Never Have I Ever... [2025-05-01]
It had been on her mind all week and now it was finally almost time.
Nerves had her indecisive as fuck, changing up her outfit more times than she'd have liked but she finally settled on something. It was times like this where she wished she had more, eye catching outfits, but such was the life of a simple, quiet girl. Quiet on the outside, as her mind was anything but. And again, on this day, it was racing.
Racing through thoughts of lust, of desire, she knew that alcohol plus this wild mind of hers would completely juxtapose itself with the look she was giving off. Innocent, but just waiting to be proven naughty.
Her phone vibrated, a message from her partner flashing up on the screen.
'Gonna be here soon?' read the message. She'd been trying to figure out the perfect fit, lost in her mind, lost in her fantasy, but that reminded her this was was soon to be reality.
She stole one last glance in the mirror before grabbing her keys and phone and headed out.
After a short walk she ended up in front of her friend Sara's building. A nondescript brick building, she walked up the front path and towards the front doors. She shivered as she walked, not sure if nerves, the crisp autumn air or the anticipation of what was to come.
Finding the call box on the wall, she ran through the list of names until a familiar one popped up, and hit the call button. A buzz shortly followed announcing that the doors were unlocked and she pushed inside.
The ground floor lobby had a strange feeling to it, we'll call it the Vegas rule, one of those places that had seen so much over the years, but as they say, what happens in Vegas...
Ally walked over to the elevator and pressed the call button, checking herself out in the reflection of the elevator door while she waited; an oversized flannel was buttoned up to the collar, keeping in the warmth, but that was needed no longer. She worked down the buttons, letting it flow freely at her sides, revealing a black tank top underneath.
She posed a little, doing a bit of a spin as the shirt flowed around her. Adjusting the hem of her shirt and pulling down the top, she tried her best to make this simple outfit reflect her naughty mind, when suddenly the door opened. Caught in embarrassment she straightened back out, her hands shooting to her side as a (rather attractive she must say) guy walked appeared between the doors. She shuffled to the side as he walked past her, then looked back. As usual, a sixth sense must exist as she looked up and caught his stare, giving him a gotcha look, but once she got in the elevator it'd all be quite clear.
She stepped in and caught another glance at herself, once again in the reflection of the doors. Whether it was the chilly fall evening, or the excitement building inside, one look at her chest and you could tell exactly what that look was for.
The elevator took a second, but finally landed at the fourth floor. She stepped out into a faint cigarette smell, the hallways of the building akin to a cheap hotel, claustrophobic and confusing, but she eventually found her way to 402. She'd been there a million times but always had to check to be sure. There was little to no variance in the halls, the doors, the layout; it felt almost surreal. The faint sound of music could be heard, however, so she must have been there. She reached up and knocked on the rather plain door.
'Come on in!' a voice excitedly replied.
She entered the apartment to find everyone gathered in the small kitchenette. Her partner was sitting at the kitchen island, back to her while across the counter from them sat the voice that welcomed her in. A young couple, in their mid 20s, they had been friends for a few years now, some of the only close friends her and her partner had made since moving to the city.
'Ouu, look at you!' exclaimed Sara, 'Looking good miss!'
Smiling, Ally felt a boost of energy as the compliment lifted her. Her flannel flowed as she walked, tank-top tightly fitted around her chest, in her mind a perfect amount of cleavage visible.
'Damn babe.' her partner chimed in excitedly, spinning around in his seat to both greet and admire her. She slid onto a stool beside him as he welcomed her arrival with an arm around her waist.
Pleasantries and small talk weren't her forte, for someone as quiet as her, she preferred to be forward, albeit somewhat awkward in delivery. Tonight however, she displayed none of those signs, a confidence she wished followed her more often in life.
'You guys remember the game 'never have I ever?''
She asked this question with confidence, but anxiety about what they'd think quickly brought her back down. They were in their late 20s after all and it was quite a juvenile game, but to her surprise Sara replied with a chuckle:
'I mean, yeah, as a kid, but never have I ever played it as an adult.'
'You should! ' Ally replied, rather excitedly.
'And you should drink up then!'
She looked at her, confused, then caught on as she noticed the smirk on her face.
'You whore... ' was her reply as she grabbed a red cup, then paused for a second as she looked over the choices of alcohol.
