(part 1 of 3) Hello! So, I've read Yearz about five times since last February. It's one of the best novel-length works I've ever read, and certainly one of the best fanfics; your grasp on the characters' personalities and trajectories is just phenomenal. But beyond all that, I'm intensely curious about what the music sounds like in your version of the story! (Forgive me if you've already addressed this somewhere and I just haven't seen it.)...
(part 2 of 3) Plastic Beach, for instance—obviously, within the fic, none of those music videos were ever made. Is there any element of collaboration with other artists at all? Maybe Murdoc could have incorporated a few existing samples (in Rhinestone Eyes, for instance), but between escaping the sinking island and releasing the album, there wouldn't have been time, let alone incentive, to record anything like White Flag that references the setting literally. So what fills those gaps?...
(part 3 of 3) I'm just as curious about the Yearz version of Humanz: whether it's as consistently political despite its in-universe hodgepodge composition; whether any of the contributors to the One-Stop Shop were artists featured on the real album; whether Saturnz Barz ever acquired its rap verses... I don't mean to demand another 100k of explanation from you, but I'd love to hear whatever you've thought out already!
Hi there! Thank you for such kind messages.
This is a really interesting question. I'm going to split this answer roughly into music and lyrics.
Honestly, my approach to Yearz!Gorillaz's music is largely due to my discomfort with including real people in fanfiction. It personally feels weird to me, to be reading about the characters and then have Snoop Dogg or Jamie or someone turn up. I get that the characters do interact with the collaborators in this way in interviews but it feels strange to include them in semi serious fanfiction.
That being said, I think there's also the issue for me that Yearz!Murdoc isn't Damon Albarn. Unlike Damon, Murdoc hasn't previously been in a world famous band and had the opportunity to build up a rolodex of famous musical contacts. No matter how notorious or zeitgeisty Murdoc's music becomes over a relatively short period of time, it didn't feel plausible to me that he'd have as many famous friends (especially given his personality…).
I'm sadly not musical enough to really imagine the music sounding different in Yearz but I definitely imagine Murdoc's approach to writing music to be polar opposite. I imagine it to be a more isolated affair, especially on PB. Essentially I imagine Murdoc to be a musical magpie. He has an encyclopedic, obsessive, Special Interest level of music knowledge and uses tons of samples (implausible as that is in reality).
As you say, I see Humanz a little differently. By that point in their career, it's more likely that a band of their fame and reputation would be able to attract famous collaborators. I definitely imagine that Stu's website attracted high calibre submissions because people wanted to be involved in what seemed destined to become a Gorillaz's album.
The way Yearz!Gorillaz writes music is definitely different - and worse - than how Actual Gorillaz writes music. It's a more insular writing process in Yearz. That's largely because Murdoc uses music writing as a way of understanding and communicating with the world and with Stu like those are different. It's obsessive, oftentimes unhealthy and verges on being a barrier to him just sharing his thoughts and emotions in, you know, an actual conversation with Stu. Actual Gorillaz, on the other hand, is clearly more collaborative in nature.
I think Yearz!Gorillaz and Actual Gorillaz's writing styles converge more in the final chapters. Murdoc and Stu's conversation about what Gorillaz is and what it should be is obviously just me, in a thinly veiled way, considering that question. Personally I think, as time goes by, Gorillaz feels less like a band and more like a project, with Damo acting as a whacky producer or compere of sorts. The creation of Song Machine seems to confirm this: it's less of a traditional approach to being in a band (album, tour, album, tour) and more of a creative, collaborative mish mash.
Much like with the music itself, I can't honestly say I imagine different lyrics to those that are actually in the songs because I'm not creative enough for that. I guess I just try and focus things through a prism of telling a semi-serious story. So, lyrics about Plastic Beach being a great, war free place, I would explain in a slopey shouldered way by saying Murdoc had a very tenuous relationship with reality at that point in time.
The political lyrics depends on their nature for me: if they're about racism in America, I definitely chalk that up to Murdoc using collaborators' input. My own take on his political bent, as influenced by his canonically saying he voted for the Greens, is kind of similar to my own: working class Midlander, no nonsense, sceptical, "anyone except these bastards" mentality. I think Yearz!Murdoc is more inclined to write cryptic, emotionally constipated but somehow also oddly sincere and honest lyrics as opposed to political stuff. I imagine Yearz!Murdoc writing We've Got The Power on 2016 election night but I don't know that he'd comment about the politics of it beyond saying Trump is a [insert expletive of choice].
Thanks again for such an interesting question and hope this explains!