For fluff ideas maybe a first date night? That would be cute:)
"Date with a Devil"
A/N: Been feeling a bit down in the dumps recently but I'd be more than happy to make one of those lists I've seen people do with certain characters in certain scenarios :]
Ngl I kinda mixed both fluff and angst for this, but it's nothing too heart-wretching I promise, just normal couple things.
I'll start off with the characters separately first, and then have them all together
Notice: Poly relationship, the characters included in this scenario are all 18+ and older. X-RED is 27 and EJ says he's "31" but he actually doesn't remember his real age (here's a hint, he's VERY MUCH older than 31 lol)
Reader(Y/N) will be gender neutral for this scenario and will use gender neutral pronouns so anyone can enjoy <3
A Date with Her:
At least with RED, you have more options regarding on where your date shall take place.
When she goes out in public, she can hide her face scars and backwards eye with a simple face mask and a cap with the help of some of her hair.
She can blend in easier and of course she will take advantage of that to make sure you have a fun time with her.
She's a very experimental person so if you have an idea, she'd be more than happy to try it out, especially if it's something new.
If she could do all of the things you want to do together in a day, she would.
But unfortunately that's not realistic and sometimes society sucks so you'll make with what you can do.
And it's ok if you don't really have an idea because you're worried about the risks that could happen and the possibility that you both would get into trouble (both the police and Slenderman)
RED just so happens to know a place...
She ended up bringing you far out of bounds and into a populated city. Forbidden grounds that you know you should not even go anywhere near unless you were required to based on the missions you were given. You were worried to death about the risk that Slenderman would find out about you two misbehaving—He is your Operator after all.
But he's not RED's.
And she could give a damn less about what he thinks.
Sneaking in was simple, too simple, almost if RED had done this way too many times when no one was looking.
She believes she can trust you to know about this, she wants to try and share this place with you and maybe see if you both can find a connection towards it or relate to it somehow...
"...RED?"
"RED, what is this?"
You spoke out as she led you through the darkness, trying to follow her through a weird pile of items that were scattered all over the floor. You felt an interesting medley of textures brush onto your skin, ranging from soft, silky, firm, and even rough. You yelped a bit when you ended up tripping over an unknown item, almost causing a clatter until RED managed to catch and stop the items from piling onto you. Irritated and a bit embarrassed, you spoke out again after RED pulled you back onto your feet and you were still unable to see her...
"We shouldn't be here, we're already too far from the forest while we're off parole-"
You hushed when you suddenly felt RED's thumb press onto your lips as she shushed you. You couldn't see her but you swore she leaned in closer to your face when she did that, feeling a slight tickle on your nose from her warm breath. She caressed your cheek for a bit to try and reassure you, and she almost allowed you to melt into her palm but you both still had yet to reach your destination. She was brushing her thumb on top of your hand before she finally managed to find a door. You could tell only because you heard the hinges squeak, not because you could finally see where you were...
But you could hear a faint sound of an orchestra's strings singing a song somewhere in this building...
Your curiosity made you more willing to continue following her as the music was eventually growing louder and louder as she led you closer towards a faint glow at the end of what looked to be a hallway with a few old chairs stacked on top of each other. The song itself was weirdly familiar to you, like your younger self had heard this before but the small hint nostalgia wasn't enough to help you recognize the song in general.
RED stopped at a pair of old curtains, light seeping through the gap between them before she brushed one of them to the side with her arm, allowing you to enter first and finally see what it was that RED was willing to break some rules over. It was revealed that RED had led you into an old balcony that was pretty much abandoned at the top of the theater.
There was a crowd far below from where you were, all paying attention to the stage with a small orchestra sitting closest to the front of it all. You could see a variety of string instruments, easily recognizing the sound of the violin at least, along with a timed whistle from a flute or two. You didn’t know what instruments exactly were playing the song together, but you knew very much what they were playing for. You saw what looked to be three dancers in sync with one another as they stepped together in unison gracefully, while on the very tip of their toes no less...
"...A ballet?"
