Deja vu! ... or haven't we seen this standoff before?
I haven't had a good rant about things politic here for a while, so I guess its high time! I've been standing by with a partial lean-in of the ear while the lastest public sector bargaining debacle unfolds ... or that epic battle the Teachers vs. the Government.
Albeit, the media has dubbed it the Teachers vs the Liberal Party (yes, the whole darn party seems tarnished on this round, not just Christy Clark), perhaps because Minister George Abbot has been deemed the most effective spokesmodel for government on this one.
A bit of backstory here ... labour relations in BC have always hit a nerve, particularly public sector labour relations. Things have at various times escalated to such a fevered pitch, that more times than not, negotiated settlements are completely out of the question, and the whole lot ends up going to arbitration.
That is one of my pet peeves about the current mainstream media coverage, is little has been said about the fact that the teachers have NEVER had a negotiated settlement in the history of public sector bargaining in this province. I am NOT, by any stretch of the imagination a rabid liberal stormtrooper, BUT it does not help temper the hotheads to single out one administration, when no political party of any persuasion has been able to crack this nut! It would suggest to me, that the process is more flawed than the positions of the parties on either side of this negotiation.
Lets look at the facts facing each side:
Teachers are working hard: class sizes have not diminished appreciably, and most teachers are facing additional workload as they cope with an increased number of kids deemed special needs.
Province-wide solutions for the most part, address average situations, and most school districts are NOT facing average situations -- many are experiencing declining enrolments, with threats of school closures, and others are experiencing unprecedented growth, and unable to find enough room for their students.
School districts are cash strapped and having to pare programming down to the bone to balance budgets -- those who don't are threatened with firing by the province! It means that while school board trustees may be sympathetic, they can only afford to be sympathetic up to a point.
Parents want more for their kids in terms of educational programming, and are getting pissed off because the programs that keep their kids interested and engaged in learning are being slowly phased out, given they are not considered "core" education.
Teachers are citizens too, and its getting expensive to live!
Government has one hell of a fiscal challenge in the near-mid term! it has declared that net-zero positioning on all public sector contracts is the only way that costs can be contained.
There are many more public sector unions standing in line behind the teachers. If a settlement allowing more for the teachers is approved, it sets precedent for all the other unions.
There is a degree of face-saving on the part of government here that plays out in a PR sense, but with very real fiscal effects. If government is seen to be unable to manage its public sector unions, it makes attracting foreign business investment that much harder (oh, I should bring my $XXX billions to your province, but I might not be able to ship my product offshore because the railroad workers are striking in solidarity with the teachers?!).
George Abbot has essentially called the teachers spoiled brats (in not so many words) - he indicated the Teachers were the ONLY public sector union they have been unable to have productive discussions with. (Personally, I find it hard to believe they have had some 70 odd meetings without any progress whatsoever - if so, a little switcheroo of whoever is repping the government side might be in order!)
Someone asked me the other day what I thought would play out, and here's my 2c worth:
I think the government has folks scrambling around in the Ministry of Labour and the Premier's Office ready for about 3 or 4 scenarios to unfold.
I think the teachers may walk off the job for a couple of days (with or without the blessing of the Labour Relations Board), and will be legislated back to work. Government will make a couple of minor adjustments to the deal, and present what will be another version of the net-zero offer.
Teachers will go back to work (bell to bell), possibly with a short walkout or two. An arbitrator will be selected, who will provide a synopsis of the horrific dynamics between the two sides, and speculate that final offer arbitration might lead to a general strike.
Ultimately the teachers will take the deal -- for no other reason than they are the ones who have to live in the communities they are taking job action in. They are the ones who have to look parents, principles and vice-principles in the eye while at the supermarket! They also all know the history (and repeated history) on this one! And ultimately, I think they care more about the kids than government does ...
From the peanut gallery, 'til next time!