What doesnât kill you makes you wish you had been killed.
Even her hair was wincing as she spoke that. But her listeners were unaware. There was a sound elsewhere, a transient siren wailing in and out of audible seesaw. And then she laughed at the irony, her cigarette failing to stay in her lips, falling to the ground in carelessness.
Her friends were plastic but they were still friendsâand in the eyes of the public, who could really cite the difference?
The unannotated life is not worth living.
Something her professor said onceâor many times. She could not remember, at least not in that moment. She was too distracted by a scent of burning brick. There was a building nearby, ablaze in the autumn sun. It was an ironic cruelty to her. If only the building had held on for just a couple more months, when the heat of air would have frozen shut, it might have survived.
But spring rain was far gone and distance between seasons immeasurable to sitting brick. Theory versus Praxis. Concept of a building versus an Actual building burning down. Who has more merit?
âThey build them too big these days. Too many people trying to live here. Too easy for everything to catch fire.â
Her friend said this without looking up from her screen, which seethed at her, while she adjusted the frolics of her hair and buttered her cheeks in fake blush. It was quite a talent to conversate and remodel yourself at the same time, all for the sake of advancing both your physical life and your digital one. Electricity crackling in identity-indemnity.
Another one of the friends scowled, âNo, itâs the air. The planet is warming up. This is just the new reality.â
Same as the old one, Effy thought. But fake concern is fashionable these days, so she nodded, wondering where her cigarette had gone. Did it disappear? Burn out from ash to vapor?
Such a quandary to befall Effy, she secretly wished her philosophy professor was here to help, despite his arrogance and inappropriateness. But she scoffed. She already knew what he would say.
Who got off first? The Thumb or the Cigarette Lighter?
Detach all the parts and reassemble them. Not totally dissimilar to the process required to go through to rebuild that tower of dust next door. Effy sighed. They had been waiting in line forever.
The sky was so still and soothing. It should have been hot. Nay a cloud in sight yet the sun was not visible, and nothing was scalding in horrid heat. It was as though the day had taken the day off and let a cardboard cut-out of itself stand in its place.
Effy nodded. Yes, it was exactly like thatâa diorama day.
âIâll ask what the meaning to life is. Because thatâs what everybody asks.â
Hen announced this to useless fanfare, an unresponsive audience hideously indifferent. Even her own friends, Effy and the other one, were totally nonchalant and undisturbed to craft a response.
You see, Hen had always been the boring friend, the mild one, never really understanding anything they went through, being so gullible and terrifically malleable, Effy and Foneface could have their way with her as a neat sycophant without worrying about upsetting whatever imaginary balance of power assembled between them. But unbeknownst to them, Hen was a kind and sorry person. She would never hurt anyone. Is it so wrong to be weak?
Weakness is in the eye of the beholder.
Vulnerability to one predator is poisonous skin to another. Tiny frog can kill giant snakeâif the timing is right. Not to refer to Hen as a noxious creature. She was quite the opposite. Phonie could be very mean and viscous toward her sometimes. Effy was never like that. She did her best to stick up for her oily-fleshed friend, even if sometimes she became annoyed and fanged herself.
âWas that a joke?â Phonie snickered. âHen, darling, if you ask anything youâll bore the poor thing to tears.â
One time they were out in the night, in the guts of metropolis, all puffed up and skinned, searching for adventure in the form of partying, only to find a rather dead scene. So they decided upon going to an arthouse theater to get high and watch an opaque treat. The decision was between two particular film choices, which Effy and Phonie disagreed on. So, it was Hen assigned to the role of ultimate arbiter.
Both sides attempted to persuade the jury to their view. Phonie offered to assist Hen with her godawful bangs in exchange for a vote. To this, Hen grasped the tendrils of her hair, sheepishly, asking if they thought her hair was actually awful. IâŠI thought it looked fine. The person who cut it said it looked fine.
Phonie laughed at her. But Effy was stoic. She explained how Henâs hair was neat as it is and how she did not have to worry about how she looked. That none of that matters anyway, unless you let it matter.
Then Effy wrapped her arm around Henâs shoulder like a python gripping a branch, and inquired what deep in her heart was her true intentâwhich facetiously profound, pretentious film did she herself fancy to view. Hen, in pre-sob stage, sniffling and everything, quit clutching her hair and told Effy she would see whatever she wanted to see. Phonie rolled her plastic eyes. You always take her side.