'Take your pick!' replied Sara, 'plenty to go around'
It was an easy choice as saw a bottle of Patrón and filled her glass. She needed that confidence back, but also knew the connotation associated with tequila...
'Guess I'll go next' chimed Matt. 'Never have I ever... thought I'd be playing this game at 28' he chuckled and preemptively raised a beer in salute.
That brought a smile from them all. He put his back down and gestured at the drinks on the table.
'Whatchu guys want?' asked Matt as he pried the tab open on his beer, a double IPA and took a drink.
'Hmm... ' Sara looked over her options. The table had an array of choices, beer so light it may as well be in a water bottle, craft beer that apparently Matt loved, cider, always popular vodka coolers, the tequila Ally made her own, and some wine.
She pondered for a second before grabbing a vodka cooler and taking a sip.
'Mango pineapple, good choice.' noted Luca. He deliberated for a second before grabbing a cider and cracking the top. 'Heard good things about this, I'll give it a try.'
Who's next? Ally asked, eager to get the game going.
'I think that'd be you, miss.' Matt suggested, as he gave Sara a playful nudge. She took a second to ponder options, thinking as she spoke
'Never have I ever... hmm.. been arrested.' stated Sara.
She threw a curious glance around the table, everyone's suspicious eyes darting from person to person, before Matt reached for his drink.
'Ouu, bad boy over here, what'd you do?' Sara asked, teasingly.
'I spray painted a big blue dick on a sign...' replied Matt with a snicker.
'Tryin' to compensate for something eh there?' teased Sara.
That brought an eye roll from Matt, but everyone's attention had quickly shifted.
'Do I tell them... that summer I got caught... ' thought Ally, her hand restlessly tapping the table, slowly inching towards her drink.
'Do we have another criminal in our presence?' joked Sara,
Early in their relationship, they found themselves parked in a secluded area, a pretty normal thing for young couples lusting for each other, and one thing lead to another. It was late, dark, and they were completely lost in each other. Maybe it was the fogged up windows, maybe the fact they were the only car in this otherwise empty lot, but they got quickly interrupted by a sharp knock on the window.
They scrambled to slide back into clothes and cover themselves up how ever possible. Long story short, it was indeed a cop and he was just doing rounds, maybe proving the ACAB label, maybe just trying to keep tabs on the neighbourhood. They ended up getting a stern talking to, and a promise to avoid any trouble if they just left, but this was closer than she thought she'd get.
She looked at her partner with a bit of a guilty eye. He shot her a puzzled look, before the light-bulb turned on and he smirked.
'We didn't get arrested though, ' he whispered to her.
This was the main thing, he was right there. Just a warning. But she had thought about that constantly. She was the one who wanted to go for the drive, who made the move. Did she want to get caught by the cops? Not particularly, but the thrill of being out in public had her beyond the point of no return once he acknowledged her intent.
She laid her hand back down, a slightly disappointed look coming across her face.
Sara was looking at her intently, 'Ohh, maybe we do have one over here, hmm'?
Ally looked down, then spilled the details. Sara and Matt laughed;
'Happened to us too, a few times to be honest. Once was a cop, but a few close calls with randoms.'
Matt recalled the time when he was in the back with Sara, parked alongside a public trail, only to look up and make awkward eye contact with a man out with his dog.
'Did he catch on to what was going on?' asked Ally, her curiosity piqued.
'Uh, I don't know, he kinda just gave friendly smile and kept walking his dog...'
'Ahh... ' Ally's voice trailed off as she looked back at Matt and then Luca.
She secretly wished there was more to the story. She slid her hand over Luca's thigh as she gestured with her eyes discretely. The subject matter had began to take her mind into somewhat naughty waters, and she hoped her subtle actions could do the same to his.
'Do you guys wanna move this to the living room? It's a bit more comfortable over there than these hard stools...'
'Yeah, sure, make yourselves at home. We'll be over there in a sec.' replied Sara.
They got up from the kitchen and made their way over to the couch, placing their drinks on the coffee table as they settled into the low, well worn couch. Ally sat down and laid against Luca, almost melting into her partner. She began to slide her hand across her partners thigh. Noticing it, he grabbed a blanket laying over the armrest and tried to cover her move, subtly, but
'Hey guys, keep it PG over there...'
