I’ve only been in love the two times. There was my first boyfriend, Aaron, whom I met when I left home and moved down to Salem, Oregon for my first year of college. We started dating only a few weeks into the semester and somehow it lasted the better part of a year even though I was a fair amount more batshit crazy back then than I am now. We spent the majority of our time together holding hands while watching Family Guy, listening to music (John Mayer will forever make me think of him), and faux studying in my dorm. He was cute and adventurous and said the funniest things over AOL Instant Messenger. I really cared about him and he was only ever good to me, but our love for each other was too young and too little to last through something like my complete mental breakdown. Hypothetically speaking, of course.
And then there was my second boyfriend, Jerod. I loved him so much that after nearly two years of dating I married him. We were set up by my brother Ben and his wife Alex (his fiancée at the time and also a childhood friend of Jerod’s) because we had both been trudging through the pain of heartbreak and I guess they thought we might as well be sad together. But I wasn’t quite over Aaron yet and Jerod still hadn’t moved completely past his lost love either, also named Erin by the way because life is just too weird, and so when they invited us both over to hang out around the fire pit on the back patio of Alex’s folks’ house, there wasn’t a single spark within either one of us. Butterflies on my end maybe because Jerod is an effing attractive man, but still no connection to carry us past that one encounter.
We didn’t see or speak to each other for over two years after that. Until one day I randomly messaged him on Facebook (I know, no shame!) and invited him to come over and watch the Miss America pageant on TV with me later that same week. Here’s the really unbelievable part: he agreed to my crazy invitation and then actually showed up. I guess you could say that was our first date because after that we were kind of just always together. We watched football games on his friends’ couches, went out to all the local pubs, danced late into the night on weekends and worked our way through his extensive DVD collection. Jerod was constantly making me laugh and when I was around him I felt like the girl I wanted to be. Weeks into our relationship he told me he loved me, and then he also made sure things didn’t get weird when I didn’t say it back.
I was scared to open up my heart, and not just because of any past break up, but because a lot of the love I’d known all my life had deeply hurt me and made me think that maybe I wasn’t so worthy of it. To take his love in and make it my own and then to love him back, it all felt a bit risky. So I hid parts of myself and pushed him away, even as my feelings for him grew, because I couldn’t seem to stop being so afraid. One evening in particular, after the mile high walls around my heart had made it nearly impossible for us to enjoy being together, we got into a fight that was nothing short of fierce. Somewhere along the way in all our arguing, just about every last one of my defenses was stripped down and I went to sleep that night feeling exposed, vulnerable and completely unloveable. I thought for sure that things were over.
The next morning I woke up and went downtown to open up the restaurant where I waited tables. While I was standing at the counter busily refilling the sugar shakers, I looked up and there was Jerod standing in the doorway. I knew right then at that very moment that not only had I been wrong, that things were not in fact over, but also that I loved him, this man who saw the good in me even when I couldn’t see it myself yet, who continued to lean into me despite all of my walls and wariness. And though our relationship since then hasn’t been without struggle (we’ve been married seven years now and have had two babies and he’s not perfect and I’m reallllly not perfect), I will always be grateful to Jerod for showing me just how beautiful and good love can be.