How to Bring the Utopian Parallel Back
If you’re familiar with America Chavez then you’re probably aware that she had her backstory retcon in comics. Originally she was from an alternate alien dimension known as the Utopian Parallel created by future Billy Kaplan AKA Wiccan. Now those memories of the Utopian Parallel were revealed to be false and trauma-based. In reality she was an ill human girl that was experimented on along with other girls including her sister, and her moms sacrificed themselves by blowing the facility up.
Personally I have mixed feelings about the retcon. It’s unfortunate that America’s unique backstory that was a celebratory symbol of BIPOC women was traded in for a generic superhero backstory. On the other hand I am super relieved I don’t have to hear those “well she’s not really Puerto Rican” arguments as if anyone would ever tried to argue Clark Kent isn’t a white boy from the Midwest.
I believe the best way to bring the Utopian Parallel back is to create a mixture of both backstories that’ll leave America Chavez being more empowered than ever. What if she got Billy Kaplan’s help and with the mix of her dimension portal opening powers and his magic reality warping powers they created the Utopian Parallel together. It’s through her sheer will and imagination she create her own little pocket dimension the way she always thought solely Billy would be responsible for when in all actuality she was always just as much the demiurge as Billy is if not more. The place could also be a sanctuary for all of the girls that were experimented and trapped on the facility same as her.
From this point forward there’s different ways you can go about it. For instance America could’ve always been the Demiurge and it’s a chicken or the egg situation. Does it make complete sense? No, but it’s comics. Who cares? Maybe it’s ties in to the chamber the mad scientist kept the girls in. Or this can be an entire new separate utopian parallel. This could also paved the way for her sister Catalina’s redemption arc by having her decide to stay in the Utopian Parallel and take care of all the little girls and teach them how to use her powers. What do you think?
TL;DR Use America & Billy’s powers to create the Utopian Parallel together, but it’s America’s willpower and imagination making her the true Demiurge

















