Okay, so you know that via this headcanon, I treat Merida as Princess of DunBroch, a Kingdom, and ignored the fact that she would one day become Queen because the family had male heirs, but I realised that I’ve been going through this all wrong.
Merida, could come to rule DunBroch, over the triplets – and why? Because DunBroch isn’t only a Kingdom. First, and foremost it’s a clan. And, Scottish clans were ran differently than royalty.
Clan chiefs, which is what Fergus was before the other chiefs/Lords gave him the title of King, wasn’t about heirs, or who was born first, it was about who was strong enough to lead the clan, and rule over the clan members. This often led to heirs being bet out from someone who wasn’t even part of the royal family if someone showed enough strength that they would be a better leader.
And, even more so – male OR females could be clan chief. Unlike in Ireland where it had to be a male, Scottish clans also let a woman lead. This is what I think I’m going to base Merida’s future off of. It’s not going to be if she’s going to be QUEEN, like Elinor wants, she’s going to want to be the clan of DunBroch’s chief.
Merida doesn’t want to be Queen, she’s not ready for the responsibility, but it’s understandable. Elinor rules. She is basically what every Disney Princess/Disney Queen is. She is not the chief, she is not the strength and power that Fergus is that makes him the chief. She’s the intelligence, righteous force behind Fergus and keeps him in line. She’s the diplomat. Merida doesn’t want to be that. She wants the sword in her hand, the arrows flying from her aim and the chance to show that she can lead.
Clan leaders can be elected, so unless there’s full support from the people in the clan then the first born son (or daughter in this case, as its normal if the male heir cannot lead, and the triplets are so young) may not be adopted as head of the clan. The clan’s chief. So if MacIntosh, Maguffin and Dingwall clans riot then there can be a war and disruption – exile and dare I saw it, brute force to get what we want, just like we saw in Once Upon a Time.
This is why I’m going to take it this way – Merida will fight to be chief of her clan, but not to be Queen of her Kingdom. I’m running Merida as a daughter who lives as part of a Scottish clan, not as the Princess of a Kingdom.