That statement had Ally tingling, yet she was torn, knowing if she let her inhibitions she'd be far beyond PG, but she was also with friends, and was it really the time or place...
Sara and Matt returned to join them, Matt sitting sit down on the floor across the coffee table from them and Sara finding comfort in a beanbag chair.
Shall we continue? 'Earth to Ally, you with us'?
Ally was still lost in her mind, and finding it hard to contain herself.
'Never have I ever had a fantasy I hadn't told my partner' she blurted out, biting her lip gently in the process.
Everyone looked at each other, suspiciously, then, Ally reached for her cup. This brought a curious look from her partner...
'Babe'?, Luca replied in surprise.
'Nothing, it's nothing, I'll tell you later...' replied Ally, somewhat defensively.
'Ally come on, what is ittt?' begged Luca.
Ally looked down. He seemed oblivious to the hand creeping under the blanket laid across Luca's lap.
Sara, sensing the tension, took that moment;
'Hey guys. I gotta pee, I'll be right back'.
She got up, and Matt, not wanting to awkwardly third wheel, headed to the kitchen.
'Babe, you can tell me...'
She looked away, shyly and took a long drink.
He gave her a reassuring glance.
Do you remember that time last summer, when your friend uh, caught us...
Her partner paused a second in thought, remembering the time when he thought they were alone in the apartment only to have their roommate walk up behind them while they were rather uh, busy, on the couch.
'Yeah, I do, what about it?'
She pondered how to word it, nervously piecing together her reply. This was something she'd often thought about, but didn't want to be judged.
Welll... I kinda... uh.. I didn't mind...'
Her partners eyes widened.
'But... you were first to cover us up, to blush, to try to cover things up...' Luca retorted.
'I didn't wanna make things weird...'
She noticed his wrap around her.
'You wanted her to see... didn't you...?
'I.. uh.. maybe I...' she replied, blushing. He began to slide his hand down, cupping her breast and giving it a light squeeze.
'Luca is now really the...' he cut her off with a kiss.
She could sense he was beginning to understand made Ally's mind tick, but she needed the confidence yet. She poured out a sizable amount of tequila and chugged it all, firmly placing the empty cup back on the table before returning a very seductive gaze back to Luca. Right at that moment Matt reappeared, a large bowl of chips in his hands.
'I thought you guys might want a snack'
He slid the bowl across the coffee table offered to them, but they were already lost in each other.
'Never have I ever walked in on my friends getting it on...' he said, sarcastically.
Ally heard everything, and received it with a smile as she leaned in and kissed him deeply. He welcomed it, his coming to rest on her lower back as the made out passionately.
'Get a room would ya?' sneared Matt, chuckling.
Ally looked into her partners eyes, and in that moment she knew she couldn't keep it a secret any longer.
'What if we don't want to, Matt...'
Whether it was escalating tension in the games of never have you ever, that had upped the tension to an uncontrollable level, the alcohol, or the thought of the fantasy finally playing out, she simply couldn't contain herself any more.
'...what if the thought of being watched turns me on...?' she replied with a devious smile.
She slid her leg over his lap, straddling him as her lips found his in a suffocating embrace. Luca's hands grabbed her chest as Ally's facial expressions told Matt everything.
She exhumed as his touch had her breathless. Her eyes rolled back as she fully let the ecstasy of the moment wash over her. He toyed with her chest, teasing fingers over her nipples, now clearly poking through the thin cotton.
Matt sat in silence for a second, unsure of how to respond to that. What would Sara think? He raised his drink to his lips and took a big drink.
He looked back at them, still lost in each other, Lucas now under her shirt, hands full.
Ally was fully in the moment now, drunk with the thought of fantasy or just drunk she wasn't sure. She playfully leaned and fell down again into the couch beside him, knowing full well her secret was now out.
'Hey Matt' she asked. He looked up from his phone to see Ally holding her shirt up, tits fully exposed. Luca laughed, and reached for his can of cider.
He gave it a shake as he picked it up, nearly empty. He looked at Ally, lost in her moment of exhibitionism, and began to lift himself up off the couch.
'I'm gonna grab another drink, anyone want anything?'
He lifted himself off the couch to stand and she seized her moment. Readjusting herself from a seated position to her knees she reached up and grabbed the waist of his pants, pulling herself closer to the prize she knew she wanted.
