May 17, 2019
Elmo’s
2349 Millersport Highway
Getzville, NY 14068
We ventured in because they are featured on the Buffalo Wing Trail, but I HAD to try the fish. Look out when you enter! If it’s sunny outside it will take some time for your eyes to adjust to the darkness. There are wood benches that line the entrance that will put a nice dent in your shin if you aren’t paying attention. Fish was beer battered skinless cod. Batter was super crispy. Portion was a good size and the fish was done perfectly with good flavor. (9) It came with standard 3/8 fries that were frozen longer than they were alive. No seasoning but crisp. Good not great. (7) Finely minced coleslaw was obviously from a bucket but was as good as you can get for a mass produced side. (7) Potato salad appeared to be home made. Potatoes were el dente and there was a heavy presence of vinegar. (8) Tartar was served in packets... no effort there. Major bummer that there was no Mac salad on the plate... 😔 Loved the fish, but their sides need some work. It is located in a strip mall with limited parking. Our server Elizabeth was incredibly sweet and handled out party of 11 with skill and a smile. Overall rating is an 8.5. Go for the wings... they are special.