You were surprised by how RED was even able to find this place and be able to show you a free show like this in general. She thought you looked cute the way your eyes lit up as you were already captivated by the professionalism in both the dancers and the music working together perfectly...
...but she had to pull you down so you wouldn't get caught so you both would have to watch while sitting on your knees as the balcony would hide you both from anyone who didn't need to know that you were here, especially staff. You didn’t protest when RED placed her hand on the top of your head just to gently push you down before she would sit next to you and watch the ballet continue with a bird's eye view of it all. She would sit right next to you of course with her hat and mask off to the side, resting her chin on top of her folded arms, enjoying the performance like you,
Together.
It's not everyday you would get to see a well-performed ballet that wasn't composed by a bunch of preschoolers, much less in a spot that would most definitely go to someone who paid a lot of money just to be separated above from the rest of the crowd. Granted, it was all a wonderful experience altogether and you were happy to be shared a wonderful moment like this with RED, but something didn't sit right with you...
Why here?
You don't recall ever bringing up an idea close to something such as ballet, neither in a conversation or anything that could serve as a hint towards it. You would try to ask RED about it but she seems to be more in a trance than you were and you didn't want to be the reason that peaceful smile on her face goes away—so you kept silent for what oddly felt like a long time before it was now halfway into the play and everyone was given a 20 minute break, both the crowd and the dancers, and pretty much the entire crowd of people had gotten up to take advantage of the break so they could use the restroom of course. RED seemed to be back into reality at last, which gave you the chance to try and speak up your mind...
"RED?.."
You placed your hand on her thigh to grab her attention before you said her name, to which she looked at you and added her hand on top of yours. Before you could speak, she took your gesture as an invite to let her kiss you. The way she held up your chin and wrapped her arm around your waist made it nearly impossible for you to resist her touch. The kiss quickly turned heated as you ended up laid back against the floor with RED on top of you, trailing her kisses down to the crook of your neck, making you whimper as she sucked on your sweet and doughy skin. She continued to shower your face with kisses, first starting off rough and frequently planting kisses on every part she could reach with her lips. Slowly but surely, she'd become more gentle and appreciative, savoring the feeling of your soft lips against hers, with a few more soft kisses to the corners of your cheeks, your forehead, and your cute nose. She gave you one more passionate kiss, just to leave you breathless beneath her, which made her chuckle. You let out a delightful sigh before she got off of you and gave you a chance to sit up again. Now would not be a good time to get frisky, otherwise you would both miss the rest of the performance because neither of you could behave and wait til you got back home.
"...Like?"
RED ended up asking you if you were enjoying the performance so far, pulling you closer to her side with her arm back around your waist. You nuzzled into her a bit before you'd finally answer her,
But then it'd be your turn to ask your question for her after...
"I do like it, dear."
"I'm surprised that you were able to find something like this for a date."
"But if you don't mind me asking... why ballet?"
"there's no way we just happen to "stumble upon" this place when there's a performance going on,"
"They don't usually happen everyday, they can take a lot of time..."
"...Surely, this isn't your first time coming to this exact theater?"
"...No."
RED was honest towards you, willing to open up to you in general. At least you looked like you were enjoying it too, maybe not as much as she was but she could tell that there was definitely some effort.
"Do you know this place?"
"...Nope."
"...Then how did you find it?"
"...Ehh... drunk."
"...Hide... shelter..."
"..err... stum...ble.. on?"
RED was trying her best to make sense towards you, how she snuck out when she was drunk and she ended up getting lost out in the city while it was raining, so she needed to find shelter. Most of it is blurry for her, she can't exactly remember every single detail on how she found this place, but she's glad she found it to begin with. It's one of the few places that brings her some joy while she's been unable to return to where she originally came from.
"...Feel..."
"Err..."
RED continued to open up to you but she was getting held back by her struggle of putting words together. She didn't know how to say what she wanted, it was on the tip of her tongue but at the same time, she couldn't remember how to even begin pronouncing what she wanted to say. She tried to make an example for you to see if you could say it for her... she tried touching her index fingers together first before she came up with what she thought was better, clasping her hands over each other to fit as a whole...?
