considers killing Perry himself, but thinks it would be more "beneficial" and "therapeutic" if Celeste did it instead.
He matter-of-factly discusses with Celeste a plan for her to rent her own apartment for herself and the children to escape to. Celeste is uneasy with the suggestion, telling him "I have to say, I'm getting a bit uncomfortable. I think this is unethical"
Hannibal responds smoothly "I throw off the ethical chains when I sense a patient is in danger".
As an expert psychiatrist, Hannibal also knows that the most dangerous time for a battered woman is after she ends the relationship. He thinks it would be more practical if Celeste killed Perry pre-emptively instead.
During their sessions, he very gradually hints and insinuates that things would be much easier for Celeste if Perry was dead. Then she wouldn't have to worry about Perry's violence anymore, an ugly divorce, custody battles, fighting over child support and alimony. She wouldn't even have to move out of her house. She would be free and her sons would never need to know the truth about their father.
When Celeste finally realizes what Hannibal is actually suggesting, she is shocked and alarmed:
She flees from his office, and Hannibal thinks maybe he pushed her too fast. Celeste is definitely disturbed by what Hannibal said but can't help thinking maybe he was right and is appalled at herself.
Soon afterwards, Hannibal hears about Perry's "accidental" death on the news and is pleasantly surprised when he watches the press conference on TV, hearing that "the victim suffered from right-rib fractures, a shattered pelvis, fractured base of the skull and lower vertebrae". Hannibal smiles slightly, thinking "Well, well. Maybe she did heed my good advice after all"