hey, Elisa, does Varric /really/ throw away all those letters from the Merchant's Guild? I guess I'm just curious about his whole relationship and interactions with them. I can't recall if you've already discussed this
SEND ME A TOPIC TO WRITE A META ABOUT MY MUSE ON // meme cache // always accepting
I had like half a reply written to this like twice or so, so now I’m just gonna list all the reasons why Varric skirted away from the Merchant’s Guild!
This has nothing to do with Varric, however, as a whole --- it does. The writers continuously forget that Varric has a reputation not only as a Tethras, but a reputation politically. The choice to have Varric converse ( or not ) with the Guild was due to time restraints and well laziness. Varric is a bigger powerhouse than people give him credit for and the Inquisition was all about allies, and there was a good chance that if people wanted a more corrupt ( aka smuggling, spy, trade heavy ) Inquisition there could have been a choice for Varric to converse with the Guild, even if it was a simple War Table mission. While we did get a taste of that, it really wasn’t the authentic flavour of espionage that gets the blood pumping!
ii. varric and the protection of the inquisitor
Let’s face it, the Guild and the Carta are two sides of the same coin, one is composed of surfacers and the other composed of Orzammar dwarves. Both don’t really fit it, both have an archaic hierarchy and sometimes seem opposed to change as a whole. They’re both smuggling rings, illicit crime rings, and hold tiers of influence. However, Varric understands the nuances of political machine that is the Inquisition, he saw it start out on rocky footing and was there for the messiest birth of gang of happy misfits SINCE the Kirkwall bunch, and as a seasoned hell-worn companion he has unique insight on what may or may not be needed in these cases, and a highly conservative dwarf smuggling ring is not one of them. Varric may have skirted the other kalnas mainly because instead of the Inquisition having some benefit from the alliance, it was more likely that the Guild would have made away with something much more beneficial. So he ignores letters to protect his Inquisitor, simple enough --- right?
iii. the makeup of the merchant’s guild
The composition of the merchant’s guild is another thing to consider! We don’t have much information on how many members are within the upper circle, but we do know that Varric inherited Bartrand’s seat upon his death and according to the wiki, he’s the only listed ascendant, which means he’s the only new-age thinker. This makeup means that the Guild is more likely to keep to themselves and work as if they were part of the Orzammar caste system, even abiding by old laws and treaties if the moment called for it. It’s evident at the Winter Palace that they do not really keep to themselves, but that can be chalked up to them simply playing on the insecurities and uncertainty of Orlais, which means that they were MAKING SO MUCH MONEY ( and essentially Varric lost out on this, so ---- the Guild may have some questions ). This make-up is unfavourable to any of Varric’s canonical stances and ignoring the letters may have been easier than dealing with the make-up of the guild that still remembers Varric’s brother who was also a Kalna, those who would rather run the guild by Orzammar rules ( but modify them ).
iv. varric’s reasonable time constraints
The only book that Varric publishes between his interrogation and the closing of DA:I ( not Trespasser ) is one chapter of Swords & Shields and even then he hadn’t really touched that book since he had been on the road. His banters and other comments in conversations lead us to believe that he is working on paperwork for Kirkwall and Her Interests, which means he may have skirted his other duties and let them fall to the wayside. He had to pick a couple of things, so he picked the Inquisitor and Kirkwall. So for his health and lack of time, he most likely just ignored the letters or better yet burned them!
v. varric and his reasonable expectations of people
Varric expects people to burn him. Varric expects this of the Merchant’s Guild and wouldn’t allow them to do that to the Inquisitor ( leading back to his protection of the Inquisitor, mainly because Varric didn’t join the Inquisition, he stated he’ll follow the Inquisitor, which is a foil of Solas and I’ll get into how Varric and Solas foil each other later ). Also, he didn’t want the Merchant’s Guild to influence how he was thought of, he’s a bastard and a scoundrel and would prove that on his own rather than the Guild daring to spin some fictitious story about him that can’t even hold a flame.