'I might...' she said with a smirk, eyes meeting his. Her friends partner sat there, eyes wide as this came as quite a surprise despite the nature of the game they were quite engrossed in.
He looked at her, shocked, but she paid no mind to it. She ran her fingertips over the crotch of his jeans. The outline of his cock was visible through his jeans. She knew his uncertainty was bullshit. He wanted this just as much as she did.
Matt sat there, silent at first, still most likely trying to process what had unfolded so quickly.
'Never have I ever thought I'd watch my friend getting a blowjob...' he said under his breath as he looked up at them again, then picked up his phone, thinking it best to distract himself rather than feel like a creep... but he just couldn't look away...
Teasing her fingers up the shape of him, she turned towards her audience of one and smiled, giving a subtle nod.
He was somewhat still in awe of what had transpired, fixated on the scene unfolding before his eyes, completely lost for words.
She smirked as her two hands worked on his jeans to unbutton the fly, but the work was almost done for her with how much his dick was straining. She made quick work of the button and quickly slid the zipper pull down, the subject of her lust now only a thin layer of fabric away.
For Luca, time seemed to stand still while all of this took place. Maybe nerves, but he seemed to be at the mercy of her touch. Lost in the moment, this was lust in the moment as he felt himself throb.
'Holy fuck, is this really happening'? he thought as she slowly teased the waist band away and down, revealing him in a rather dramatic fashion.
That reveal came back to reality.
'Okay my cock is fully out in front of my partners friend.. what the fuck...'
The thought raced through his mind somewhat unbelievably as all the blood in his body was currently in one place. He glanced over at Matt, sitting on the floor across from him, the only thing keeping him from being fully in view was his partners head, now level with his waist.
She slowly reached up and teased her finger up the underside of his shaft, then slid her hand around and began to stroke his cock. He filled her hand, maybe even more so now, veins throbbing.
'Holy fuck, where did this side of her come from...?', he thought, in between sighs of pleasure. Would she? He knew if she did he'd cum immediately...
She slowly stuck out her tongue mimicking a lick, then kissed the swollen tip of his dick. Looking up at him to enjoy his reaction, she slowly eased it past the head with every bob of her head, inch by inch in her mouth until her nose touched his stomach. His hands naturally found themselves in her wavy blonde hair while she played, both teasing it from her face and toying with it, trying to find a way to express the pleasure building from her touch, all the while pushing her for more.
Completely overcome by lust at this point she wrapped her hands around him, doing the job he had began and pulled him as deep as humanly possible down her throat, then pulled away completely, strings of saliva stretching between her lips and his balls as she gasped for breath.
'Yeah Ally, god damn...!'
She froze, deer in the headlights. Sara and Matt were standing at the kitchen island, watching them intently.
Ally had been so caught up their fun that she hadn't noticed Matt get up and leave...
'Sara? I thought you were gone? ' she mentioned in a confused tone.
Sara laughed before she replied;
'Gone? Matt texted me that you guys were having a bit too much fun.., and I was curious'
'I, welll.. we... uh yeah...' She looked up at Luca who looked back at her with a smile before finishing her thought.
'...we got a little carried away. You were gone, Matt was on his phone... We couldn't help it..'
'Hey, it's all good, we enjoyed the show', Sara replied, smoothing out any tension with a sly smile.
I think were going to call it a night though.'
Ally looked at the clock on the wall, ' Jeez, 11pm already,'
'Time flies when you're having fun I guess' Sara cheekily replied
Ally wiped the spit from her lips, grabbing a hold of her partners arm as he lifted her to her feet.
'That it does, yeah.' She paused for a second, lost in thought as the magnitude of what just unfolded hit her.
'I guess we'll uh, head out now...', she stated,
They headed back through the kitchen, to the front entry way, Lucas fixing his pants as they walked.
Sara and Matt followed close behind, the events of the night seemingly in Luca's mind as Matt noticed him wrap his arm around her, lower even than just a friendly embrace.
'Thanks for coming over guys, maybe we'll do it again...'
Sara then watched as Lucas opened the door and stepped out into the hallway. Ally paused when she heard her name.
'Never have I ever thought you had that in you...'
Ally smirked as she walked through the door knowing this was just the beginning.