And that is how it has always been. A battle between two superior extroverts, and their subterfuge against one another to manipulate their less inclined best friend to support either of their claims to power. Of course, just as Phonie claimed, Hen did have a tradition of legitimizing Effyâs crown more often than notâexcept in those times when Phonie managed to scare Hen in to servitude.
âOkie. Something decent then. What is the difference between âin toâ and âintoâ? Iâve always wondered that.â Hen queried.
âIs it âin toâ or âintoâ?! Does it matter? Why does intent and implication mean anything to you? Canât things just be things and happen because they happen?â Phonie barked at her.
Effy grinned, something Phonie could not see because she was locked on that crystal ball in her hands, which she plodded her fingers upon precipitously. So Effy turned to Hen, and they both smiled at each other and silently giggled. Despite her aptitude for submissiveness, it was not as if Hen was not capable of inflicting grievance in subtle and sardonic ways. After allâhow did they become friends?
The line moved forward like a lazy caterpillar. Sirens still blared in the background. Effy took out another cigarette. It had been an hourâor more.
An hour is nothing when you think about it. Evolution took millions of years to mold man from oozeâthough it should have stopped at woman. The universe took billions of years to spark the first atoms and elements, with a few billion more to shape them into anything remarkable.
In a day there are twenty-four hours; in a year there are three-hundred-and-sixty-five days. Everything that is everything is nearly a trillion years aged. So equate that wine and when you realize how deep the red goes, you may find yourself wary of expecting longitude from an hour. Time only works when there is a lot of it.
But an hour waiting in line, doing nothing, among strangers you do not care about or maybe even despise, while the sky is blank, air stale, buildings burning, sirens crying, with friends like theseâwell, Effy was prepared to blast her brains out on the sidewalk, coloring drab gray in gorgeous gore.
And if love of self proved to be too overwhelming, then Effy considered at least blowing Phonie to pieces.
It is healthy to think about homicide every day.
Her professor joked about this once. Half the class got it. The other half was appalled. But that is what you get for taking things so seriously, opening yourself up to abhorrence and outrage. Not to say these feelings did not come from an authentic placeâEffy learned from a former student that Professor had twice attempted to take his own life. Once before he met his wifeâagain after she left him. Maybe there was a third time, even, which is why his wife abandoned him. Is our marriage not good enough to keep you alive? Why did she not say love?
Effy knew a secret. Something no one else in class knew. Discovered when she came in during off-hours to discuss a missing essay. Her professor showed her the gun he kept in his desk. His face pretended to be humored and casual, but his neck was trembling, and she knew it was the real thing. He told her that every single day he came in to class, he thought about taking the gun out and shooting all these complacent, ignorant fools right in the headâa shepherd come to lay his flock to rest. But then Effy would walk in, and he immediately regretted even thinking it. If you missed just one class, Effy, IâI donât know what Iâd do.
Was that guilt or shame or longing? Effy could not discern the difference. It was a toxic abomination of everything wrong and sublime. Nobody had ever cared so much about her. She related perfectly to his sentiment. Her whole life, she had been waiting for someone to say how she feltâto speak a mind of amoral violence and a disappointment at how society has become. She comforted him. And that is when he kissed her.
Then she pushed him away, embarrassed, thinking she had found a companion in mind, but he was only disgusted flesh, still trying to express itself the only way it knew how.
As Effy thought about this, she felt a nudge on her shoulder. Hen reminded her to take a step, for the long procession of bodies had propelled itself forward for a split-second, only to halt its progress and seethe in its banality.
I wait; therefore I canât go.
Smoke strung above. Lengthy laps of bubbling smolder carried with them a dissolved grave of brick and molding. We build and build and build, only to leave ruin and ash.
Her professor resigned the semester after their encounter. For inappropriate physical conduct regarding a female student. Then he killed himself.
Effy wondered if the student had wandered into the same web she had, only instead of escaping, she tore herself out completely. Quite the contradiction it all seemed to be. All these situations never quite as clear as clarity. Effy disliked her professor for that. But it is not like she could criticize his painâonly the method through which he consoled it.