"Uhh... hook?.."
"No... piece..."
"...Puzzle!"
She seemed to be more irritated with herself than by you taking longer to try and understand what she saying, watching her hold her hands together as if they were a shape while she continued to repeat "puzzle" and "piece."
"Put together...?"
"Err...no.."
"...Connect? Connection?"
"You feel a connection to ballet?"
RED looked so relieved when your intelligence kicked in and you made communication so much easier for her right there, she showed you her gratitude by kissing your closed fist before she sighed with relief. She then looked back over to the stage on the ground. She's not sure how to put it down exactly, especially since she still doesn't have her memories yet.
But she keeps finding herself coming back here whenever she can, just to watch the dancers.
RED looked sad when she reminded herself that she doesn't know who she was before her... incident. You know just how desperate RED has been to find any other hint to discovering about her younger self, and you hated the way she was tearing herself up over it. You could only be sympathetic towards her, as it's even the one thing the humanity left in her has been fighting for,
Like a dying wish.
EJ, however, can't seem to really understand her pain, despite being in the same situation as her. He has given up on his human memories long ago because he has accepted the fact that he is, and no longer will be "a human." He doesn't understand why RED wants to find lost pieces of her, thinking they will just be useless to her in general, that they're not worth throwing fits over or fighting against everyone who's been generous to her and has allowed her to live, like Slenderman.
You keep your thoughts to yourself though, despite being one of his proxies who's supposed to keep her in check. You're in love with her after all,
You hate seeing her in pain and you'd do anything to make her happy,
Like she would for you.
You ended up pulling her into a tight embrace with your hand on the back of her head. She seemed a bit stunned at first but she returned the affection and allowed you to comfort her.
"I know, baby... I know..."
"...Things like this take time."
"But as long as you have hope, I'm sure your memory will heal."
"If you think it will help, perhaps for our next date, we could go dancing together?"
What a wonderful idea.
A Date with Him:
As stated before, unfortunately typical dates in public will not be an option for you two.
Not even Halloween will protect your boyfriend from being suspicious, infact the sound of people screaming will only get him all excited (plus he has definitely tried to eat some gore props before, only to end up extremely disappointed.)
But that's ok, a nice date doesn't have to take place in a fancy restaurant or a movie theater.
At least you both have miles and miles of "spooky" forest to explore together.
It doesn't have to be wild or adventurous like taking a dip in a creek or hunting for a deer,
You can just take a walk through the woods together and admire the scenery until you find a perfect spot to place a blanket down for you to lie on.
Let the sound of nature comfort both of you while you cuddle in the lush outdoors...
It's not everyday you get to see EJ behave so peacefully for being one of the most vile, and sadistic monsters to exist. Sure, you both do normally spend a lot of your quality time together, but it doesn't hurt to have more of it. You couldn't ask for anything better while EJ was practically curled up to fit into your smaller form, his face buried in the crook of your neck while his mask was off to the side. There was a low, guttural noise emitting from him everytime he breathed, almost like he was purring—but he insists that he does not purr, he's not a cat. You agree that he's not a cat, but he sure as hell does end up behaving like one sometimes. You couldn't help but giggle while your fingers were fiddling with his hair strands, a bit oily from the lack of a regular bathing schedule, but at least he put in some effort today so he's not reeking of salty blood and rotting meat. You suddenly shivered as you felt something warm run down along your skin to your collarbone, it's thick texture hard to miss and you had to lean up to check if it stained your shirt.
"...I'm sorry."
"Babe, it's alright, I know you can't help it."
"I'm wearing a dark colored shirt today for a reason."
You reassured him that you were expecting him to make a mess with his tar-like tears and you really didn't mind if he did, you were prepared for it this time. Honestly, you were surprised it took longer than expected, usually it happens a lot quicker and it can get really messy at that. EJ sat up for a second just to take a moment and dig his fingers carefully into his eye sockets, trying to scoop out as much of the endless mush that's been sitting inside. You cringed at the sight of it, because it's not common for someone to just start digging their fingers into where their eyes would be—but he no longer has any.
