TL;DR:Last Ditch Apologies
I understand if you want nothing to do with this or me, and this isn’t for attention or to try and “fix things” or be friends again or whatever.. but I’ve realized over the years that there’s a lot that feels like (to me) “unfinished business” and I can’t help but feel crazy because I think about this way too often. It’s so stupid that I’m fixated on this one stupid period of time in my life, but I seriously can’t let myself keep obsessing. This is my last ditch effort (what even does that phrase mean?) to try, at least, to make peace with you, with myself and with my mistakes. And if it helps you too in any way, all the better.
Let me start off by saying you’re not the only person I’m writing to. I can’t stress enough that my intent isn’t to “win” you back or to make you feel bad or to ask for forgiveness. I’ve got a nasty habit of just pretending certain issues aren’t real until I realize it’s too late to fix anything. (Flight instead of fight, I guess..) I’ll soon be facing some serious issues with my family and I’m doing what I can to alleviate as much outside anxiety before things really get icky. I’m doing my best to be conscious of how I’m feeling through this process and make sure I don’t end up in whatever terrible pit I was in for so long. These things have been weighing on me for years and even if you don’t ever read any of this, at least it’s not all just buried in my chest anymore.
TL;DR: Last Ditch Apologies
I can’t tell you what happened to me when we broke up. There are parts I don’t remember correctly and that there are gaps that either I purposely blocked out or blacked out during. And there are so many things that I’ve learned since but for obvious reasons.. I can’t thank you or even apologize. And even though I know we’ve both moved on, and I’m sure you don’t even care (it’s been what... 6 years?) I hope the opportunity arises someday anyway. Not necessarily for reconciliation (I think that door’s long since closed..) but for my own sanity.
For a long time, I refused to believe that our separation was my fault. You made a good effort to make it seem like it was best for both of us. And I agreed, although I felt very blindsided. I knew there were things you were unhappy about.. I thought moving closer would fix them. (It took me months to really understand what you meant and by then, you had found someone else and your reasons didn’t make sense to me anymore.)
I shut you out on purpose pretty quickly.. I couldn’t handle “mourning” and trying to talk with you through it. You came over a few days after the fact (I think.. my time line gets pretty jumbled that summer..) and explained to me that you’d always be my best friend, that you’d always be there for me, that you’d always love me. I believed you, but I couldn’t believe it either. Those things were exactly what I wanted to hear, but I didn’t understand why you were still giving me hope. You asked me at some point after That Day if I thought you were doing the right thing. Of course, I didn’t. I didn’t say it though, I thought the right thing to do was to let you make up your own mind. I didn’t want you to change your mind because I influenced you somehow, I wanted you to change your mind because it was what you wanted. I thought that was why we broke up, we were making decisions more based off each other, and less of our own personal interests. I didn’t realize that it would come off as me not willing to help you or fight for you. I’d give anything to take that back.
It never occurred to me that, at that time, you may have been just as emotionally reliant on me as I was you.. and that breaking up wasn’t an easy decision for you and that maybe you needed help or still wanted to feel loved, it just wasn’t the time for something as demanding as what we had. And that’s my fault. I’m sorry I wasn’t there, that I wasn’t supportive, and that I, per uge, made the whole thing about me. Not just with our breakup but with the entire time we knew each other.
I wasn’t a drinker outside of Iowa City. I drank when I lived in that house, and then after when I was visiting you and I’d get sooo messy and embarrassing and for that, I am so sorry. I tried keeping up, it felt like I was supposed to. Your friends all seemed so... seasoned. You seemed disappointed when I got high.. and we always talked about being on the same “level” so, I thought I needed to drink for that to happen. After we broke up, it seemed like the only way I could be distracted was to drink. I felt guilty smoking and I eventually got busted anyway so... after my roommate moved and I had to move in with my dad (again) I thought I had lost everything.