All great pains must first don venomous and suicidal masks before they may have empathy from humanity.
A stellar argument to be made, Effy considered. If evolution transformed the prey into predator, then what transformed the victim into victimizer? Effy recalled her obsession with serial killers during her youth. How mesmerizing they were to her, these persons who consciously chose to torment and murder other people. What a level of disdain one must have. Effy did not think of them as psychotic freaks. Maybe they were hateful, or apathetic, but never freakish. People who let âGodâ touch them are the true freaks.
God isnât deadâbut Heâs getting there.
God is genderless. God is plural. God is everything and nothing and anything we want it to be. God just is. For Effy, damnation was real. Internally. Once you have damned yourself, you may as well be damned by all. But God is fictitious. Only so far as to assume we could ever conceive of God, and then further assume we could have adequate ways of worshiping God. But thank God for God, Effy figured, because without anything above us, we might assume we were God. As if we did not already fight each other over our egos.
Professor had an appreciation for spirituality. One session, he deemed it necessary to educate the class on reincarnation and karma and mediation. One of the students pronounced himself an atheist, arguing ceaselessly against Buddha and Jesus and Peace and Chaos, until finally leaving class cursing and yelling. Professor just chuckled.
Thought experiment: what caused the creation of the universe? Answers? Guess whatânobody knows. No one on the entire spectrum of this molten beach can provide an explanation on how it happened. And this is what Professor proposed to the class: if anyone can say to me with any sort of certainty that there is something to believe, then they automatically pass and do not have to attend class for the remainder of the semester. Many came forth with their own ideas, but they all had their doubts. Effy didnât even try.
There is no possible certainty in anything we believe and certainly this is true.
Professor must have been quite amused then. When the god-hating student returned the following class, everyone ridiculed him. Except for Effy. Ignorance is its own cross to bearâbut vain ignorance is casting the first stone. All you do is set yourself up for failure and invite the possibility of resurrection.
Effy coughed. Smoke got her. She glared at her cigarette, but it was not lit. No, this was vaporous decomposition from the smoldering building around the corner, which looked upon the sky and sought to replace nonexistent clouds with itself. The whole line was coughing, but these toxic fumes did not deter anyone from changing their position. The opportunity here outweighed anything nature could shove at them.
âIs it okay to feel nothing at all?â Hen pondered aloud.
Her friends were caught in their own mental comas, but she had no such entertainment. Phonie ignored her. Effy acted as if she mulled it over, then told Hen, âThatâs an alright question. I think the answer is feel how you want to feel. Maybe itâs something to save for another time, you know what I mean?â
Hen nodded, defeated. Without missing a chance for insult, Phonie interposed, âYou should ask how to properly wash your skin. They might think I brought my pet toad with me.â
Phonie snapped a portrait of herself snickering, sunglasses hovering in reflected smoke, while Hen bit her lip, staring at her feet sullenly. Effy should have said something, but she was lost again in memory and rhetoric.
Her Professor left behind no suicide note. They say everybody does, but Effy was skeptical of that claim. There was no disbelief, although they say this is a sign of grief. There was no grief. Not for Effy. Probably not for his wife.
It was in the Spring. When life was blooming and being reborn. His class supposedly waited twenty minutes for him to arrive, before they finally just left. Then he was absent a second time. And a third. Counting all the time that must have passed until somebody was concerned enough to noticeâŠ
The story goes it was two weeks gone, then at last a student emailed Professor asking what gives. But Effy can tell you what takes. Not God. Not Death. But Choice. Consequence. Chance. What are the chances anybody would have guessed that their caustically sarcastic philosophy Professor would kill himself? Not a high enough amount to care, apparently.
He had contacted Effy over break, around Christmas. When the world stung with cold, bitter spite. He was lonely, spending the holidays all alone. Effy could relate. She chose not to go back home, staying at school instead. She dreaded her family. Like she ever asked to be born. Never.
She fed them some bullshit excuse about an internship and they sent holiday money which she promptly spent on drugs and clothesâbecause you should look nice in your misery. And feel nice, too.
Professor invited Effy out for a frosty beverageâas if coldness meant nothing to them. Hindsight, so they say, is a twenty divided over another, which in regular sight is one.