"Still, I wish I didn't have this problem."
"So you could wear cute outfits around me too."
"Cute outfits can also be in dark colors."
"Besides, I don't really have any lighter colors in my wardrobe."
"Because of that one night I stained your favorite pajama set or-?"
"...That was probably the only set of clothing of mine that wasn't in a dark shade, dear."
When EJ was done cleaning out his eyes, flicking his stained fingers off to the side, he would return to the same position he was in before, letting you lie back so he can snuggle into your body again. You continued to pet his head and let the feeling of his lips gently grazing your neck tickle a bit of a fire into your core.
"I don't mean to sound insensitive but can you even see the hues properly?"
"...Barely, very barely."
"Unless it's a shade of red, like pink, I can see it just fine."
"Everything else is just muted and gray... blue is barely an exception."
"How do you know what colors are if you can't see them very well?"
EJ shifted in his position a bit, primarily so he doesn't sound muffled and his mouth isn't being covered by your neck. Lifting his head up a bit, he ended up placing his large hand on top of your cheek, grazing his sharp thumb in the shape of a circle along your plush skin as he continued to speak.
"I know the names of colors, I remember that there are names for them... but that doesn't mean I can see their differences very well."
"I can see red well because, well, it's important."
"Red usually ends up meaning it's food, something I can eat."
"Pink is basically red mixed with white, so it's also considered important for me to recognize."
"However, it does not apply to orange, or purple."
"They're mixed with other colors that are not important, so that also makes them not important."
"It's like you're seeing colors solely based on memory..?"
"...I guess so."
"Regardless, I prefer to use my nose and my ears over whatever "vision" I'm using."
EJ ended up leaning closer towards your face, the tip of his nose barely touching yours with his chin stubble poking at your skin a bit. His lips tugged into a smirk from the way you gasped at the feeling of his claws gently tracing along the side of your neck, gliding over your sweet spot.
"I like to listen for the cute noises you make when I touch you..."
"I like the smell of your hot blood rushing through your veins under your layers of sweet meat..."
"The taste of your savory flesh, your soft skin against my rough tongue..."
EJ stuck out one of his tongues just to glide it across where your wind pipe would be before he planted a few kisses on top. He took a deep breath in, letting your scent fill his undead lungs and make him drool the moment you left his throat. He ended up sucking on your neck a bit, his sharp teeth threatening to pierce your flesh and add onto the hickey he was going to give you. You couldn't help but whimper and submit to him, making him chuckle as he relished in your beautiful presence.
"...God, I love it when you smell like a sweet bakery of flowers."
You weren't exactly sure on what he meant by that, but you had a feeling that he probably really likes the new soap you've been washing yourself with recently. You couldn't help but blush bright red like a ripe tomato with the luxurious amounts of kissing and affection you were given. You were so close to falling into a complete trance by his touch, but you snapped out of it the moment he tried to slide his hand under your shirt to search for a feel, making you squeal.
"E-Excuse you!"
"Not out here, sir!"
"S-Save it for when we get back..!"
"What, you're afraid that someone's gonna get a good look at you?~"
"T-There's always eyes in this forest—and I don't just mean the animals!"
EJ clicked his tongue, feeling a bit impatient but he can't force you to give him consent. He snuggled his face into the crook of your neck again, his hands out of your shirt and instead wrapped around your waist to keep you close. Besides, you did say 'save it for later.'
And trust me when I say this,
He's going to.
A Date With Both:
Honestly, a date with both is probably going to be very tricky for you all to pull off.
It's not like you don't see them together every day, but unfortunately both of them have restrictions that collide with the other's abilities.
RED can go out and blend in public, EJ cannot.
Your outdoor activities are limited too, going fishing or for a quick swim in a pond is a no-go, because RED can't swim at all and she wants nothing to do with water.
And most of the time, she wants to do more than just lie down under a tree to cuddle.
EJ, thankfully, is not extremely picky on what you all should do together—he's practically fine with anything either you or RED have in mind.
