Well this was depressing to read.
The only good thing I can say about it really is that it wasn’t as totally awful as I feared it would be.
Still really bad. Barely tries to even at all dispute the idea that you should hate everyone different to you and, for those wondering, no, there is not even a slight element of ambiguity to the T’au until the postscript addendums, in the actual story, and with the characters, the T’au are just 100% evil constantly.
Also the lady T’au’s big evil plan was...selling T’au technology to humans without the T’au Empire’s consent.
I also love the part where we get the girl, Zelia, basically condemning the T’au as evil because they let the ‘Savage’ and ‘Primitive’ Kroot into their Empire.
Yep. That’s what we need. Type-casting ‘savages’ as inherently evil compared to the Imperium’s oh-so-civilized glory.
It even ends with Zelia explicitly thinking to herself the T’au Empire is no better than the Imperium because, you know, what’s an official policy of wiping out all other sapient life compared to not doing that? Clearly that’s a trivial and absolutely unimportant detail.
I had really hoped the book would, for children, try to actually teach a lesson about getting along with people outside your own sphere, understanding that you shouldn’t hate something just for being different and that people can communicate but...no. That’s not what we got.
If this was just another Black Library book it would be one thing, I’d be upset but that’s okay, but this is marketed for children and so I am honestly disgusted by it.
The only moment of empathy for Xenos comes at the very end of the book, when an Inquisitor froths at the mouth and refuses aid to a medic because she was friends with a dead Kroot she calls ‘not a bad sort’. This is literally the very end of the book and has no connection to our protagonists, our moral view point characters, at all.
Also I don’t want some ‘maybe they’ll touch on it again later’ nonsense, next up are Orks. If you aren’t going to demonstrate racism is bad using the T’au then, in 40k, you basically have no options left.