How is âoneâ so supremely wise? The problem was never just one. It was when one was joined by another one. Then these two ones were interrupted by a new one, and this third one hatched the serpentine conspiracy that would undo all of them. Apologies for repeating such a recurrent refrain.
One thing Effy should have done was decline. But she was lonely. She was spending the holidays all alone. Professor could relate. His wife was not there. His dog had passed away. His family condemned him for his menial career choiceâbesides, he loathed his family. Like he ever asked to be born. Ever.
They met at a collegiate bar, a hole where sometimes other professors watered their snouts. But not this time, especially fortunate since Professor did not deign for others to see him drinking with a former student. He had been exposed before. Nearly plunged into a forceful resignation.
âFuck them, who cares!â Effy slashed words with her throat. âWhy do math professors need to drink? Or engineering ones? Their lives are fine, their studentsâ lives are fine. Everything up-to-date and paid-for, nothing left behind, no lingering questions, no insurmountable weight surrounding a desire to ask why to everything?â
Effy considered herself to have a point. They never bother asking why. They just learn how to build and then they built. Even while everything burned down eventually.
Professor sipped his beer, smiling like a talking pig. âYouâre passionate about this.â
Effy nodded, gulping her beer, hoping to impress with her blasé consumption. Secretly, she thought beer tasted like fetid piss.
Professor shrugged. âSome of our most famous and profound philosophers were mathematicians and engineers themselves. They fancied those things. Math and Science comes from philosophy; those are their roots. The ancients desired to understand the natural worââ
âI know all this, so what?â She interrupted him. âWeâre not talking about the ancients here. Weâre talking about 21st-Century Society, a place where everyone is just endlessly complacent and empty-head. Fuck! They donât care where their roots come fromâthey donât even eat the plant anymore!â
They both laughed. He knew what she meant; she knew what he had meant. Then Effyâs mood grew pensive.
âSometimes⊠I feel like Iâm Angry Adorno. Screaming at everybody to shut the fuck up about superheroes and celebrities already. Mass Culture is fascist poison. All it does is make me furious at Mass Society. I just wish⊠I just wish that some people would, at least, agree with me.â
Effy finished her beer, its rotten spell swirling around her.
Professor, calmly and comfortably, responded, âWell, sometimes I feel like Regretful Hitler. Which is to say: sometimes the last thing you want is people agreeing with you.â
Effy giggled. A sudden warmness overtook her. They clinked the tip of their bottles together, salutation to their own rightness. Effy pretended there was still a sip left, drinking void. Professor ordered another beer for himself, then asked Effy what she preferred. âI know you donât like beer. Youâre not as good an actress as you think.â
She requested a gin and tonic instead. âAm I a good philosopher at least?â
Some unrecognizable tune fell in the background. He stared at her, silent. Until they uneasily chuckled. Then he asked, âWhat do you want to do with your life?â
He seemed semi-serious, as if he had doubted his own student. Effy was taken aback, believing he would have been on her side. âUh, what do you mean? I want to study philosophy. I want to be a thinker. I want to ask the great questions.â
Professor shook his head. âItâs not too late to save yourself.â
Effy insisted. âI enjoy knowing things. But more than that, I enjoy not knowing. Iâll be fine. I wonât be around forever anyway. Probably a shorter time than you thinkâŠâ
She mumbled the last part while guzzling her gin and tonic, hiding her true intentions. But he knew what she was implying. In a dark and miserable empathy, he approved of it. He accepted it. This is why she was so fond of him. There was no judgment. No pleading out of ignorance. No guilt.
âAlright then, Effy. I believe thatâs what you want. Hereâs to a life of financial failure and societal mockeryâcheers!â
They clunk their glasses once again, contented knowing their only reward in life being what they know. With this difficult topic removed, Effy became more playful.
âIf you met Godâassuming God existsâwhat would you ask him?â
Effy posed the question. She was curious to pick the brain of her preferred professor.
âNothing. I donât have anything to say to that asshole.â
Effy laughed, genuinely and sweetly. Professor had a smile, too, but it was hung-up, rather than natural.
âWhat would you ask, Effy?â
âUmmâŠâ She did not know what to say.
She thought about all the possible question, subtracting cliché and obvious queries, configuring together a question of riddle and wit, almost as if she was trying to outsmart a genie rather than god.
