Karen Page is Daredevilâs next big villain, and thereâs nothing you can do about it (a.k.a. Give Me My Spin-Off Show Damn It Netflix)
Itâs about ten hours until Daredevilâs second season will be released in all its glory on Netflix, and Iâm here to talk about a theory/want/burning passion thatâs been steadily brewing ever since Karen Page shot James Wesley six times in the fucking chest.Â
The theory is this: Karen Page is Daredevilâs next villain.
And when I say âtheoryâ, I more mean âplot twist that I really, really wantâ; a theory would suggest I have literally any evidence to back it up.
Recently, the Daredevil cast participated in a Talk at Google in which, arguably, Deborah Ann Woll went off. One of the high-lights was when each actor was asked about their characterâs weakness. All of a sudden, Deborah stopped talking about Karen Page and started talking about herself and womenâs relationship with power in an industry which is pretty awful to women.
Which makes sense because, when you think about it, Karen Page slots unfortunately into a space most women in telefantasy reside. Think about Doctor Who, where the Doctor casually decided not to tell Amy Pond that she was not only pregnant, but also a fake copy of her actual self until she was literally giving birth. âCause, you know. Who needs to hear that? Or in Misfits, where Superhoodie a.k.a. Future Simon a.k.a. (letâs be real here) Hot Simon failed to tell Alicia she had to let him die until the very last minute.
Itâs probably one of my least favourite tropes in telefantasy, because it places male characters in a position of narrative power over their female counter-parts. Itâs yet another way to provide a male character dominance over a female character who is usually side-lined to B-plots and the position of slightly useless love interest, existing to serve and continue a male characterâs storyline and his Angsty Man Angst.
I wrote last year about how Daredevil was changing the face of the superhero genre, largely through its portrayal of male fragility and the way it treats its female characters. And then, of course, we got Jessica Jones which (sorry, Daredevil) blew it out of the fucking park. Itâs one of the feminist shows Iâve seen, and if you havenât seen it just go sort your life out, honestly â but with new show-runners and a new female villain, Iâm worried Daredevilâs second season will slip back into lazy tropes; a Sexy⢠Female Villain and a depressing kind of competitiveness between two women that we see over and over and over on television because they both have the hots for the same guy.
But perhaps the most worrying aspect of Daredevilâs second series is that Karen Page is still in the dark about Daredevilâs identity, six months on. But, as Deborah Ann Woll pointed out, Karen is keeping two big secrets from Matt and Foggy. The first, of course, is that she straight up killed James Wesley. The secondâŚ
Whatâs the second, Deborah? Whatâs the second?
Iâm sure, this season, weâll find out. Thereâs been hints to Karen Pageâs dark past in series one, and in this season we see her âfascinatedâ by the Punisher.
So, in the words of Miley Cyrus, what does it mean?Â
To me, it means that Marvel should be setting Karen Page up as the next big, bad villain for Matt Murdock to face off against.
Think about it. Youâve suffered a traumatic event and are accused of murder when two white knights swoop in and saved you. They give you a job. They become like family to you. Theyâre the only friends you have.
And then you get kidnapped, and you murder a guy
The city falls apart around you, you sort of want to bang Matt Murdock but you also want to bang this mysterious superhero who occasionally rocks up and saves your life. You help your friends save Hellâs Kitchen. Six months fly by. You get closer and closer to Matt, until finally â
You discover that your two best friends have been lying to you. Not only have they been lying to you, theyâve kept a secret from you in order to protect you. Protect you in a way every man in your life has tried to protect you, as if you canât protect yourself. As if you canât do what needs to be done.
So you start trying to prove yourself. If Matt Murdock can be a vigilante hero, why canât you? You study Daredevil â but you study the Punisher too. And you start to wonder if maybe heâs not wrong. Maybe all people are inherently bad, and maybe when theyâre put down they need to stay down. Corrupt local governments, who lie. Your friends â who lie. Yourself â maybe youâre the worst of all.
And suddenly itâs a year later and Karen Page is running the seedy underbelly of Hellâs Kitchen in a power suit and then we get the spin-off series Iâve dreamed about for so long, where Claire Temple and Trish Walker team up to bring Karen Page in and itâs amazing and I cry a lot.
Which, as we all know, would be AWESOME.
Not just because the idea of Claire Temple and Trish Walker watching their superhero besties and deciding they want to do much of the same thing (albeit a little reluctantly on Claireâs part, no doubt) would be fucking amazing. But because when Deborah talked about Karen, and talked about power and impotence, she didnât really seem all that upset. No. She seemed angry. And if youâre a young woman, I can without a doubt say youâve felt that impotence and that resulting anger countless times. If you havenât yet, itâs probably on its way. If you never do, youâre incredibly lucky.
But I rarely get to see that anger on screen. I see the impotence all the time, all the times male characters have decided they know whatâs best and kept female characters in the dark, giving themselves the perfect opportunity to swoop in and save them later. But the fall-out â the anger â usually lasts an episode or so. It rarely gets the repercussions it deserves; as a viewer, I rarely get the satisfaction of seeing my anger played out in a way male viewers get with every single shitty action movie in the world. I donât get that. As a female viewer, I get the woman on the side in spandex and heels, making eyes at the male hero. If Iâm lucky, I might get Black Widow in The Winter Soldier, kissing Steve for no good reason but at least with some sense of agency and power in the narrative. For every one hundred male-centric fantasies splashed out across the screens, I get one Rey in The Force Awakens, or one Jessica Jones. But I want to see all the anger and hurt Deborah Ann Woll spilled out in a Talk at Google on my television screen. Like, right now.
And, to be honest, I just really want my Karen Page-Trish Walker-Claire Temple spin-off show. Come on, Netflix. Donât be a dick. Â