The kitchen didn't seem to be frequently visited today, so you had an idea that could at least satisfy RED's requirements of actively doing something.
But you're not sure how baking with two demons that don't eat human food will go...
You were hoping this could be easy for the other two to follow. It's not a crazy recipe at all, just something that Sally ended up choosing because you all were torn apart on what exactly to make. You were given the easy route because Sally asked if you could make sugar cookies—bonus points if they're multi-colored instead of just off-white. You stocked up on what you believed would be enough ingredients, along with a few more extra just in case anything went wrong.
And by God, you were so glad you made yourself prepared for this...
"RED, it's not supposed to be liquid..!"
"You can't make a solid ball if it's pure mush!"
These two have absolutely no idea how baking works. EJ can't read the recipe instructions and RED can't verbally communicate correctly on what she needs—it was a 2-ingredient recipe to make a pure baking disaster in the kitchen. There's flour pretty much everywhere, because EJ dropped the bag in the beginning and none of y'all could find the broom to clean it up. You've previously thrown out at least 3 batches already because. The first batch, RED left in egg shells, unaware that they're not safe to consume. Second batch was almost successful if EJ hadn't added all of the food coloring into the same bowl which was all mixed into a disgusting brown. And for the third batch, RED mixed up sugar with salt because EJ didn't read the label when he handed it to her. Thankfully you caught it before the cookies ended up being baked.
Now, this is going to be the 4th batch that you'd have to throw out because RED added in way too much melted butter. You never thought this would be so stressful and far from fun.
Honestly though, you're kind of an idiot if you didn't think that RED or EJ would struggle with this.
"Stop yelling..."
"...We can just start over again."
RED looked sad when you got mad at her for a mistake that she thought was helpful, so EJ called you out, not appreciating how you're taking out your frustration on them. He actually warned you before all of this that they don't know what they're doing or how exactly to make a cookie "right" when they're not even going to be able to eat them. (Even so, RED still likes to try the batter, only to end up gagging everytime.) You growled a bit as you were trying to stay composed, massaging your temples to try and calm down because you knew that they did not deserve to be yelled at like this. Like EJ said, you should be able to start a new batter, you did stock up on enough ingredients, or so you thought you did...
"...Where are the eggs?"
You went to check the fridge for the same ingredients but there was no egg carton in sight. RED actually cringed when you asked about them because she knew that there were none left, and the empty carton was thrown in the trash. If only you bought 2 dozen instead of 1...
"We're out of eggs?! How th-"
You groaned loudly, cutting yourself off. Your frustration left you defeated so you dropped to your knees. This cute baking date just ended up becoming a stressful disaster nightmare.
"You're acting ridiculous."
"Jack..-"
"Sally isn't going to perish without a sugar cookie."
"If she wants one that bad, then she can ask Slenderman."
"It's not about Sally—I'm upset because how are we struggling this badly to make a fucking cookie??"
"We don't eat cookies, y/n."
"I warned you before all of this yet you still insisted that we'd be included."
"Maybe you should have just made the cookies by yourself then if you have a problem with us."
EJ ended up leaving the kitchen, his mask hiding his emotions but you could hear how fed up he was with you in his tone of voice. You didn't chase after him, you actually began to try and clean up the mess, starting with the dishes and the big bowl that was holding your fourth and final failure. RED still had yet to move, unsure if she should follow Jack or if she should try and help you, but with the way you kept growling under your breath, she decided that you needed your space and she ended up leaving you behind in the kitchen. You didn’t get a chance to see where she went, so you assumed she ended up following EJ. You were almost willing to be petty and shout at them "thanks for helping me clean up" but you held your tongue, not too thrilled over how upset you're becoming over this.
This was supposed to be something fun, not a fight...
