2015 WAEDC Log Check Report
“汝、減点簿に目を塞ぐなかれ。然してこれを公表せしめ、以って明日への礎石とすべし”
8月に行われたWAEDCのLog Check Reportが早くもやって来た。本コンテストも厳密なログチェックを行う方針に変わったようだ。WPXと同様、ナンバーのミスであってもマルチごと召し上げるという情け容赦ない&血も涙もない減点方式だ(もちろんそれが正しいんだけどね)。
Wrong Callsign : 4 (0.8%)
Wrong Serial Number : 22 (4.2%)
Claimed Score = (521_QSOs + 497_QTCs) x 215_Mult = 218,870
Final Score = (495_QSOs + 497_QTCs) x 200_Mult = 198,400(-9.35%)
かなり厳しいコンディションだったとは言え(それと正直に言うとWAEのログチェックは緩いと思って舐めていた部分があったとは言え)エラー率5%は酷い。修練が必要なのはもちろんだが、運用方針の見直しも(このチェックを前提として)必要だろう。
以下の “5a) List of 'Unique' or 'Rare' calls left unchanged in your log”もエラーの可能性を含んでいるが、減点は行われていない。先日行われたCQWWのアンケートでは、「今後はミスコピーとみなして予めスコア計算から除外することに賛成か?」との質問があった部分だ。(私はこの処置はどちらかと言えば公平性を高める方向に作用すると考えて賛成を投じた)
(2015 WAEDCのレポート等はこちら。1、2、3)
---- Your Log Check Report --------------------------------------------- This report is divided into several sections. 1. Your claimed score as per summary sheet QSOs, QTCs, Multipliers => 218.87 2. Your raw score as calculated after log conversion and removing duplicate and EU/EU or DX/DX contacts before log checking took place: Band QSOs QTCs Mul 80 m 0 0 0 40 m 73 23 75 20 m 291 319 76 15 m 157 155 64 10 m 0 0 0 Total 521 497 215 ==> 218.870 80 m: 40 m: 4O 9A DL ES EU F HA I LX LY LZ OE OH OK OM ON S5 SM SP UA UA2 UR YL YO YU 20 m: 4O 4U1I 9A CT DL E7 EA EI ES EU F G GJ GM HA HB I IT9 JW LX LY LZ OE OH OK OM ON OZ PA S5 SM SP UA UA2 UR YL YO YU 15 m: 4O 9A CT DL E7 EA EI ER ES F G GJ HA I IT9 LX LY LZ OE OH OK OM ON PA S5 SM SP UA UA2 UR YO YU 10 m: 3. Errors, removed from your log 3a) Wrong callsign or wrong serial number in QSO. The number on the left side of the != sign is what you had in your log, the number on the right is what's in the other station's log. UTC Band/Mode QSO Callsign Call/Exchange --------------------------------------------------- 0625Z: 15 C # 21 RK3ER 0203!=223 0627Z: 15 C # 25 4O3A 0281!=0293 0700Z: 15 C # 35 S50A 0196!=296 0701Z: 15 C # 36 HG7T 0375!=0365 0726Z: 15 C # 47 EC2DX 0046!=0467 0733Z: 15 C # 50 9A1G 9A1P 0734Z: 15 C # 51 OE3K 0253!=0263 0905Z: 15 C # 60 OL5T OL5Y 1007Z: 15 C # 85 RW1A 0114!=0214 1049Z: 15 C # 92 S56A 0161!=0171 1525Z: 20 C # 194 HB9ARF 0206!=0226 1530Z: 20 C # 197 4O4A 4O3A 1539Z: 20 C # 200 S50A 0501!=401 1635Z: 20 C # 234 OZ7BQ 0279!=0079 1757Z: 40 C # 279 9A5Y 0497!=0397 1814Z: 40 C # 287 OM3GI 0369!=0379 1814Z: 40 C # 288 9A1P 0477!=0378 1039Z: 15 C # 335 OH5TS 0247!=0257 1051Z: 15 C # 339 DL8DWW 0302!=308 1441Z: 20 C # 369 DL1GBQ 0418!=0318 1503Z: 20 C # 383 OH2BN 0085!=095 1533Z: 20 C # 398 HB9BUN 0522!=0422 1635Z: 20 C # 423 IZ2FNI 0099!=29 1703Z: 20 C # 432 UV3QF 0037!=137 1811Z: 20 C # 460 OK1KZ 0004!=104 2000Z: 40 C # 516 DL2DQL DL3DQL Lost: 26