A couple months went by and I moved to Iowa City and I started drinking a ton. I originally made plans to move so I could be closer to you, closer to being how I wanted to be and live how I wanted to live. Obviously Cedar Rapids sucks but what I don’t think you realized when you said “We’re too young to spend all of our time focused on another person” is that I had a whole other life there. I had a job and friends and I was finishing school and I had started dancing again.. I was broke, but I felt more successful than I’d ever been and when you said that was the reason we shouldn’t be together... it just didn’t make sense to me. When we broke up I realized I didn’t care about all that. When I moved, I realized it didn’t matter if I cared about all that or not because I simply didn’t have any of it anymore. I left it behind thinking I was moving forward, starting a new chapter. But when it came time to actually move, it felt like I was moving into a snake pit or something. Everyone I knew there was a friend of yours, they were untouchable. I gravitated towards strangers because everyone I knew personally was a reminder of how much I was fucking up.
It’s not that I didn’t try at all.. I’ve got the drawings, the paintings, the journals, I wanted so badly to get better. To get “over” it. I didn’t know how, and I thought I needed to do it on my own. I heard so many rumors.. “he never loved you,” “you were just a game” or “he dumped you so he could sleep around..” You and I met up at a coffee shop a couple months after I moved. I was so excited to catch up, I thought it was a move in the right direction, and at that point, personal things were starting to fall into place (friends, work, etc..) I mentioned that my roommate had gone on a date with the girl who lived in your house, that she left her bracelet in my apartment. You told me that you and her were together now. I was obviously surprised and later pretty sad.. but overall I appreciated that you told me in person. We hugged, you said we’d catch up again soon and I was happy to have made progress. JP told me later that you thought the meetup was a disaster. I didn’t believe him and texted you to ask if we could communicate directly, hearing things from other people was messing with me and I didn’t know what was true and what wasn’t. Your response was “I don’t know what you’re trying to do here.”
Years later, he apologized for purposely meddling. He said he recognized that he made things worse. I leaned on him the most because I thought he understood the situation better than anyone... I didn’t realize how unhappy he also was at the time. He was constantly reminding me of you, because it made him feel closer to me. Being sad turned into being a raging bitch and I couldn’t trust anyone to help me. Every time I saw someone who knew you, even my own friends, I got self-conscious. I couldn’t get it out of my head that everyone was pitying me or judging me or just straight up thought I was a fuck up. I had never had a broken heart before, and honestly I had never been in the position where I needed to take care of myself, emotionally. I always had a crutch. I didn’t realize how much I was putting on other people until I didn’t have anyone anymore.
I know the situation changed when I started drinking.. but in my mind, you had made a lot of promises you weren’t keeping. Every day I didn’t hear from you just buried that idea deeper. I said something to you once about how I wished we hadn’t dated. And in a way, I meant it. Not the way I said it.. I’m sure I said it out of spite but what I meant was I regretted that our friendship was ruined. I blamed it on us breaking up instead of blaming it on myself apparently having no self-control.
I have dreams, pretty frequently, where you’re just there. And everything is alright, like there’s some “we were emotional and too young” sort of statute of limitations that ran its course. You’re too far away for that ever to even be a possibility. Anyway. I wrote the majority of this post months ago and just found it in my drafts. So before I try to re-write everything or just start rambling, I’ll finish it with this:
I’m not upset that we’re not together anymore, or that we broke up. I understand why those things happened (although it took me years to work it out) and I’m fine. What I’m really sad about (still) is that back then, I knew who I wanted to be... but I had no idea how to become that person. I thought moving would be what pushed me over the edge to being who/how I wanted to be (who/how I thought you wanted me to be.) The breakup, and your reasons for the breakup, turned me into a giant ball of self-doubt. And I think that was what was/is/will forever be so hard.. I had never experienced self-doubt.. I always thought I was doing everything I could and that it would be enough.
I haven’t felt like I was enough, since you. The self-doubt has never gone away. It’s this little smoking pit that sits in my chest. In a way, it feels like my innocence was stolen. I feel shame, and fear, and anxiety, about everything. It’s not hard to pretend I don’t feel that way, but occasionally it isn’t so easy to bury. I hate feeling dramatic and crazy, but it really does just feel like a sandstorm in my brain sometimes. And the worst part is, I AM who I wanted myself to be back then. I’ve gotten myself to be conscious and hard working, and empathetic and helpful. I am a good employee, a (relatively) healthy person who cares about the earth and nutrition and quality over quantity. And I guess I just really wish you knew.