After a minute, her Professor egged her on. âCome on, Effy, master philosopher. What are you going to ask?â
âFuck, I donât know! I canât make my mind up!.â
âWhat kind of philosopher canât make up their mind?â Professor retorted.
Effy, her nerves loose and whittling at the same time, realized it was not God she was trying to outwit, but her professor.
âDonât all philosophers essentially âmake up their mindsâ?â Effy answered.
Her Professor laughed, the first time he had truly done it sincerely, his usual morbidity bled away in a hurdle of humor. After that, there was no more conversation of philosophy. They spoke about music, art, politics, lost loves, new crushes, poor students and even poorer convictions.
Every time a holiday song appeared in the bar, they would boo at unseen speakers. They rejoiced in each otherâs company, without feeling remorse or contempt about separating themselves from their family. They were two cynical and jaded ones, spit upon by life and society, crushed by their knowledge of knowledge, their ability to know better than to think they know anything at all. But then, they must have known that?
They applauded senseless argument and welcomed paradox. They so desperately wanted someone to come by and tell them both they were wrong just so they could agree with it. So they could watch the look of this someoneâs face as they muddled an appropriate response to a situation where they were expecting conflict. Effy and Professor both got a wicked joy from defusing the fuse, then igniting it again.
None of that ever happened.
There was no âsomeoneâ. Effy and Professor intoxicated themselves with toxic liquids and pessimism. By a certain point, Effy was joyously presenting her scars of previous pains as trophies inscribed in her flesh.
âThese are my trophy scars,â she proudly proclaimed.
Professor examined them, not an ounce of antipathy visible in his eyes. âThose are dandy but check this ugliness out.â
He pulled his collared shirt away from his neck, revealing a line of bundled flesh across it. Effy gasped. For all her seditious attitude, she still expressed sympathy when she witnessed this.
âIs it from your first time or the second?â she asked.
âHow did you know it was two times?â
Effyâs face bellied-up in blush, revealing the only card she had to keep hidden. But Professor was amiable about it, smiling at her, saying it was alright, he knows people talk about himâoh, and by the way, it was both times.
âHow about you?â Professor waved for a whiskey.
Effy nibbled on her lip, nervous. âNot yetâbut someday soon.â
Suddenly, the scent of smoke.
By now, this linear assembly of people, seemed to have not grown nor wither at all. It was purgatorialânot enough people cared to wait in line to make it longer and yet the people who had been were too many people to be waiting behind in line.
Phonie puckered her lips, then muttered, âAsking questions is arbitraryâwhen I finally get in there, Iâm just going to say, âfuck offâ and leave.â
Hen did not appreciate the sentiment, but Effy mumbled a derisive amen and flicked her lighter. Another cigarette is just what she needed.
Hen peered down the street, catching no glimpse of fire, but a cauldron of black air. A sigh sung from her mouth, almost delicately, somewhat rhythmically remorseful. âWhy do we have to suffer? Maybe Iâll ask that question.â
Effy sneered at her cigarette.
Man suffers only because he has to.
For all the bluster blowing from that building, Effy thought it bizarre she heard no screaming. No weeping. No torment. None of it. Either they were all dying in silence or Effy was blessed by deafness. Ambulances came and went, inspiring confidence in passersby, but no sirens, while Effy visualized a mental image of charred and scorched corpses stuffed in the back, with those alive churning out organs and blood and skin all over the walls and attendants, and the driver somehow must keep a straight face during all this agony and anguish. Ambulances must be a special kind of hell.
Lying is a sin. At least, Effy recalled it as such. She has had her share of spewing lies and fantasy. When her professor asked her what she wanted to do in life, she imagined she spun a sarcastic joke to him. Truth is, when he asked her this humiliating question, she did not say anything. Effy did not know what she wantedâshe still doesnât. Or she wants everything and anything and nothing. And how can you want that?
Not peace but peace of mind. As if that will ever happen...
Three things are necessary for the absolution of Man: man, men, and Man.
A hulking behemoth of ruby-scorched metal and lucid flash hunkered beside the sidewalk. Not just one either, but multiples, multiplying to a web, almost entrapping all the little flies within their line. Giant chimps in helmets and rubber gowns winded between them, passing out facemasks and cool air.