You ended up cleaning the kitchen mess by yourself, forced to use paper towels to clean up all of the flour because no one found the broom in the beginning. You were also unfortunately spotted by Jeff who was first coming into the kitchen for a soda, only to find the absolute mess that you and your partners made, but they were nowhere to be found. He actually ended up laughing at you, but mainly because your face and clothes were covered in flour, to which you threw the mixing bowl at him before you stormed out, ignoring his complaints. You had been cleaning that kitchen for what felt like hours and you just wanted to take a bath and go to bed, shooting glares at anyone who ended up snickering at the sight of your messy self—thankfully it was only 2 people. Your frustration seemed to be wearing off the closer you were getting to your room, to which you realized you felt exhausted. Your head hung low with your left hand holding onto your right arm as you began to feel sad.
You wish you didn't get mad at them over this...
Maybe you should have listened when EJ suggested it wouldn't be a good idea, maybe you should have bought more eggs in the beginning, maybe you should have been more patient with them...
...But you definitely need to apologize to them.
"Y/N..?"
You stopped and turned to see RED once she called out your name. Her head was poking out from behind EJ's door until you payed attention to her, so she came out to reveal the store bought sugar cookies that she obtained for you, hoping it'll make you feel better in some way since you seemed really determined to make cookies with them but things turned out unfortunate.
"...Good?"
She asked you if the cookies she found were acceptable, and honestly, you teared up a bit because she was still trying to help you feel better despite the way you treated her earlier.
"Oh RED..."
You wanted to hug her and tell her how sorry you were. Even though she was in a bathrobe and she was worried about being spotted by someone else, she didn't push you away and welcomed you into her arms. You even got to kiss her and rub your foreheads together for a bit until RED had to pull you into EJ's bedroom because she saw someone coming down the hallway in the corner of her eye. You didn’t spot EJ immediately and you looked around for him before you asked RED where he was, to which she said he was taking a bath to clean himself off from all of the flour with the help of some lavender candles and bath salts to calm him down. She actually led you to where he was and you could see his head poking out from the tub as he was laid back with his whole body submerged. He ended up looking back to see you enter the bathroom with RED. He looked nervous when he sat up and you were extremely flustered because he is literally naked in a bathtub...
"...I didn't think you'd be the type to have a bubble bath, Jack."
You broke the awkward silence, and you smiled softly at him, to which he returned, now seeming relieved to see you in a much better mood than earlier. The bath smelled absolutely wonderful, you found yourself hovering over the tub just to grab at some bubble and smell them like they're freshly picked flowers. EJ offered if you would like to join him, seeing that you're still covered in flour and well, you're already here with him. You definitely couldn't resist when RED began to peel off your gross clothes for you. The moment you stepped into the hot water, you felt every ounce of stress melt away as your muscles began to relax. EJ actually ended up scooting closer to you, but he didn't snuggle you just yet because RED wanted to help clean out all of the food gunk from your hair, using her hands to scoop up some water, taking advantage of the opportunity to massage your scalp and occasionally plant kisses on your forehead. EJ would also sneak in a few kisses to your cheek and lips but he didn't want to get in the way of RED's care.
You were a bit surprised when EJ actually apologized to you first, for leaving you alone to clean up the mess in the kitchen but also if he seemed dismissive about how you felt. You reassured him and told him he didn't need to apologize, that it should actually be you apologizing to both him and RED, for taking out your stress onto them and for making them do something they were uncomfortable with.
"...Honestly, I should have done what RED did and just buy a batch of cookies from the store instead."
"A whole mess could have been avoided to begin with."
"Well, if you had done that, then we probably wouldn't be in this bathtub together~"
EJ ended up pulling you into his lap, keeping you close to his body, flustering you once again that you couldn't help but giggle.
"Hey... why aren't you in with us, RED?"
RED blinked at you when you asked her that question. She insisted she already had a shower earlier and that a bath for her was not needed, but she did try to humor you by sitting on the bathtub edge and putting her legs in the water. Unfortunately, that wasn't gonna be enough. The moment you and EJ looked at each other, you both knew that RED just had to share this tub with you properly.
Both of you took advantage of the fact that she had pretty much extended her legs to you and you pulled her in by grabbing onto them. Of course she protested, mainly because she didn't want her little bathrobe to get soaked, which is fine, because it's not like she's going to need it.
Definitely not for the rest of the night <3.











