Cave Painting from Indonesia, c.46,000 BCE: this prehistoric painting shows several animals being hunted by tiny figures that are part-human and part-animal
This artwork was discovered in a limestone cave known as Leang Bulu' Sipong 4, which is located on the island of Sulawesi, in Indonesia. The panel depicted above is just one part of a much larger painting that measures nearly 4.5 meters (about 15 feet) long, and it covers the wall of a hidden chamber that was discovered back in 2017.
Above: a section of the painting from Leang Bulu' Sipong
The full-length painting depicts six animals, including two wild pigs and four anoas (small, buffalo-like creatures that are endemic to Indonesia) being hunted by tiny therianthropes, which are figures that appear to be part-human and part-animal. The figures are vaguely human-like, but they are depicted with animalistic features including tails, beaks, snouts, lizard-like torsos, and horns.
Above: a digital tracing of the full-sized painting, with the anoa and therianthropic figures magnified
Some of these animalistic traits may represent masks, headdresses, or costumes, but several of the figures also exhibit more extreme features that do not resemble simple costumes. Researchers also argue that such costumes would be useless and impractical as hunting props, given that the features mostly seem to mimic small animals like birds and lizards.
Above: two therianthropic figures that seem to be using spears or ropes to subdue the much larger anoa
A 2019 analysis of this painting originally indicated that it was created over 43,900 years ago, but further testing in 2024 revealed that it was created even earlier, dating back to at least 48,000 years ago -- which would make this the world's second-oldest example of figurative art (i.e. artwork that depicts real or recognizable subjects, such as humans or animals).
It's unclear whether or not the animal-like figures actually represent therianthropes, but if they are therianthropic, as archaeologists speculate, then this painting would also qualify as the world's oldest known depiction of mythical beings, and it would constitute the earliest known evidence of spiritual or supernatural thinking. It is more than 8,000 years older than the famous Löwenmensch ("lion-man") carving from Germany, which has long been recognized as the world's oldest depiction of a therianthrope.
According to this article:
For whoever painted these figures, they represented much more than ordinary human hunters. One appears to have a large beak while another has an appendage resembling a tail. In the language of archaeology, these are therianthropes, or characters that embody a mix of human and animal characteristics.
"The images of therianthropes may also represent the earliest evidence for our capacity to conceive of things that do not exist in the natural world, a basic concept that underpins modern religion,” said Adam Brumm, study co-author and associate professor at the Australian Research Centre for Human Evolution. “Therianthropes occur in the folklore or narrative fiction of almost every modern society, and they are perceived as gods, spirits or ancestral beings in many religions worldwide.”
These interpretations are speculative, however, and the inspiration for the painting, as well as its significance to the humans who created it, is likely to remain a mystery.
Archaeologists have been aware of Sulawesi's abundant cave art since the 1950's, but dating techniques were not used on the paintings until 2014. For decades, it was assumed that the artwork was less than 10,000 years old, but when animal paintings and hand stencils from seven different caves were finally analyzed, researchers were shocked to discover that some of the artwork was created more than 39,900 years ago -- predating most of the world's earliest known cave paintings. Since then, archaeologists have discovered and analyzed many other cave paintings from Sulawesi that date back to between 40,000 and 51,200 years ago (the 51,200-year-old cave painting was discussed in one of my previous posts).
These discoveries firmly contradict the traditional (and deeply eurocentric) beliefs that were previously held regarding the origins of artistic expression, as this article explains:
Previously, the oldest known cave art was thought to have first appeared in Europe 40,000 years ago, showcasing abstract symbols. By 35,000 years ago, the art became more sophisticated, showing horses and other animals.
These latest finds in Indonesia have challenged a long-standing belief that artistic expression – and the cognitive leap that may have accompanied it – began in Europe.
It’s now thought that the capability to create figurative art either emerged before Homo sapiens migrated out of Africa and headed for Europe and Asia more than 60,000 years ago, or that it emerged more than once as humans spread around the globe.
Unfortunately, many of the cave paintings in Sulawesi and other parts of Indonesia are now rapidly crumbling away as a result of climate change. The limestone surfaces of the cave walls are peeling away at an alarming rate, erasing large sections of the paintings in the process. At some sites, patches of artwork measuring 2-3cm wide are now vanishing every few months.
The Guardian: Earliest Known Cave Art by Modern Humans Found in Indonesia
Scientific American: Is This Indonesian Cave Painting the Earliest Portrayal of a Mythical Story?
National Geographic: Ancient Cave Art May Depict the World's Oldest Hunting Scene
The Leakey Foundation: Indonesian Cave Paintings Show the Dawn of Imaginative Art
Nature: Earliest Hunting Scene in Prehistoric Art
Nature: Narrative Cave Art in Indonesia by 51,200 Years Ago
The New York Times: Mythical Beings May be Earliest Imaginative Cave Art by Humans
Science: World's Oldest Hunting Scene Shows Half-Human, Half-Animal Figures
Smithsonian Magazine: A Journey to the Oldest Cave Paintings in the World
Art Net: Some of the Oldest and Most Revered Cave Paintings in the World Are Under Extreme Threat Due to Climate Change
Nature: Humanity's Oldest Art is Flaking Away