Warrior Cats: Into the Wild; Thoughts and Snark
0.) "\"But that seems foolish! Why can't the Clans work together and share their hunting grounds, instead of fighting each other?\" Firepaw suggested boldly."
Because the plot requires it Firepaw. The plot requires it.
All we need next is Warrior Cats fanfiction where the "International Feline Soviet" is established. Call it the "SovietClan" or something lol.
Imagine the cats singing The Internationale. (Perhaps this one: https://youtu.be/TVbwtiAkvCc?si=1HvcKnSyEFvU8u4C) The theme of communism being inevitable, even among talking cats in the realm of fantasy, is an interesting one. It would make for an interesting story! Well, atleast by my standards it would.
This story as is isn't really my "cup of tea". I'm really only doing it for Oliver lol. (Page 60)
1.) "There was no trace of the house cat in him now." Bruh, it has only been two days. Stop stroking your own dick Firepaw. (Page 82)
2.) "Firepaw smarted at the she-cat's words. Could she smell the scent of Twolegs on him, even now, after all this time?" Yes, because it's only been two days.
3.) Nikolai: "🎵Firepaw and Yellowfang sitting in a tree🎵 🎵K-I-L-L-I-N-G🎵"
I really hope this isn't some weird sort of romantic setup between Firepaw and Yellowfang, that would be cringe. My aromantic ass wants plot, not token gesture romance. (Page ~86)
4.) "He could smell the fear-scent on her." I'm pretty sure cats don't smell different when they get scared.
Regardless this "fear scent" thing is a really weird creative decision. Cats have body language, and we see that in the book, so why the addition of this "emotion smells" thing? (Page 89)
5.) Also this "she-cat" phrase. Why? Just WHY? Every single female cat in here has been referred to with "she-cat". The male characters don't get this: They don't get referred to with "he-cat". They just get referred to with "cat"!
I thought maybe it was a strange title at first, but no it's clearly gendered language. "She-cat" also just sounds weird. What's next? "They-cat"? Do enby cats get referred to with "they-cat"?
What a weird form of misogyny. (Various pages)
6.) "\"It's just to dangerous to bring an enemy warrior into the heart of ThunderClan! Now that she knows the camp, even the youngest ShadowClan kit will hear of it. We will have to move."
Not exactly the most natural of dialog. Regardless, doesn't all the clans know where the other clans are? I mean they know the placement of the borders, just trespass and locate the massive crowd of cats. All of this didn't come off to me as clandestine.
Also: How would the rest of ShadowClan know about this? Yellowfang presumably got kicked out or something. Also these are cats. They don't uh... Don't have any mobile phones or ham radios, you know what I mean? Communication is slow.
But assuming ShadowClan knows where the capitol of ThunderClan is..... WHO GIVES A SHIT!? This information isn't what I'd call "national security" worthy. No need to move. (Page 94)
7.) "Never before had one Clan driven another from its hunting grounds." Oh bullshit! And then what the fuck was that battle at the very beginning of the book for then? Shits-and-giggles? That was very blatantly an attempt to slurp up territory!
8.) "\"Usually she trains only the kits of deputies!\"" Mistook "trains" for "trans" which lowkey got me excited lol.
9.) "\"Firepaw, although you showed bad judgement in talking to a house cat." Um.... WHAT? God this is more dictatorial then the United States! Wtf would talking to a "house cat" do? Cause the destruction of the universe?
10.) How do the cats know about lions and leopards and stuff? It's clear the famous African big cats are being referenced but uh.... Those are in Africa, not North America. (Page ~145)
11.) The clan leader getting eight Totems of Undying.... How is this kept secret from the humans? The clan cat religion thing is a real thing in this world, so do the humans already know about it? If so, do human religions revolve around it? Do the major religions like Islam and Christianity deify cats?
12.) "We'll follow the warrior code, even if ShadowClan doesn't."
"Don't worry ladies, Israel signed the ceasefire! They won't attack!"
5 minutes later Israel attacks. (Page 169)
13.) I enjoy how smells play a role in both the narrative and world building!
14.) "You should hunt if you are hungry and then get some rest." DID YOU NOT JUST GO ON ABOUT THE WARRIOR CODE!? Specifically the thing of hunting on the land of other Clans? (Page 174)
15.) "The sun would be rising soon." The passage of time is so weird in this book. It only felt like five minutes! (Page 183)
16.) Oh so Bluestar chewed Firepaw a new asshole for talking to Smudge (is that his name?) but here she's talking Barley. Fucking hypocrite. (Page 183)
17.) "\"Rats!\" spat Tigerclaw. \"Barley has sent us into a trap!\""
Lol, just be glad this isn't my Rats of NIMH fanfiction Tigerclaw. You'd be facing rats armed with submachine guns there. Would be riddled with bullets in about a minute!
(Rats are small. Can't carry much! They also don't have much strength to resist recoil. As such the Army of NIMH has SMGs with low fire rates!)
Barley supposedly sending them into a trap of rats is odd, isn't it? Did BrokenStar promise Barley a beer or something? (Page 185)
18.) "\"He's wanted to be deputy ever since he took care of Redtail-\"" Oh screw you. Dumb plot twist, I don't like it. (Page 199)
19.) "The warriors looked hungry and battle-scarred, but Firepaw could see the hard muscles pounding beneath their patchy fur."
Yeah that's not how mammals work. Muscles are expensive, and they're one of the first bits of tissue the body will break down during starvation.
You can't be both malnourished and jacked at the same time. (Page 259)
20.) So ShadowClan is filled with scrawny weak cats..... Then how the shit did they launch that attack against ThunderClan? You can't sustain a war if your people are starving and weak.
21.) "\"ThunderClan warriors do not kill unless they have to,\" he growled in Firepaw's ear. \"We just need to let them know not to show their faces here again!\"" Ah yes, just give the murder happy cat a warning bite. What could go wrong? (Page 260)
22.) BOO!!! Should've killed Brokenstar when you had the chance!