One of them glared at Effy as her cigarette twinkled beneath smoky sky. âOh, you donât know?â She snorted. âWeâre all saved now!â
They moved on and so did the line, but Effy was still stuck, the glue of the past enveloping her prescient feet. Everybody else was coughing. Lungs weakening, sweet oxygen stiffened by putrid perfume, tasting like hollowed-out chocolate cooked in a kiva of dust.
âFor your dissertationâcan I steal a cigarette from you?â Professor asked, back outside the bar.
His breath, diluted by alcohol, lacked a visible exhaust in the frigid moon, instead appearing as normal, which is to say not appearing at all. Still, ice crept everywhere with snow trampling down. Effy stumbled with her carton, its riddling lid unsolvable and beyond her simple skills, confounding her for some time until she accidentally dropped it. With fragile cigarettes drenched in snow, Effy and Professor both cried out, searing the streetlights with their special brand of agnostic sorrow.
âTo what God shall we pray?â Professor asked. âThe only one that exists!â
He had a charming sort of laugh. It was mischievous but rare. And it involved only his headâhis neck remained motionless. What meant most to Effy, however, was the way he looked directly in to her eyes when he did it, sharing and wanting.
Effy knew she probably should not have done what she didâoh, it must be holiday and reverence causing such moments to miraculously sprout into being. Or gin and beer. Both?
Effy thought about her apartment. Nobody was there. Nobody was coming over. Then she thought about friends and family and lovers and suddenly, there was a blank space in her mind where these sort of memories should be, proceeding to an epiphany of the kind only Christmas lights and child-prophets could make you feel.
Her face curdled. âAre we alone in this world?â
Professor shoveled her face from the pavement, coiling his arm around her shoulder, her cynical charm and laissez-faire attitude dissipated to unaffected fear, soon replaced by effectual sorrow.
âMaybe we are, but thatâs what makes having each other so wonderful.â
Her tears sloshed down her cheeks. She smashed them in shame, mortified to show emotion, of all things, especially in front of her Professor and philosophical peer. She shook her head, calling herself a baby, a witless loser. Professor waved those aspersions aside, assuring her there was nothing wrong with feeling anything. Rationality is not the only trait that defines human; feelings were as important as rhetoric and logic. Because otherwise, what would we be? Empty machines?
It was placating then, but that shallow sentiment has since soured. Effy meditated on herself. Still empty. Still worthless. Still slithering through life like a worm wearing a corpse.
As affectionate as it was, reason has its regrets.
Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be thinking it instead
Planets spinning while their moons loop around them, stars dancing in place, a constant array, unchanged for eonsâthousands of years before, the same constellations hung in their window as in ours. Yet, we think of ours as being so much clearer.
There is no sky anymore. Just a cauldron of black. Some have given up hope and abandoned their gravities. We may move further than ever, but it is still in the same direction, a linear certitude reminding us how lesser our dimension truly is. Oh, thereâs something: truth.
Hen has that look on her face againâsheâs about to ask a hideously insipid question.
âWhat if it knows the future? Should I ask if Iâll ever find love? Or if Iâll be successful?â
It isnât necessary to peer at Phonie because we know already she is going to say something scathingâprobably without diverting attention from her precious electric-obelisk.
âItâs not a damn crystal-ball, Hen! God, you can be so obnoxious sometimes!â
When Hen is ashamed, her right arm grasps her left, curling inward, as if trying to make herself smaller, to minimize her disgrace to a reduced surface area. Guilt as gravity.
Not that she has ever done anything wrong. It is the way she does itâso vapid and cloying. A teenager intently acting like a child to appear more innocent and guileless, but they know what they did wrong. She should have learned by now, but perhaps she still behaves in this manner just to infuriate Phonie.
Smoke distorts the view, muddles distance. They must be closer, though, considering it has been hours, they must have gotten somewhere by now.
So it is almost a surprise when Effy sees the roped gates and hanging shrouds of an entrance, or what appears to be an entrance, and the line of people in front of her becomes black bound void. Behind it is the long dark outline of a building, or some supernal structure, holding this abyss contained within, the noise and smoke and pallor of this world seemingly dissipating around it. And it seems to have come out of nowhere, and as she looks around it, she cannot recall what building it is. Had they passed such a building to get here?