3b) Wrong callsign in QTC-to or QTC-from field: UTC Band QTC Callsign True Callsign ------------------------------------------------- Lost: 0 3c) Unverifyable QSOs (not in log or wrong band / wrong mode reported), removed from your log: UTC Band/mode QSO Callsign Reason ------------------------------------------------------------- Lost: 0 3d) Transfer errors in QTCs. The receiving station loses credit for a QTC which was not transferred correctly. The transmitting station loses credit if the QSO is not found in the log the way it was transmitted. We compare QTC group nr, time, callsign and serial number here. 'No match in existing log' maybe can mean, that a received QTC was transmitted to another station. UTC Callsign Your Log Other Log ------------------------------------------------------------- Lost: 0 3e) QSOs and QTCs found in violation of the 10 minute QSY rule in effect for the Multi OP category: UTC Call QTC tx rx Band ------------------------------------------------------------- Lost: 0 3f) QSOs and QTCs found in violation of the 12 hour offtime rule in effect for the Single OP category: UTC Call QTC Band ------------------------------------------------------------- Lost: 0 and 0 QTCs 3g) QSOs and QTCs removed due to other reasons UTC Call QTC Band ------------------------------------------------------------- Lost: 0 3h) Duplicate contacts or contacts you asked us to remove: UTC Band/mode QSO Callsign Reason ------------------------------------------------------------- 0650Z: 15 C # 30 RT4F Dupe: prev QSO at 2015-08-08 06:23:00 with Nr: 0020 1456Z: 20 C # 172 RN4NF Dupe: prev QSO at 2015-08-08 13:49:00 with Nr: 0151 1751Z: 20 C # 450 OE/DL1AMH Dupe: prev QSO at 2015-08-09 17:36:00 with Nr: 0444 1822Z: 20 C # 468 IR2C Dupe: prev QSO at 2015-08-08 15:39:00 with Nr: 0199 Lost: 4 4. Your final score after log checking applied: Band QSOs QTCs Mul 80 m 0 0 0 Lost: 40 m 69 23 72 Lost: 9A 20 m 281 319 72 Lost: 4O OZ 15 m 145 155 56 Lost: 4O EA OE OH 10 m 0 0 0 Lost: Total 495 497 200 ==> 198.400 80 m: 40 m: 4O DL ES EU F HA I LX LY LZ OE OH OK OM ON S5 SM SP UA UA2 UR YL YO YU 20 m: 4U1I 9A CT DL E7 EA EI ES EU F G GJ GM HA HB I IT9 JW LX LY LZ OE OH OK OM ON PA S5 SM SP UA UA2 UR YL YO YU 15 m: 9A CT DL E7 EI ER ES F G GJ HA I IT9 LX LY LZ OK OM ON PA S5 SM SP UA UA2 UR YO YU 10 m: The score reduction in percent is: -9.35% 5. For your information: 5a) List of 'Unique' or 'Rare' calls left unchanged in your log: UTC Band/mode QSO Callsign -------------------------------------- 1229Z: 15 C # 117 F6CLH 1723Z: 20 C # 254 DJ0FX 1724Z: 20 C # 255 DF1SD 1730Z: 20 C # 261 DL/OE2BVG/P 0821Z: 15 C # 297 DL3YA 1714Z: 20 C # 434 YU1DU 1736Z: 20 C # 444 OE/DL1AMH 1812Z: 20 C # 462 SP9LCW 1813Z: 20 C # 463 OE/DL1AGS 1817Z: 20 C # 466 OK2AP 1936Z: 40 C # 502 DL2AWB 5b) List of QSOs where your callsign was copied wrong by the other station (QSO removed in his log): UTC Band/Mode QSO Callsign Copied you as... -------------------------------------------------------- 1349Z: 20 C # 151 RN4NF JF3KNA 1700Z: 20 C # 245 EI1Y JF3NKT