There's a post I keep seeing go around that's like, "quick, list five things you like that aren't a piece of media," and every time I see it, I get the very petty urge to respond with, "teaching media literacy, studying media history, analyzing media, using media as a lens to study historical trends, and finding ways to connect people's interest in pop culture to important social issues."
I have plenty of hobbies that aren't media-related, sure. I love my garden, my pets, baking, and sewing. I just get rather tired of "media is evil, actually, and if you're really into it is is actually rotting your stupid little brain" rhetoric. If your goal is to get people to broaden their horizons and engage in multiple hobbies beyond passive media engagement, leading with shame (and social media posts that function as OCD traps) is a BAD FUCKING APPROACH. Shame is not a motivator. Shame only serves to condescend and shut people down.
This week I'm working on lesson plans to lead a six-week class on media literacy skills for a pack of homeschoolers. What the fuck kind of teacher would I be if I used an approach of "you're stupid for liking cartoons, go do something WORTHWHILE!" instead of "let's develop these skills by talking about a piece of media you already enjoy!"
To say nothing of the fact that this is the fandom and media website. This is literally where people come to engage with their fandom/media hobby. It's a cow farm, there are going to be cows outside. If that's not how YOU use tumblr, that's fine, but let's not pretend like "people into fandom" isn't a core demographic that this site actively markets itself toward. If you see someone being over-the-top about a piece of media, it's a fool's conclusion that they clearly must never log off and only ever do fandom stuff.
It's like reading a recipe website that focuses on cookies and cakes, and concluding that the recipe authors clearly must never eat anything that isn't chocolate, chocolate is the only thing they care about, and they think literally everyone in the world should eat only chocolate.






