Suddenly, Effyâs chest is wringing. No question. No question. Shit, she hasnât prepared a question yet. What has she been doing this whole damn time?
Phonie struts in front of them. âIâll go first, it makes the most sense.â
Whatever, that gives Effy ample appendage to fumble something out of the nothingness of her mind. The doormen let Phonie in, their eyes hidden by sunglasses.
It was a surprising lack of security for something so monumental. When it had first arrived from space, the entire world was abrupt. Celebrations, curses, ceremonies. Pacts were forged or reinstated, alliances drawn, supply lines slowed then sped up. For a second, and it was only a second, it seemed as if the human race had finally come to know peace. But eventually the novelty wore off. Countries went back to their places. All the wars and famines and economies continued on. Still, though, it was a nice thing to have, and a nice post on social media to say you had gone and been, spoken to it directly, asked it the one question it promised all people.
That, of course, was the bargain. Every individual was permitted one question to ask. That was it. Many kept secret what they asked. Others bragged. It was like a bunch of apes stuck in this contest of proving shadows to one another.
Effy sighs. She still canât think of what to ask. And isnât this just her whole fucking problem?
What would her Professor have asked? Probably nothing. He was too cynical for that. What was Phonieâs question then? Something about how to be more popular, how to gain more followers, how to reap clout? Perhaps the perfect makeup routine? Then there was Hen, oh, cute little Hen, her mind like a roving eggâwhat could she possibly ask? Does God exist? Is evolution real? What really came firstâthe chicken or the egg?
Does it even matter? Effy cannot figure this out. She is still going to be Effy after this. She is not going to be richer nor wiser nor prettier. Even if this thing can divine the secret of immortality to her, is Effy capable of executing it? Does she want to live forever? Does she want to see so many winters come to pass, so many summers come to harvest, so much time that time becomes little, to the point that an hour feels like a breath, a year like a splash of water, and her whole life moving through chrysalis and entropy and regeneration so many times that it starts to feel like dressing herselfâlike life is just another thing to do in the morning before going out.
Funny then that Effy sees time pass her by here. Suddenly, Hen is gone. Effy assumes sheâs gone in. Now sheâs next in line. The sun is setting while smoke raises it up. The fire is dying down but maybe thatâs wishful thinking.
âYouâre next,â one of the guards say. âHeyâare you there?â
Effy snaps back. She apologizes. They open the entrance and wave her through. Finally, sheâs here. The proverbial line has ended.
As she walks, she feels numb. Almost like sheâs forgotten how to walk. She stumbles a bit, smiles, tries to seem as normal as possible out of fear they may consider her out of order and remove her when sheâs come so close. But the guards arenât even paying attention, and Effy is going through a hallway as freely and dumbly as she pleases.
No furniture. No carpet. There are lanterns hanging on the wall, glowing crimson and emerald. A door is at the endâthe only door there, with a knob of ebon glass, etched in nothing, with no discernible material on the door itself, leaving wonder if it is made of wood or plastic or whatever carbon manifest it is.
Effy approaches. She holds up her hand but pausesâno, Effy, this is it. You cannot stop now. You need to quit being a frightened little bitch about this. Your whole life youâve been runningâsorry, thatâs clichĂ©. My whole life I have been ignoring this thing inside me. I must ask it, ask anything, anything at all. This is itâŠ
Effy opens the door and enters.
In the room is a translucent chair and nothing else. Its back is facing the door, so Effy assumes itâs meant for her. As soon as she sits, the Inquisitor appears.
âHello to you,â the Inquisitor says.
Its voice is low, cold, like a wind, without any of the attachments or forces. A wind that does not blow or move or carry, but still heard and felt.
Effy shivers, then says hello. Sheâs nervous yet relieved that the Inquisitor looks like nothing. She was expecting some monstrous alien spectacle, but instead they appear as a spectral shroud, no face or body visible, just waves of a shadow.
âYour name is Effy?â the Inquisitor asks.
âYes. Do you, uhâdo you have name?â Effy replies.
âI have told the people to call me Inquisitor. It is simpler that way. I understand names are a significant symbolic gesture, so I appease that. I am the symbol. You are the guest.â
âYes, a guest. Thank you for having me.â
Effy bites her lip. She doesnât want to say the wrong thing. The Inquisitor doesnât seem bothered by small talk.
