The Summer I Turned Pretty is a beautiful and complex story of grief, first loves, young love, and insecurity. It's fun to decide what team you're on and talk about how Belly is indecisive, but I think we're missing the bigger picture here. I find that many lovers of the books and television series are often too focus on this "love triangle," myself included at times, but I have to remind myself and everyone else, that this is more than just a love triangle. Honestly, it's not even a story about a love triangle.
The Summer I Turned Pretty is a story about a young girl, Belly, who is insecure. Insecure about the way she looks, insecure about her intelligence, and insecure about her place in the world. And this story is about how one's insecurities can mold one's relationships, for better or for worse. The Summer I Turned Pretty is also a story about a young boy, Conrad, and his brother, Jeremiah, as they navigate the plights of adulthood. This growing pains that they both go through is intensified as they deal with the sickness and death of their beloved mother, Susannah Beck. They are left to navigate a world without their biggest supporter. As the stories of Belly, Conrad and Jeremiah evolve, we see a beautiful love story also take shape.
This story is about Belly and Conrad, and how love can take shape in many ways. It's about how feeling insecure about yourself can seriously impact your place in a relationship. It's about how grief, depression, and anxiety can be its own person in a relationship. It's about the bravery in recognizing how grief and depression can be all encompassing and can consume one’s life, and how taking a step back in a relationship to focus on mental health can be beneficial to all involved even if it's hurts. It's about taking accountability. It's about how love is deep and precious and something to fight for.
This is not to say that Jeremiah and his story and his feelings are not important. They are valid, especially his feelings of having to compete with his brother which derive from his relationship to his father. What I'm saying is that though Jeremiah has a large presence in this book and series, that does not make this story about him. He is not, and was never the main focus of this story. The idea of "teams" does not exist because it was never about who loved whom more or who is the better brother or whatever else. It's a story about how two young people find their way to each other against all odds; against feeling not good enough, against the crippling feelings of fear and depression, against feeling as if you do not deserve love, feeling that you are incapable of being loved and being in love.
That's why I love this story so much. That's why I hold this story so near and dear to my heart and why I constantly defend it. It's not as surface level as people make it out to be.
Edit: Jenny Han liked and commented on my TikTok that reiterated this post!