@na-yserin replied to your post “You're such a great writer, especially with sex...”:
imo tis part is WHY its good. "I can't write sex disassociated from the reality and physicality of bodies. I've also never had "perfect" sex that so many people insist should be the goal of erotica. "
@wordsandrobots replied to your post “You're such a great writer, especially with sex...”:
To split hairs in defence of things you are *really good at writing*, not all sex scenes are porn. A scene in which sex is implied is still a sex scene, it's just not designed to turn someone on as rapidly as possible. It may do so because a lot of us are freaks who get high off emotional resonance, but it's a separate category. And you are exceptionally good at writing the kind of intimacy that's key to it precisely because you recognise its fundamental ridiculousness.
@thedancingwalrus-blog replied to your post “You're such a great writer, especially with sex...”:
Listen to the winged cat and the circle! You are good at writing! You are good at writing all of the things! Squeeze the secrets out of your brain meats and tell the Anon! Accept that you are good at the thing! (Not high just under caffinated)
You three. I love you. But stop.
You're projecting an entirely different conversation onto the one I'm trying to have with this anon.
I'm not being self-deprecating because uwu, I'm insecure about my writing.
I'm not being self-deprecating at all.
Like, I love you. I understand the instinct to instantly reassure someone you like when they talk about not being good at doing things. I love you for having that impulse. And I am both touched and flattered that you have that impulse about me. But that's a bad instinct to have, when you insert it into a conversation where self-deprecation isn't happening.
Read the anon again! The anon is asking for help. The anon is gushing about my work and using that as the reason why they've come to me to ask for help. And I cannot help them! Because I do not have the skills they're looking to improve. They've made an objectively wrong assessment of my work and my skillset, and I'm trying to set the record straight in as humorous a way I can. Because that's what I do.
Trying to come up with a definition of "sex scene" that includes my work is not helpful. Expressing that you like my work does not mean my work magically fits the definition we're working on here. Anon said "sex scenes". Guys. Guys. I went and checked. I haven't written anything rated E since November 2020 and that wasn't a proper explicit sex scene. The last actual proper sex scene I've written is from March 2019.
You're such a great writer, especially with sex scenes! is a very sweet sentiment, but it objectively and categorically does not apply to me. And I need to make that clear, because the follow up to that praise is Do you have any tips or advice on writing a good sex scene? Because I do not. Because I do not really write sex scenes, good or otherwise.
Again, I'm not being self-deprecating or insecure. If someone comes to me for help, and I cannot help them, I have to be honest and tell them I can't help them. There is nothing to be won by pretending I have a skill I do not have, and everything to lose - ie, the respect and trust I've built within my community - by talking out of my ass and pretending I have any kind of authority to tell someone how to do something I objectively do not know how to do. Specially when I'm surrounded by people who do have that skill and do know how to do the thing! And it's not unheard of that someone might have confused me for someone else. It's happened this month already. If anon sent the ask by mistake, I'm answering it because there's a chance they might see it and go send it to the right person. And if they didn't send it by mistake, and they do mean it, I want them to know I'm unfortunately not the person who can give them what they're looking for.
Like, again. I'm not mad or anything. And I don't mean to be rude. But I find this particular behavior to be terribly unhelpful and while I know it comes from a place of kindness and sincere affection, I don't actually think it's healthy.
Let's rewrite that ask, okay?
You're such a great welder, especially corner joints! Do you have any tips or advice on welding a good corner joint?
Would you have felt the urge to reply the same way if I'd had told anon I'm not a welder, that I've only ever done patchy, awkward, DIY butt joints and sent them off to look for help elsewhere? I have a friend who is a welder, so perhaps they meant to send the ask to her instead? Writing is a skill. And yes, writers are inherently dramatic peacocks. We all are. Writing is basically about putting bits and pieces of yourself into your work, and that creates a very close and visceral type of insecurity. And yes, it's very kind of you to reach out and try to smother someone's insecurities with praise but like. Make sure insecurity is what's happening.
Look at the context of what conversation people are having. Because your objectively well-meaning words put me in the awkward position of defending my personal assessment of my skills and somehow not offending you while also pointing out you've misread the situation, while also trying to keep the previous interaction from being re-framed as me asking for reassurance under the guise of false modesty. THAT would give me anxiety, if I was the kind of person who was prone to it. THAT turns a routine, almost transactional interaction into a high level juggling routine that will have actual consequences if I don't land the tone right. That can and has caused people to get into fights and even strain friendships. I've seen it happen, hence why I don't think it's healthy.
And like, I'm glad you like the stuff I write! But I tag my work primarily as M for a reason: it sets the expectation that no explicit shenanigans will be present, because I know myself not good at and also not that interested in writing explicit shenanigans, but also allows people to know I'm going to tackle themes the way I like to.
I'm more than happy to have a conversation about how to create the kind of effect you're describing, how to make sex humanizing instead of titillating. Because that's a thing I do. Nearly all my characters are sexual one way or another, but never explicitly so. I don't need them to be, to communicate the things I'm trying to put into my stories. I'm more than happy to have a conversation about the eroticism of not actually showing the sex itself. Sure. But none of those are the conversation I was having with anon, and they all kind of miss the point of the conversation I was having with anon. And maybe that's on me. Sure. I was a blob on Friday and dearly needed the kind comments and support I got.
Seriously. Contextualize your comments and do not respond to things you're projecting into a conversation that had nothing to do with what is actually happening in the first place.
And also, reminder, I am allowed to not be good at things. You are allowed to not be good at things. Everyone is allowed to not be good at things. If someone says they're not good at something? That's perfectly fine. If someone thinks they're not good at something you think they're good at, that's also perfectly fine. Not all assessments about skill are self-deprecation. Both people who are perfectly disinterested in learning a specific skill (me and sex scenes, really), and people who are looking to master a specific skill (anon and sex scenes apparently) can say the same thing about themselves, and you do them both a disservice when you imply by your reaction that the only possible reason someone would disqualify their skill at something is out of insecurity.
So for fun here's a list of things I do not have the skill to do and I am not insecure about at all:
Pretty much all arts and crafts
These are all things I know people who do have the skill to do it and who are amazing at it. And I admire them greatly for it! And I also respect them enough to assess my skillset correctly next to theirs. And that's not a personal slight or a self-deprecating thing.
Different people have different abilities and different skillsets and that's okay!
Again, I love you. I love that you felt the strong urge to do this. But like. Let me be bad at things. Being bad at things is one of life's greatest pleasures.