âHow is your day, Effy?â the Inquisitor asks.
âOh,â Effy says, surprised. âItâs not bad. A bit rough outside and boring to wait, butâuh, how is your day?â
âSame as every day. And if that day should be different, I shall cease to be useful.â
Effy nods. The two of them stare at each other for a few moments. Are they intrigued? Curious? What is going through either mind at this moment? Certainly questions, or maybe not, something more like feeding, eating the air around each other, placing the crumbs of their lives in comparison to try and make sense of a thing that no longer exists. How else can you assess the past? Whether it be a day or a lifetime.
Effy decides to break the silence, âYouâre a lot taller than I thought youâd be.â
The Inquisitor laughs, then says, âOnly because you are sitting. So, Effy, as I told everyone elseâyou can ask me one question and only one, and I shall answer it. I have traversed this universe an infinite times over, seen all things and dreamt all others. I know all that is and all that will ever be. What is your question?â
Effy ponders and ponders. Her thoughts dangle on the edge of her mind, forever out of reach, threatening to cut imaginary flesh and rend her incompletely torn. By now, she should have thought of something. After how many yearsâafter how many books? After all that she had been through and said and done and been andâyet things cannot come together. Yet thoughts are random and distant and inconclusive. Has she failed? Has an ideology never formed? Is hers a system that cannot function to finish even its most fundamental task?
That to have a mind is to think. And to think is to ask questions. To wonder and expand beyond the shroud of primal shadows. Overcoming that abyss and casting ignorant nature to ruin beneath you.
But Effy has never thought about it. All the great questions have been asked. Some of them answered. And here, Effy realizes, is the problemâshe doesnât actually care. Even if the Inquisitor can explain to her the meaning of life, it wouldnât make her life any more meaningful. Sheâd still be Effy. Sheâd still be smoking cigarettes on the sidewalk with her friends. Theyâd still be Phonie and Hen. Phonie would still be self-absorbed while Hen would remain as delicately obtuse as ever. And, so too, would Effy still be lingering, thinking about her Professor, who is now dead and may never know the meaning of it.
Sheâs shaking, trying to hide it. But eventually, she decides to tell the truth.
âI canât make up my mind,â Effy rubs her head in frustration. âWhat question should I ask you?â
âAsk me why you cannot make up your mind.â
âWhy canât I make up my mind?â
âTo answer that, you will have to get back in line and ask again.â
Effy scoffs, then protests, âThatâs not an answer.â
âThe rules are you only get to ask one question. If you want another, you will have to wait in line again. Please make way for the next guest.â
âNo, thatâs fucked! You lied. Youâre supposed to answer my question. Give me the goddamn truth for onceââ
The Inquisitor interrupts her, âI promise you, Effy, I already did.â
And with that, the Inquisitor vanishes.
All that remains is Effy, sitting in a chair, tears going down her cheeks. All that stumbling and stewing and studying, gone to waste in an effusive moment, remaining only an effigy of reason, this thinkerâs chair, emptying and lonely.
After a few minutes she sighs, then gets up and leaves the way she came.
All that is real is ridiculous, and all that is ridiculous is real.
Outside Effy returns, the night taking on its appearances while the smoke dissipates. No sirens blare, no people argue. Just the languishing line and its many disciples, coated in dusk, streetlight smog, storefronts gazing in neon eyes and appetites shadowing a taste.
In the distance, Effy thinks she sees snow falling, but that wouldnât be right. She looks for Phonie and Hen but theyâre nowhere to be foundâuntil they find her, through the phone, a message explaining they had gone for bubble tea down the street. They didnât wait for her.
Effy sighs. She wanders along the sidewalk, not sure where to go. No sense waiting for them or waiting for the line again. Just no sense, nonsense, all senses deprived and spread thin across void until they are no longer alive, no longer being at all.
Effy pinches her skin, trying to stretch it that way, spread it out. But it just hurts, snaps back to place. Then she laughs, truly and genuinely, like she hasnât in such a long time, no longer waiting for a joke, no longer searching for the punchline. Because it has to be that way, that cycle of nil, that constant draining of things into other things, until the original is indistinguishable from its copy.
And thenâonly thenâcan you know what is true.