This is very true, and the ādisappearing middle classā is a huge thing in Europe too. People think middle class means āwent to collegeā or ānot that poorā, but itās about how much power you have within capitalism. If the power of your boss or contractor, your landlord or mortgage could fuck up your whole life? Thatās working class. Even if you have a car and a bit of savings, still working class. That is your relationship to capitalism. Someone else holds the power.
Buuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuut⦠thatās not the whole story.
Ya see, while the old middle class disappeared, the myth of it has been kept alive. This myth has been used to divide of the working class into two groups: those who are seen as inherently working class and those who are seen as āculturallyā middle class who just happen to be making $12 per hour on a temporary contract at the university.
Itās a social construct. But it is not without consequences.
If you are perceived as āculturallyā middle class - even if your relationship to capitalism is absolutely that of a worker - you are treated differently by the system. You are given more opportunities and second chances. You have a better chance in court. You are less likely to lose custody over your children during hard times. You have a chance at better housing. You are, yes, privileged, in ways that people who are viewed as āthe poorsā are not.
This is not a privilege in kind, but in degree. Like light skinned privilege, or being seen as the āgood/safeā among the mentally ill, or being seen as the good gendernormative gay person. You may have a low income but you are not like those people: the uneducated poors, the multi-generation poors, the rude poors, the trashy poors. Youāre not a chav/redneck/prole/tokkie. No, youāre better. You have āclassā. And if you just collaborate with the system as if youāre middle class, you might escape the worst of the violence of capitalism.
(And no, you canāt opt out of that privilege by roleplaying poverty. Itās actually pretty offensive when you make a point of pride out of torn-up jeans, while those without that privilege have to put effort into not being vilified for their poverty. Itās a pretty good sign of privilege to think itās cool to look poor. Stop it.)
Itās important to acknowledge this privilege and to be aware of how it impacts our place in the workers struggle. Did everyone in your anti-capitalist group go to college? Are the ones who went to college always doing the public speaking and running the show? Thatās a big big problem, my friend. It means youāre excluding, erasing and speaking over the most marginalized within the working class. Change that.