Hate Me
Katherine Pierce & Male Reader Gilbert x Stefan Salvatore.
Plot: Y/N comes face to face with last person he wants to see during the Hunter's curse.
“Ugh, don't you ever stop crying?” Katherine asked with a roll of her eyes as Y/N sat in a chair, knees up to his chest. Tear stains on his face.
“Poor, Y/N, always the victim.” Katherine stopped mid-walk and turned around to look at Y/N with a grin. “Except now you're a killer. What does Stefan think of the new you?”
“Shut up,” Y/N growled.
“The boy he fell in love with is gone, you know.” Y/N looks at her. How can someone who looks so much like his sister be so cruel and mean?
“You're like me now,” Katherine says as she whispers. “Maybe worse…”
“I made a mistake. I can do better,” Y/N bargains.
“No, you can't. You're a vampire. You'll kill again,” Katherine said. “It'll change you. And it'll keep changing you until you're just like me.” She leans down close to Y/N as she says this.
No, it can't be true. Y/N was nothing like Katerina Petrova. He couldn't be, right? Y/N shot to his feet in anger as he towered over Katherine, who didn't seem to mind the height difference. “I am nothing like you!”
Katherine scoffed. “I was you before you even existed.” She smiled at the middle Gilbert. “And when Stefan knew the real me… He hated me.”
Y/N looked down. After Stefan found out what Katherine did to him and Damon, he quickly hated her for what she'd done to them. “Now he's going to hate you, too.” Y/N felt a tear stream down his face at Katherine's words. She was right. Stefan was gonna hate him for what he did. He was a monster, and Stefan couldn't be in love with a monster like him.
“Well, at least you'll still have Damon to love you,” Katherine teased as she walked away.
“SHUT UP!” Y/N charged at her with vampire speed as tried to grab her, but quickly went through her as he fell on the bed. It had been an illusion. A trick from the Hunter's curse. Y/N grabbed his head in worry as he began to cry once again.