dilapidatedheart mentioned you on a post
“Hello, what is your (scientific :D) opinion on transgender people and...”
@nonegenderwithleftbees which studies exactly? It’d be really helpful as I’m writing a dissertation about brain structure
Sure no worries! @dilapidatedheart
Sex beyond the genitalia: The human brain mosaic - this paper is the main one peope cite when talking about brain scans and differences in brains between genders. It’s unique in that it was one of the first studies to actually use the whole scan of the brain to look for “gender differences” (as well as size, and amount of gray vs. white matter) rather than just individual features or structures like majority of previous studies. It’s important to note however that they only looked at structure and not function of the brain. Here’s also an article on the research
Sex Redefined; the idea of two sexes is simplistic - goes over previous data and points out that even the most basic fundamental aspects of sexual differentiation (chromosomes, cells, genital anatomy, reproductive anatomy, ect.) doesn’t fit the female/male binary and that thinking in male/female terms it no longer tenable.
Black and White or Shades of Gray; Are Gender Differences Categorical or Dimensional? - this research review found that behavioural measures used to score male or females can’t actually be grouped into two categories (male or female)
Brain size, sex, and the aging brain - this research found that the “sex differences” found in their study actually turned out to be false when proper and careful analytical techniques were actually used.
The human hippocampus is not sexually-dimorphic: Meta-analysis of structural MRI volumes - this paper finds the same as the above. When proper analytical techniques are used the “results” they found on “sex differences” in the brain disappear.
The Gender Similarities Hypothesis - the above research also finds similar results to what psychologists have been reporting for for several years now; when it comes to cognitive and personality characteristics, the “two sexes” are more similar than they are different
There’s tons and tons more and there’s neroscientists (like Prof Gina Rippon) who make the really good point of pointing out that many “female / male brains are different” studies are most likely the result of gender bias and stereotyping from the researchers themselves, a result of being raised in a society that raises children with such strict gender roles, or from lack of proper and careful analysis.
Alot of these studies also don’t include trans people.